Stuart fined.... again

tig_prmz

tig_prmz

Well-known member
15K for this

http://www.nrl.com/rd-15-press-conference-eels/tabid/10959/contentid/557221/default.aspx

The NRL will issue the Parramatta Eels with a breach notice outlining a $15,000 fine in relation to coach Ricky Stuart’s post-match comments.

The breach notice relates to Stuart’s comments at the post-match media conference regarding the performance of the on-field match officials as well as NRL Referees Elite Performance Manager Daniel Anderson.

“There are clear guidelines for coaches and officials in regards to commenting on decisions and they do not permit an attack on a match official’s character or integrity,” NRL General Manager of Football Operations, Mr Nathan McGuirk, said today.

“To question the competency of the match officials and the head of the referees in that manner is not acceptable.”

The Eels will have five working days to make submissions in relation to the breach notice.
 
Ricky wasn't in breach of any guidelines was he? He said that he disagreed with what they were doing, not their competency, not their character and not their integrity.

Bloody NRL.

That other rant was fair, 10k and he knew it but this is over the top.
 
Theyre so precious, Anderson & co.

I know its not an easy job, but you only need to go back as far as our last game, an error EVERYONE could see was wrong bar the fool with the whistle almost cost us a game

I dont agree with Stickys tactics, he needs to lead - but the refs association is accountable to no - one.
Thats wrong
 
I see nothing wrong with what Stuart said.
Although I hardly ever do when these things come up.
I don't see why criticism of referees is not allowed. It's as though they are a protected species…
If they've done a rubbish job (which is far too often) then they should have to cop any criticism they get, just like everybody else does.

Some of them are just plain incompetent at being an NRL referee and deserve all the criticism they get. It's time the NRL sided with the coaches and sack the referees who are constantly stuffing up.
 
Stuart is a rubbish coach… He talks about teaching his team to be disciplined yet he can't walk the talk... This is all a diversion to distract what a lousy coach he really is Parra for the spoon in 2013 &2014

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
Another win for the 'Untouchables'. The men in pink should be more accountable for their abysmal performances.
Good on you Ricky! Someone has to stand up to them…I just hope you have a good sponsor.......costing heaps...lol.
Seriously though, he raised a good point the first time he was fined when he said the further down the ladder you are the more penalised you get.....or something along those lines, and I'm sure we can all relate to that with our own club!
 
Maybe the refs should do a presser after each game & explain the crap calls *cough raiders try against us*

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
@Robz said:
Maybe the refs should do a presser after each game & explain the crap calls *cough raiders try against us*

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
Click to expand...

I like it

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
Remove Stuart from the equation, what he speaks of are the same issues we have faced eg that game vs Melbourne.

Some teams get it better than others, it's not how good they are, they get 40/60 calls their way.

It's absolute bollox he got fined, such a joke.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
Remove Stuart from the equation, what he speaks of are the same issues we have faced eg that game vs Melbourne.

Some teams get it better than others, it's not how good they are, they get 40/60 calls their way.

It's absolute bollox he got fined, such a joke.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
Refs doing pressers is absurd, it would just be a complete carve up with journos going after every little mistake they made. It would achieve absolutely nothing. I can just imagine it now:

Journo: so what happened with this call
Ref: yeah I got it wrong
*repeat 20 times*
\
\
As for Ricky, I don't call him the most gracious loser in the NRL for nothing, he never owns his failures and always pins it on the refs, his rap sheet is getting ridiculous.
 
I like the rating system used by the ICC Umpires and TCCB County umpires

Have the Dickie Bird autobiography and he covers it in detail

Each captain rates each umpire who officiates their games and if you score below a particular average for the season you were gone and they would bring the up and comers through

At least you have to earn your place every season

Ricky complains too much about the refs , so whatever point he is trying to make gets diluted

Why all the coaches and captains can't watch the games every week and make judgements on the referees can't be that hard , can it ??
 
@18thman said:
Seriously though, he raised a good point the first time he was fined when he said the further down the ladder you are the more penalised you get…..or something along those lines, and I'm sure we can all relate to that with our own club!
Click to expand...

There's probably more causation than correlation there; closer to the bottom because we can't win a penalty count. I'm not saying it's the be all and end all, but there's a reason the teams up top win more counts (I'm assuming, haven't looked at stats) and that'd be discipline.
 
I don't disagree with Ricky for one moment but geez he's poor at communicating with the referees and their bosses. I'd hate to know how much he's been fined over his career. Just looks like a serial whinger. Never seen him be constructive about his issues either.
 
He is a sook and a serial whinger. I would be embarassed if he coached Wests Tigers and carried on like that.

You make excuses and pass the buck like that and you get the performance from the players that kind of attitude warrants. All victim, all woe is me, zero accountability.

Professional sportsmen and professional sporting organisations get on with their job. Their are correct channels to explore issues available to every club.

There is an important reason why officials are a no go zone. We want to encourage growth in the ranks and need to accept that if you don't want a stop start 3 hour game you need to allow for human error. It happens. Good teams get on with it.

Bottom line is Ricky stuffed up this season. Wok Ryan said it best on ABC radio. By announcing the cull as he did the Parramatta Eels are now a team of individuals trying to secure their playing future. A team of individuals will get beaten every week by teams working together as a unit
 
I don't think the fines have been coming out of Stuart's pocket. The reality is that the Parramatta club is copping the fines.

A point which Stuart might like to consider is Milford's try against the Wests Tigers last Saturday. If the Tigers players and coach kept bleating about the try and dropped their heads for the rest of the match I am sure that WT would not have won the match as they did.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 546 (members: 7, guests: 539)
Back
Top