My 2 cents.
At the moment with the state of the team and the position we are going to be in Reynolds hands down.
He is an out and out five eight. A runner first, reacting to the defence, doesn't throw a slick ball in a sweeping play but he does get his arms free to link up with his centre or backrower (Jackson). In addition to this, Brooks is an out and out halfback, he will not is yet but he will be a great organiser / game manager half and already has good kicking skill. (In game application needs work).
Reynolds will help mild our team into a consistent finals side.
However.
Once that time comes. The player you want once you become a consistent contender is actually someone like Mitchell Moses. I truely believe that he has more X factor in him and will be a key to a team winning a comp.
As I said at this stage we need a Reynolds type more.
