Sin-binning

[Sabre]

anyone else think Marshalls sin-bining was a bit harsh, no guarentee at all that Souths would have scored.

But, what about Burgess in about the 8th Minute. We were over the line and he made an offside tackle to save it. Thats a prime example of a professional foul, why wasn't he binned?

 

[Balmain_Tiger]

marshall knew the risk..i dont think any referee wouldnt of awarded the sin binning.

 

[Marshall_magic]

Doesn't need to be a guarantee of scoring, it was a professional foul not a penalty try. Correct call I thought, we would have been scrambling to get back onside, but the penalty gave us a huge advantage.

 

[southerntiger]

Deserved to go to the bin as did Burgess

 

[Juro]

Yeah, I was wondering what constitutes a professional foul. We see all the time, players getting binned for holding a player down who has made a big break. What other deliberate penalties could a player be sent off for?

 

[Spartan117]

Game was in the bag, I didnt mind an early shower for Benji.

He is a star and i dont mind a little less risk when he is involved.

 

[BIG_AL]

No doubt Burgess should have been binned.