innsaneink
Well-known member
Rabs & MMM now running with this ref calling time….hes said he's asked Bill harrigan to look at it.
Wont change anything tho
Wont change anything tho
That last try was not a try
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
tigerlogic
New member
Macdougal apart from at the game I have now watched that try at full speed a few times, and ur absolutely dreaming! The try was fair, inu got it down in time, poor option to run it the set before, fair try! Shattering result!!!
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Tigerdave
Well-known member
@innsaneink said:
nah won't change anything unfortunately, be interesting to see if we've been dudded in a finals series again though.
In saying that, we've had a lot of calls go our way during our 9 wins, some certainly we were lucky to get away with.
Just went to this again on the reply to see about this Ref whistle.
For mine the whistle goes as Inu is putting the ball down the second time. Yeah he was a little premature but it's not like he blew the whistle and everyone stopped.
Still a fair try for mine,
Please no one bring anything else up about that situation I don't want to have to watch it again.
For mine the whistle goes as Inu is putting the ball down the second time. Yeah he was a little premature but it's not like he blew the whistle and everyone stopped.
Still a fair try for mine,
Please no one bring anything else up about that situation I don't want to have to watch it again.
tiger4ever
Active member
Yeah i thought no try not only with the double movement but i also thought when the ball was in the air it touched inu hand and went forward but looked like it went back cause inu fell forward after the contest.
Whats with that earlier decision in the first half when they ruled it touched vatuvei hand for a drop out then the video refs over rules it.Not a game changer and in the end it was right but gees how often do we see that.
I wasn't nervous at all about the game last night maybe the players wernt either
Yes yes we all know there's no point in whinging
Whats with that earlier decision in the first half when they ruled it touched vatuvei hand for a drop out then the video refs over rules it.Not a game changer and in the end it was right but gees how often do we see that.
I wasn't nervous at all about the game last night maybe the players wernt either
Yes yes we all know there's no point in whinging
innsaneink
Well-known member
@derailed said:
Yeh I thought touch and go too….almost simultaneous.
Watched it soo many times now know exactly where to go back to - 120 mins viewer defined.... :laughing:
innsaneink
Well-known member
@tiger4ever said:
Theyre reading this thread….they brought this up too.
Harrigan says he rang Hayne and hayne clearly remembers :laughing: blowing the whistle after the 2nd put down
W
Warriorsallday
Guest
Some of you guys are funny, the ref helped the tigers more than the warriors and that last try may have been doubtful but IF the ref blew time off after the first attempt then he cant have been penalised for a double movement. Ball was dead after the first attempt so Warriors get another set with couple minutes to go and Warriors with all the momentum :slight_smile:
@innsaneink said:
Why would he say this when there is clear evidence that it is not the case. The whistle may have been just after the put down put the intent was to blow it before.
These guys are so determined to not put there hand up and say they made a mistake no matter how big or small it can be embarrassing sometimes.
Right decision but wrong attitude to get backs up about it.
innsaneink
Well-known member
Looking at it again for what must be the 12th time- listening for the whistle this time….I'm OK with it.
Hayne dodged a bullet a bit, he reacted and blew whistle to the first put down imo....by the time he does this the 2nd put down & whistle blown are the same time
Hayne dodged a bullet a bit, he reacted and blew whistle to the first put down imo....by the time he does this the 2nd put down & whistle blown are the same time
Michaelson
New member
Talk about clutching at straws. If that was given a no try because the ref blew the whistle the Warriors would have been absolutely dudded. He wasn't tackled and he hadn't scored, the ref can't just stop the game.
It was a fair try. We won the penalties 9-4, including 3 back to back in the dying stages that were all terrible calls against NZ. If Tigers fans carry on about this decision, or try to suggest we were hard done by at all in this game, then we will deserve a rep as massive sooks.
