Spine against the Warriors

[watersider]

That was the worst 1,6, 7, 9 performance I've seen for a long time. Brooks was the least bad of them, but they were horribly out of sorts: mbye running across field, never putting the foot down, Doueihi ponderous and confused, Brooks not organising, Liddle stutter step nowhere and not able to release the ball. Terrible defense from Liddle and Doueihi as well. That was insipid, directionless, wasteful play. I get the teams not good, but Madge has to take blame for the collective ineptitude as well.

 

[happy_tiger]

When Laurie goes down the smart call was Mbye to 6 ...Douehi to 1 .....

 

[watersider]

I was happy with Mbye moving to 1, I just think they should have played better.

 

[boonboon]

Spine was horrible. Our outside backs were i thought good, our backrowers were good our starting props and lock were good but our soine was horriffic and our bench forwards non existent.

 

[the_third]

I’m sure it been said, but we have shown no spine in that game.

Who played well

Who would play for us

It’s Pascoe up the board is a joke. Pascoe a joke. I don’t support a club to turn a profit makes me feel undervalued as a paid up (4X) member

 

[Sabre]

1 Cini
6 Doueihi
7 Brooks
9 Simpkin

Doueihi has to keep his spot, you can't drop him based on 1 game. Brooks can't be dropped either because there isn't really anyone to replace him with. I don't think Madden is up to it.

Liddle however, has to go. He isn't fit enough, makes poor decisions and has awful service dummy half.

With Laurie injured I'd like to see Cini get a go. He was doing a good job at fullback for the Magpies.

 

[Harvey]

Mbye is weak as.

His 20m bouncing pass to maumalo to avoid taking a kick return was disgraceful. He should be moved on or put on gardening leave.

 

[Needaname]

I think I’d be considering a spine next season of
1. Laurie 1
6. Mbye (left) 6
7. Hastings (right) 7
9. Simpkin 9

Doueihi back to centre. He can wonder in field if he wants to bomb other than that HE IS A RUNNER!

 

[YesHeCheeKam]

One of the worst spines in the NRL if not the worst. Tigers, Cows, Dogs (Who are at least fixing theirs) and Broncos. The four worst spines in the NRL and theres a reason they are where they are.

I think the biggest issue is the 9.Can't get us going forward in any capacity. I know Grant was an exception, but we just can't roll forward at all. He also to me is a 40 minute hooker. His just a body out there in the 2nd half.

 

[tigerap]

I had high hopes an injury free Liddle would finally deliver on his hype….he has been poor most games….not an 80 min player that’s for sure