Who Should our New Halfback be ?

[Red88_Tiger]

Is Fogarty actually available

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

I've said it before, and I'll say it again.

7. Klemmer

Sheens did more Corey Pearson to 7 for a game so it’s possible.

 

[Dino]

Fogarty hands down since he's the only one currently playing nrl at a decent standard but I don't think the raiders are going to let him go considering they just lost Wighton

 

[earl]

Jayden Sullivan for sure. First game against us this year he played 7, he shredded Brooks and us. I thought, I wish we had a half like him.

I like the positive comments. I think he is the best option with Fainu at 6. Two guys playing attacking footy behind a good forward pack.

 

[diedpretty]

i want a no name at the club so i have gone for Austin Szueir

 

[NT_Tiger]

Whoever we can con into signing at twice the price for a ten year deal

 

[gregjm87]

Don't want any of them. Wouldn't say i'm pleased with Sullivan but looks to be the best of a bad bunch thus far. Certainly, prefer him to those 4.

 

[Todd Packer]

Ostin Staysharp for me with Dave Sullivan at 6

 

[Todd Packer]

Leeds are playing St Helens at 5am. Saturday morning if anyone wants to watch Sezer.

 

[GCfan]

Jayden Sullivan for sure. First game against us this year he played 7, he shredded Brooks and us. I thought, I wish we had a half like him.

Did you watch his next few games though?

 

[crazycat]

Leedsss are playing St Helens at 5am. Saturday morning if anyone wants to watch Sezer.

5am... Tell me the highlights!

 

[Fallen Angel]

Jayden Sullivan for sure. First game against us this year he played 7, he shredded Brooks and us. I thought, I wish we had a half like him.

Never take any game any player plays against us as a barometer

 

[tiger_scott]

My vote:

 

[tiger_one]

My vote:
View attachment 6079

If only.

 

[Yossarian]

This is almost like asking "how would you like to be executed you have a choice of 4"

The one from Meaning of Life

 

[Fallen Angel]

If these are the sorts of options we had to revert to, then no wonder the club stuck with Brooks for as long as they did.

 

[TigerSJ]

I think the next two seasons will be about transitioning to our juniors so any half needs to have experience and be able to guide the team while the juniors gain experience. A guy like Sezer with a young off the cuff type 5/8 will probably be the best way forward.
Probably only a short term deal for Sezer.
Sullivan worries me as he doesn’t seem too durable so far in his career and we need that stability over the next 2 seasons.

 

[TigerNeddyK]

Cleary for me

 

[crazycat]

Adam Reynolds....

Now lets put this all into perspective. Its 2021. Michael Mcguire is our coach. Brooks has struggled as he has almost every year he has been with us.

Adam Reynolds wasn't on our interest list. We knew the contracts, the dates and the pressures souths are under.... Imagine this:

Adam Reynolds at 7, Luke Brooks at 6 and Doueihi at Bench - reserve lock/center?

^any of the players above dislike this, move them on.

Instead, we had no plan and no identification of weakness. We needed a hard conversation about Brooks and to work out where he can grow within the wests tigers and what we needed to grow.

So we hired Hastings, and Amazingly Hastings turned out to be a stack better then I expected. Still had we had a plan we could have:
Identified Adam Reynolds as a Halfback we wanted at our club.
Offered Adam the same money as Brisbane, but the opportunity to continue in Sydney.

We had no plan. So come 2021 Jackson Hastings becomes availablish, we sign him... We refuse to let Brooks go because WE HAVE NO PLAN! Then we punt Hastings the next year for what? The same combination that has let us down the last 10.


I want a damn plan!

 

[innsaneink]

Looks. Like it's whatsusname the saints fella