Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

They are 20 and 21 respectively. They spent seven and eight years in the WT system, only to be discarded.

For WT to think that recruiting mercenaries at the end of their careers makes more sense is absolutely ludicrous.
If the mercenaries are better players and are replacing players that haven’t set the world on fire when given opportunities, then decisions have to be made. As I said, let’s see if they develop in WA, if not the right decision was made.
 
Don't reply to me. Problem solved.

That's good advice - people's opinions are just that, not a declaration of war or personal insult (unless meant that way)
 
You have convinced me.

My initial thought was similar. There is little between Madden and Fogarty in terms of playing style and playing ability. In a fairly miserable 2026 season one of the positives was the combination between Jock and Adam. I thought they played great together and we won 3 out of 4 with those two in the halves.
I get the sentiment on this line of thinking in that Madden is a similar style of player as Fogarty, but saying they're basically a like for like is a pretty big stretch. Since Fogarty debuted in 2020, he's made the finals as a starting halfback more times than he's missed them. Jock, by contrast, has never made the finals as a starting 7 and has never really even locked down a starting half role. And I like Jock, don't get me wrong. But Fogarty is much more of a proven commodity than Jock is and that's why we'd be bringing him on board if we do end up signing him. Also, in defence of Fogarty's age, like Cody Walker, the guy debuted in his late 20s so he doesn't quite have the mileage that a 33-year-old who debuted at 19 or 20 would have. I'm all for the signing.
 
If the mercenaries are better players and are replacing players that haven’t set the world on fire when given opportunities, then decisions have to be made. As I said, let’s see if they develop in WA, if not the right decision was made.
What? They are juniors that spent multiple years in our system.

Could the problem possibly be our system?
 
Back
Top