It was a fair try. We won the penalties 9-4, including 3 back to back in the dying stages that were all terrible calls against NZ. If Tigers fans carry on about this decision, or try to suggest we were hard done by at all in this game, then we will deserve a rep as massive sooks.
hybrid_tiger
Well-known member
I honestly can't believe anyone can seriously front up after last night and complain about the officiating.
We were getting all the calls, we won the penalty count 9-4 and some of those penalties in the second half were VERY harsh against the Warriors. If they were against us most of us would have been blowing up (and rightly so).
Over the last two months we have received the majority of the favourable calls in most games, and if anyone honestly believes we were dudded they are either a) a massive, massive whinger and sore loser or b) completely deluded.
Just cop it on the chin guys. We lost fare and square. We had all the calls go our way and couldn't finish them off. Nobody's fault but our own.
We were getting all the calls, we won the penalty count 9-4 and some of those penalties in the second half were VERY harsh against the Warriors. If they were against us most of us would have been blowing up (and rightly so).
Over the last two months we have received the majority of the favourable calls in most games, and if anyone honestly believes we were dudded they are either a) a massive, massive whinger and sore loser or b) completely deluded.
Just cop it on the chin guys. We lost fare and square. We had all the calls go our way and couldn't finish them off. Nobody's fault but our own.
Tigerspirit
New member
To true hybrid tiger your point is exactly on the mark.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Just cause i was at the game and its hard to tell , what calls went against us?
Was it the moltzen held back call? and im guessing the locke dangerous tackle call? I actually dont like people shooting in like that, and even if it was around hte legs im not a fan of it.
Either way I think the last try was probably a try, although macdougall makes an interesting point, I just felt the warriors were a better side on the night. We looked really unthreateing all game bar the lawrence run in the first minute
Was it the moltzen held back call? and im guessing the locke dangerous tackle call? I actually dont like people shooting in like that, and even if it was around hte legs im not a fan of it.
Either way I think the last try was probably a try, although macdougall makes an interesting point, I just felt the warriors were a better side on the night. We looked really unthreateing all game bar the lawrence run in the first minute
in the actual put down for which they awarded a try - im pretty sure he lost the ball, then grounded it..
they didn't show proper replays on #9/FOX of it - but the ball separates from the hand, hits the ground and then he places his hand on it…
for the biggest game in the year to date, to not check it, after all those 3+ minute decisions we sit through during the year - is laughable... its a semi final and they don't even take their time with it..
they didn't show proper replays on #9/FOX of it - but the ball separates from the hand, hits the ground and then he places his hand on it…
for the biggest game in the year to date, to not check it, after all those 3+ minute decisions we sit through during the year - is laughable... its a semi final and they don't even take their time with it..
Marshall_magic
New member
It was a try 100% Inu was not tackled. We're in no position to blame refs though, we had the rub of the green for the entire game last night.
J
jonny
Guest
I think you should stop having a cry MacDougall
jirskyr
Well-known member
I thought it was a double-movement, but I agree with the sentiment that a couple of 1% efforts here and there and we don't lose.
Tigers kick long on the preceding set instead of running, Tigers hold their line when Hohaia jumps over, Tigers scramble harder when Inu is reaching out - all tiny things that add up to a loss. Matt Groat did two dumb things in the first half, the only dumb things we'd done until that moment, and Warriors score immediately.
Same thing happened last year vs St George, put in a bad kick and Soward sets up for the match-winning field goals.
So I reckon when you lose one like last night, you can blow up however you want about refs and decisions, but ultimately in semi finals it is your mistakes that lose them.
Tigers kick long on the preceding set instead of running, Tigers hold their line when Hohaia jumps over, Tigers scramble harder when Inu is reaching out - all tiny things that add up to a loss. Matt Groat did two dumb things in the first half, the only dumb things we'd done until that moment, and Warriors score immediately.
Same thing happened last year vs St George, put in a bad kick and Soward sets up for the match-winning field goals.
So I reckon when you lose one like last night, you can blow up however you want about refs and decisions, but ultimately in semi finals it is your mistakes that lose them.
Staff online
-
DempsModerator