Trent Robinson

[Todd Packer]

Is Trent Robinson the most overrated coach in the history of the game?
His team just lost to half a team of Cowboys and is sitting in the middle of the table even though Uncle Nick provides him with the most talented group every year.
He seems immune from criticism.
Why is it so?

 

[Demps]

Thought Dom Young played incredibly poorly

 

[jadtiger]

Thought Dom Young played incredibly poorly

It was probably his worst game in Australia,he had an absolute shocker

 

[TYGA]

Is Trent Robinson the most overrated coach in the history of the game?
His team just lost to half a team of Cowboys and is sitting in the middle of the table even though Uncle Nick provides him with the most talented group every year.
He seems immune from criticism.
Why is it so?

Won two comps gets benefit of the doubt.

 

[Spartan117]

Is Trent Robinson the most overrated coach in the history of the game?
His team just lost to half a team of Cowboys and is sitting in the middle of the table even though Uncle Nick provides him with the most talented group every year.
He seems immune from criticism.
Why is it so?

Agree, he is up there

In terms of resources, corporate support, and a great squad, I would expect more.

 

[king_sirro]

Thought Dom Young played incredibly poorly

He is an ordinary player really. Great athlete but zero footy smarts

 

[GNR4LIFE]

What are we basing this on, an Origin affected match? If you look at the Roosters last couple of seasons, particularly last year, they really overachieved. You don’t win 3 premierships if you are overrated.

 

[cktiger]

To be honest thought they were dudded today.

 

[Todd Packer]

What are we basing this on, an Origin affected match? If you look at the Roosters last couple of seasons, particularly last year, they really overachieved. You don’t win 3 premierships if you are overrated.

I'm basing it on them having objectively the most expensive team on the open market every year.
If Bennett or Bellamy coached under the sombrero they'd be heading for their 12th straight grand final. Bellamy's already proven what he can do with an extended salary cap.

 

[Champ1]

Is Trent Robinson the most overrated coach in the history of the game?
His team just lost to half a team of Cowboys and is sitting in the middle of the table even though Uncle Nick provides him with the most talented group every year.
He seems immune from criticism.
Why is it so?

Yes, he is the biggest dip sh#t , just behind Jason Taylor. A coach that has for years a team probs worthy 1.5 times the salary cap of other teams , and still has had mediocre results. Worse still , he continues to poach the best talent from the true development clubs like the Tigers & Penrith. A dead set pretender & major DHEAD.

 

[Red88_Tiger]

I'm basing it on them having objectively the most expensive team on the open market every year.
If Bennett or Bellamy coached under the sombrero they'd be heading for their 12th straight grand final. Bellamy's already proven what he can do with an extended salary cap.

Bennett had similar when he was at the broncos in his first round there

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

What are we basing this on, an Origin affected match? If you look at the Roosters last couple of seasons, particularly last year, they really overachieved. You don’t win 3 premierships if you are overrated.

Overachieved with a squad of Tedesco, Manu, Suaalii, Smith X 3, Tupou, Radley, Crichton, Keary, Walker, Butcher X 2, JWS, Collins and now Young, Watson and Leinu? If the Tigers had the Roosters squad, I'd be disappointed with anything less than a top 2 finish.

 

[Lachlan Galvin's #1 Fan]

He is an ordinary player really. Great athlete but zero footy smarts

I really like Dom Young. Reminds me of a NBA player who fully backs himself. Doesn't always get it right but at least he is out there having a go and backing himself 100%.

 

[Tucker]

Yes, he is the biggest dip sh#t , just behind Jason Taylor. A coach that has for years a team probs worthy 1.5 times the salary cap of other teams , and still has had mediocre results. Worse still , he continues to poach the best talent from the true development clubs like the Tigers & Penrith. A dead set pretender & major DHEAD.

1&1/2 time the cap eh?
Better tell the admin he has his sums wrong.

 

[Todd Packer]

They lose Teddy to Origin and he's replaced by Manu at fullback.
Compared to if we lost Bula he'd be replaced by Staines.
Just think about that for a moment
He has talent at his disposal that our fans only dream about yet they limped into the finals last year and now sit mid table with the Bulldogs, Dragons and Knights.

 

[hank37w]

It was probably his worst game in Australia,he had an absolute shocker

About on par with the way he was playing about 2 seasons ago.

He really only came good last season and not sure what it was that caused the big improvement in his game but prior to that he was pretty hopeless I thought, dare I even say it, Gildart like. 🤣

 

[Champ1]

1&1/2 time the cap eh?
Better tell the admin he has his sums wrong.

They already know. When the players are all asked why they go to the rorters, the classic line is pumped out... "For life after footy". That tells you exactly what goes on & how they sign people for unders. When ex players are paid AFTER they leave the club its technically not a salary cap breech is it?

 

[Telltails]

Robinson is just one cog in a club that takes full advantage of the system. The conditions he works under are not comparable to many/most clubs. However making the finals is not acceptable at the Roosters. This is a premiership winning squad and is about to lose two of its stars in Manu and Sualli - he is under immense pressure this season to win a premiership not just make the finals.

 

[Todd Packer]

Bellamy takes fringe players and turns them into role playing winners. Robinson takes stars and can't develop them any further.
Brandon Smith has crashed.
Dom Young is crashing.
He turned young Flanagan into a joke and yet Flanagan Senior has turned him back into the player that arrived at the Roosters.

 

[Tucker]

They already know. When the players are all asked why they go to the rorters, the classic line is pumped out... "For life after footy". That tells you exactly what goes on & how they sign people for unders. When ex players are paid AFTER they leave the club its technically not a salary cap breech is it?

How exactly does this equate to $6million /year?
We need your figures to mount a case against them.