Wests Tigers Team v Brisbane

[momo_amp_medo]

What can I say ….. that second row …. Madge must be in love with those two.
Mikaele at lock is an experiment I suppose.
Two young forwards out of 17 should be playing ….. they need experience.
Overall disappointing selection.

No love for pauga or tuki?

Think everyone's death riding here atm is taking away the limelight of the debut for these 2 players

To the contrary I agree with trying something but the forwards are a mess ….
For me Seyfarth and Blore should be in the 17 Mbye and Garner should be in Sydney and Lucy should be interchange impact.

 

[kratos]

Ok great he split up Twal and Tamou, great to have AD back at 5/8, but dropping Seyfarth and Blore????? And Lucy shouldn't be starting either, Garner lucky to still be there.

Yeah blore and seyfarth getting dropped is a head scratcher

 

[tony soprano]

This is a weird forward combination.

Why is Twal on the bench? Seyfarth should be one of the first forwards picked.

Blore I kind of understand but we should persist with him.

I feel Madge is making changes for the sake of it without any future planning.

Same with Mbye to 6.

Seyfarth and twal have been underwhelming past few weeks

Surprised second row in tact

 

[Harvey]

Maybe madge plays musical chairs at training & this week Seyfarth and Blore missed the seat.

Seriously if dropping 2 young blokes who he has been giving minimal minutes to is his solution to the problems of the last couple of games, we should have left him in Sydney.

 

[tony soprano]

Like Chammas said the pressure is mounting

 

[kratos]

I think everyone is scratching their heads at blore and Seyfarth being dropped. Hopefully it's a rotation thing and about keeping them hungry or something along that line...good luck to the new guys. I know a lot of you on the forum have big raps of Tuki

 

[tony soprano]

Are these the real "men?"

Are they Madge men is the question I think he is gone

 

[JC99]

I think everyone is scratching their heads at blore and Seyfarth being dropped. Hopefully it's a rotation thing and about keeping them hungry or something along that line...good luck to the new guys. I know a lot of you on the forum have big raps of Tuki

Tuki is raw, really raw, he's barely played rugby league at all to be honest. Got some skills but might get caught out

 

[kratos]

I think everyone is scratching their heads at blore and Seyfarth being dropped. Hopefully it's a rotation thing and about keeping them hungry or something along that line...good luck to the new guys. I know a lot of you on the forum have big raps of Tuki

Tuki is raw, really raw, he's barely played rugby league at all to be honest. Got some skills but might get caught out

Maybe that's why he is testing him against broncos. But tbh broncos look on the bounce up

 

[kratos]

Most importantly who is referring this game?

 

[JC99]

I think everyone is scratching their heads at blore and Seyfarth being dropped. Hopefully it's a rotation thing and about keeping them hungry or something along that line...good luck to the new guys. I know a lot of you on the forum have big raps of Tuki

Tuki is raw, really raw, he's barely played rugby league at all to be honest. Got some skills but might get caught out

Maybe that's why he is testing him against broncos. But tbh broncos look on the bounce up

They've got a good pack. Haas, Kennedy and Hetherington worked really well for them last game.

 

[TrueTiger]

Everybody whinged about the young guys not getting a run....now they are and we have to keep some of the core of experienced players we still whinge....nobody but Madge and co know whats going on with Blore or Seyfarth...he could be letting them get more experience in KOE cup or letting them gradually get over injury(Blore)....I will wait and see what comes of this game...

 

[hobbo1]

Ok great he split up Twal and Tamou, great to have AD back at 5/8, but dropping Seyfarth and Blore????? And Lucy shouldn't be starting either, Garner lucky to still be there.

Yeah blore and seyfarth getting dropped is a head scratcher

Madge knows who the men are hence being omitted
He wants the pansies to man up .

 

[TigerTone]

Its interesting how Madge made the call out to his team to man up , and yet those who have done the opposite are still in the team.
Those who have shown promise and abit of gusto are not even in the seventeen or eighteen, whatever.

 

[Newtown]

A strange as our team looks, that Brisbane team is real bad. Even younger than us, with a terrible spine. Broncos by 24+

"That Brisbane team is real bad. Broncos by 24+" ?

 

[Newtown]

Its interesting how Madge made the call out to his team to man up , and yet those who have done the opposite are still in the team.
Those who have shown promise and abit of gusto are not even in the seventeen or eighteen, whatever.

I see that as those who don't man up are on the way out - permanently. MBye's very likely last chance.

 

[AdelaideTiger]

A strange as our team looks, that Brisbane team is real bad. Even younger than us, with a terrible spine. Broncos by 24+

"That Brisbane team is real bad. Broncos by 24+" ?

Point being, every time I think WTs should get a comfortable win, it's usually a resounding disappointment...

 

[bigsiro]

A strange as our team looks, that Brisbane team is real bad. Even younger than us, with a terrible spine. Broncos by 24+

"That Brisbane team is real bad. Broncos by 24+" ?

Too conservative?

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

Ok great he split up Twal and Tamou, great to have AD back at 5/8, but dropping Seyfarth and Blore????? And Lucy shouldn't be starting either, Garner lucky to still be there.

Yeah blore and seyfarth getting dropped is a head scratcher

Surely Blore & Seyfarth dropped is only either to give LL & Mikaele one last chance, or there is going to be a late change with Blore IN (as we have no back row cover except for Offa, god forbid if we haven't learnt that lesson!

While Blore has had limited opportunities, he has shown great intent & technique in D and plenty of potential in attack (almost like he's ready to have a breakout game in attack) AND Seyfarth, provides that bit of mongrel & passion that lacks elsewhere in the pack.

 

[happy_tiger]

Seyfarth deserves to be filthy over this one and yet Mbye survives...bewildering. to say the least.

Too many defensive issues mate ...has the heart but lacks some of the tools ......

As opposed to Mikaele at 13?

I don't disagree with that

Twal yes .....and I expect that will change possibly before kick off

My point is if we counter Brisbane strengths ....their prop rotation ...we go along way to winning ....and no one seems to be able to mention whether Tuki or Blore is the better option .....