Which was better ?

[GNR4LIFE]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

You're living in your own reality atm. He's playing well, and instead of swallowing your pride, you have to bang on about how average he's been throughout his career. Irrelevant to his current form.

The Brooks bashers are entering a new phase. Can't lay the boot in for his current form, so you have to clutch what he was playing like when your bashing of the guy was valid. That's the reality at present.

 

[fair dinkum]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

You're living in your own reality atm. He's playing well, and instead of swallowing your pride, you have to bang on about how average he's been throughout his career. Irrelevant to his current form.

The Brooks bashers are entering a new phase. Can't lay the boot in for his current form, so you have to clutch what he was playing like when your bashing of the guy was valid. That's the reality at present.

Can you point out something ive said that isnt true? If not, why are you moaning? Arent the Brooks fan boys meant to be so happy that a 6 year potential has just played a good game...... for once?

 

[fair dinkum]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.

Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

You're living in your own reality atm. He's playing well, and instead of swallowing your pride, you have to bang on about how average he's been throughout his career. Irrelevant to his current form.

The Brooks bashers are entering a new phase. Can't lay the boot in for his current form, so you have to clutch what he was playing like when your bashing of the guy was valid. That's the reality at present.

Can you point out something ive said that isnt true? If not, why are you moaning, Arent the Brooks fan boys meant to be so happy that a year potential has just played a good game...... for once?

I think its more a question of why are you still beating this dead horse when he's in good form.

 

[jirskyr]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

They don't award Dally Ms on how far your team gets into the finals, that's not the point. Point is to recognise the most well-performed individuals over a season of matches.

RTS obviously Dally M POTY, not too much argument, and his team lasted 1 week of finals.

The point is, fan boys or no, you can't play just 2 good games in a career and win an award like that, it's impossible, except to close-minded persons. 24 matches judged by independent and varied league pundits vs some dude on internet.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

 

[fair dinkum]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

You're living in your own reality atm. He's playing well, and instead of swallowing your pride, you have to bang on about how average he's been throughout his career. Irrelevant to his current form.

The Brooks bashers are entering a new phase. Can't lay the boot in for his current form, so you have to clutch what he was playing like when your bashing of the guy was valid. That's the reality at present.

Can you point out something ive said that isnt true? If not, why are you moaning, Arent the Brooks fan boys meant to be so happy that a year potential has just played a good game...... for once?

I think its more a question of why are you still beating this dead horse when he's in good form.

I mentioned he "had" been playing like garbage for years and said he had "finally pulled his finger out". Its evident there is only one person beating a dead horse.

 

[fair dinkum]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

So if we win on Sunday, then what? Are you going to be a man and give him credit for being that halfback, or will you take the easy way out and give it to him for taking so long to do it?

 

[fair dinkum]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

So if we win on Sunday, then what? Are you going to be a man and give him credit for being that halfback, or will you take the easy way out and give it to him for taking so long to do it?

Christ, how miserable are you.

Shouldn't you be happy the Tigers made the finals and not about what others think?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

So if we win on Sunday, then what? Are you going to be a man and give him credit for being that halfback, or will you take the easy way out and give it to him for taking so long to do it?

Christ, how miserable are you.

Shouldn't you be happy the Tigers made the finals and not about what others think?

I don't care. But we happen to be conversing on a forum. Its a common theme to ask others about their opinions. If the question to hard though, well...This seems like a good place to end the discussion.

 

[fair dinkum]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

So if we win on Sunday, then what? Are you going to be a man and give him credit for being that halfback, or will you take the easy way out and give it to him for taking so long to do it?

Christ, how miserable are you.

Shouldn't you be happy the Tigers made the finals and not about what others think?

I don't care. But we happen to be conversing on a forum. Its a common theme to ask others about their opinions. If the question to hard though, well...This seems like a good place to end the discussion.

Do you often go back and edit your posts hours later or is it just this one that you heavily edited?

 

[Tigerboy]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

So if we win on Sunday, then what? Are you going to be a man and give him credit for being that halfback, or will you take the easy way out and give it to him for taking so long to do it?

Christ, how miserable are you.

Shouldn't you be happy the Tigers made the finals and not about what others think?

I don't care. But we happen to be conversing on a forum. Its a common theme to ask others about their opinions. If the question to hard though, well...This seems like a good place to end the discussion.

Do you often go back and edit your posts hours later or is it just this one that you heavily edited?

