Wests Tigers FG vs. Wests Tigers NSW Cup

[Tommy Magpie]

I must admit that I quite like the look of our NSW Cup side.

As a hypothetical, and as a bit of off-season fun, pretend our first grade and NSW Cup sides clashed this weekend. Who do you think would win? Is there a massive gap between the two sides?

I would go First Grade 38 - NSW CUP 24.

Thoughts from the 'experts'?

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

counts me out. Im not an expert.

 

[pHyR3]

Where does the 1st grade bench fit in, as a lot played reserve grade too? Are you comparing the top 13 vs top 13, or top 17?

With the top 17, i'd say it would be around 30-10

 

[system]

Where does the 1st grade bench fit in, as a lot played reserve grade too? Are you comparing the top 13 vs top 13, or top 17?

With the top 17, i'd say it would be around 30-10

17 vs 17 as named this weekend

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

 

[BenjiMagic96]

Where does the 1st grade bench fit in, as a lot played reserve grade too? Are you comparing the top 13 vs top 13, or top 17?

With the top 17, i'd say it would be around 30-10

17 vs 17 as named this weekend

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

I am assuming what PH means is that Pettyborune and other players were names in both sides. So it would not work out right. :slight_smile:

My score would be WT- 38 NSW Cup- 12

NSW would do better than Parra :stuck_out_tongue:

 

[pHyR3]

Yeah, exactly I think tedesco pettybourne and a few others are in both so it's kinda hard to say without knowing the answer.

 

[MacDougall]

First grade would win by 50.

 

[stryker]

Firsts would win cofortably, however I do like the look or our NSW cup side. Think they will do well this year.

 

[Tommy Magpie]

I think from the NSW Cup side names this weekend that Tedesco, Naiyaravoro, Nofo, Brooks, Pettybourne and BMM all see a bit of FG this year.