Heavily edits regularly, my dude

 

[fair dinkum]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

So if we win on Sunday, then what? Are you going to be a man and give him credit for being that halfback, or will you take the easy way out and give it to him for taking so long to do it?

Christ, how miserable are you.

Shouldn't you be happy the Tigers made the finals and not about what others think?

I don't care. But we happen to be conversing on a forum. Its a common theme to ask others about their opinions. If the question to hard though, well...This seems like a good place to end the discussion.

Going back and editing a post to read completely different does seem to imply that in fact you do care. :thinking_face:

 

[fair dinkum]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

So if we win on Sunday, then what? Are you going to be a man and give him credit for being that halfback, or will you take the easy way out and give it to him for taking so long to do it?

Christ, how miserable are you.

Shouldn't you be happy the Tigers made the finals and not about what others think?

I don't care. But we happen to be conversing on a forum. Its a common theme to ask others about their opinions. If the question to hard though, well...This seems like a good place to end the discussion.

Do you often go back and edit your posts hours later or is it just this one that you heavily edited?


Heavily edits regularly, my dude

I reckon mate, night and day with this bloke. Edits messages hours after the other bloke walks away from the forum to make him look like he isnt unhinged.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Today, 2nd good game ive ever seen him play. About time. See if he can back it up next week or go missing as usual.

Solid effort to win the Dally M halfback of the year when you've only ever played 2 good games in your career and none of those games were in that year.

Just goes to show how flawed those awards are. Cant even lead his team into a finals series and gets an award that his fan boys will feed off to justify his entire failed career? :man-facepalming:

Christ, how miserable are you.

Id imagine it would be pretty miserable to never see the truth, hows that working out for you?

Mate, its great. We're playing on Sunday in front of a full house at home to get into the 8. We're all pumped. Then there's you, having a sulk because Brooks is getting credit for playing well.

nah im pointing out Brooks has been rubbish for 5 years and its about time he pulled his finger out.

Clearly you haven't been watching us play lately.

Isnt that the exact point of what i said? About time he pulled his finger out = "lately"

Okay, so you acknowledge he's pulled his finger out lately. So, why are you moaning?

If you call "moaning" pointing out that Brooks usually plays like garbage and The Tigers havent had a decent half back since Lui, then sure, call it moaning. Id prefer to call it "reality". Each to the their own.

And another thing, you are clearly bitter about it. You don't want the guy playing well. You want him to fail.


Citation needed?

On the contrary, im actually wanting a half back that can lead the Tigers into the finals, thus far it hasnt been Brooks. Why are you pleased for the failing of the past to justify a decent game here and there?

Yes, wanting A halfback. You don't want it to be Brooks. Even if he is the one to lead us.

I couldnt careless who it is, as long as they steer a team into the finals, as of yet, Brooks has proven himself incapable.

So if we win on Sunday, then what? Are you going to be a man and give him credit for being that halfback, or will you take the easy way out and give it to him for taking so long to do it?

Christ, how miserable are you.

Shouldn't you be happy the Tigers made the finals and not about what others think?

I don't care. But we happen to be conversing on a forum. Its a common theme to ask others about their opinions. If the question to hard though, well...This seems like a good place to end the discussion.

Do you often go back and edit your posts hours later or is it just this one that you heavily edited?


Heavily edits regularly, my dude

I reckon mate, night and day with this bloke. Edits messages hours after the other bloke walks away from the forum to make him look like he isnt unhinged.

I edited it 10 or 15 minutes after I posted it. Big deal. You saw it didn’t you? You’re still continuing to deflect. Deflecting from the question that was posed to you, of whether you would give credit to Brooks if we win on Sunday, or will you find another angle to avoid swallowing your pride.

 

[Guest]

Cut the crap or the thread closes, and if people want to get personal with one another, well there's another solution for that.

 

[gallagher]

I love how a couple wins bring the fans together.

 

[TCL]

@fair-dinkum we will never know but I wonder how Brooks would have performed if he had played in that 2010 team.

 

[Adam Doobie]

Why do all the idiots always come out when it's "bag Luke Brooks hour". All you have to do is go to [Luke Brooks' official profile](https://www.weststigers.com.au/teams/telstra-premiership/wests-tigers/luke-brooks/) and check his stats. They tell the entire story. Every stat improves year on year, to the point where this year has been borderline bonkers in some departments. If he improves even more next year, we could well be seeing the next Dally M Medalist. It's also a real possibility he plays Origin next year.