LIVE GAME Trial 1 v Manly

Live Game Discussion
TigerSkins said:
You'd wanna hope that with Laurie and Hastings back we improve in attack .. but whats with our forwards .. not one of them looked like they were gonna penetrate the defence line .. then also not one of them aimed up in our defence.

I know its only a trial game but when they called our try back for obstruction .. why didnt they call first Manlys first try back for obstruction .. go back and watch it .. Manly's lead runner runs straight into our player denying our player a chance to come across .. exactly what we got pinged for ... if the TV refs are gonna call what they can see .. they better be consistent .. it was terrible.

Let's hope next weekends trial against the Rorters we go better, otherwise we're in for another long hard season of misery.
Click to expand...
Just rewatched it on Kayo mini replay. Number 12 for manly runs into Luciano taking him out of the defensive line. Only difference between that play and the Foran obstruction was that Manly scored so quickly that Luciano couldn’t have made it across to tackle the try scorer. With the Foran obstruction he could have made it across to tackle Nofo. Had Nofo scored in the corner instead of coming in I suspect it would’ve been awarded a try.
 
nrlsurvivor said:
Just rewatched it on Kayo mini replay. Number 12 for manly runs into Luciano taking him out of the defensive line. Only difference between that play and the Foran obstruction was that Manly scored so quickly that Luciano couldn’t have made it across to tackle the try scorer. With the Foran obstruction he could have made it across to tackle Nofo. Had Nofo scored in the corner instead of coming in I suspect it would’ve been awarded a try.
Click to expand...
I thought that at the time..btw Foran still had a shot on Nofoaluma no way he stops that TRY..with or without obstruction..
 
Mighty_Tiger said:
Some have said Dillon in 30mins offered more than Laurie did all year which is a dumb statement.

Dillon gets alot of slack given he hasn't played with the big boys before but he isn't NRL ready and isn't in the same ball park to Laurie at the moment. That could very well change over time & hope he becomes one of the rare kids that lives up to their skill & promise within the NRL level.

People are building him up, but we need to keep it real as well. This kid needs time.
Click to expand...
Yep agree also.
As of right now ….. he is nowhere near Laurie.
I’m not saying it’s not going to happen in the future ….. but for now it’s a No for me anyway.
 
stryker 69 said:
That won’t automatically make everything just fine.
The team needs to improve now.
Papa won’t make bugger all difference if our incumbents can’t defend, have limited attacking skills and the clubs depth is sub par.
This squad must improve enough to play finals this year.
Click to expand...
Have we just watched a trial game or am I somehow got mixed up and it’s August 2022.

That may be a better time to load your ammo.
 
Cobarcats said:
What Sheens has done is identified the 2 areas where we were vulnerable, ruck control and energy and toughness in the fowards.
He has proven that with 2 astute signings of Api and Papa. I could just about guarantee there will be a further 2 new forwards in our pack in 2023.
The other area is our centres, look for another back signing.
I refuse to believe Sheens won't produce in these two areas.
Click to expand...
I agree and I’m pretty sure that next off season will again produce a large % of turnover. Players with or without 2023 contracts will be on their way unless they show- produce results and show improvement.
This year will be a watershed season for our club administrators, players and the coaching staff.
And that’s a good thing.
 
MAGPIES1963 said:
Sounds like an old footy injury @Cobarcats ?
How's the pain level and recuperation time as compared to a knee/hip replacement?... neither of which I have had luckily.
Click to expand...
Had the knee replaced two years ago ha ha.
Na not footy but army injuries, had knee, right shoulder, 2 finger joints, back and neck fusion and jaw replaced [jaw by far the worst pain]. Now you know why my golf handicap has blown out 🤣 my mates believe I cheat at golf because I've had performance enhancing surgery, my missus disagrees 😜
 
momo_amp_medo said:
Have we just watched a trial game or am I somehow got mixed up and it’s August 2022.

That may be a better time to load your ammo.
Click to expand...
I’m just stating that a fair few people have written off the upcoming season before a blow is struck.
Its a defeatist mindset.
The squad we have now have to lift and push for finals this year so that when the talent we have purchased arrive next year, they can capitalise on the momentum created and drive us towards proper success.
 
momo_amp_medo said:
I agree and I’m pretty sure that next off season will again produce a large % of turnover. Players with or without 2023 contracts will be on their way unless they show- produce results and show improvement.
This year will be a watershed season for our club administrators, players and the coaching staff.
And that’s a good thing.
Click to expand...
Mate that is spot on, I said earlier post that if some players don't perform, maybe noone will want them, Garner in particular.
 
stryker 69 said:
I’m just stating that a fair few people have written off the upcoming season before a blow is struck.
Its a defeatist mindset.
The squad we have now have to lift and push for finals this year so that when the talent we have purchased arrive next year, they can capitalise on the momentum created and drive us towards proper success.
Click to expand...
Good point
 
stryker 69 said:
I’m just stating that a fair few people have written off the upcoming season before a blow is struck.
Its a defeatist mindset.
The squad we have now have to lift and push for finals this year so that when the talent we have purchased arrive next year, they can capitalise on the momentum created and drive us towards proper success.
Click to expand...

I'll admit I have written them off. If I gambled, I'd put money on either Cowboys or us to win the spoon. However, as you can see even you are somewhat thinking of next year. We can say whatever we like but I hope the squad doesn't have the defeatist attitude.
 
tig_prmz said:
I'll admit I have written them off. If I gambled, I'd put money on either Cowboys or us to win the spoon. However, as you can see even you are somewhat thinking of next year. We can say whatever we like but I hope the squad doesn't have the defeatist attitude.
Click to expand...
Even if they don’t, the results won‘t be any better. They simply aren‘t good enough.
 
tig_prmz said:
I'll admit I have written them off. If I gambled, I'd put money on either Cowboys or us to win the spoon. However, as you can see even you are somewhat thinking of next year. We can say whatever we like but I hope the squad doesn't have the defeatist attitude.
Click to expand...
You always have to have an eye to the future and forward planning is essential. I am thinking of next year and beyond, whilst not writing this one off. I expect them to make the 8 this year.
Put it this way…if you are correct and we do come bottom 2, would you think the arrival of API and Papa will automatically turn our fortunes around?
 
Cobarcats said:
Had the knee replaced two years ago ha ha.
Na not footy but army injuries, had knee, right shoulder, 2 finger joints, back and neck fusion and jaw replaced [jaw by far the worst pain]. Now you know why my golf handicap has blown out 🤣 my mates believe I cheat at golf because I've had performance enhancing surgery, my missus disagrees 😜
Click to expand...
@Cobarcats It sounds like something pretty bad😵‍💫/dangerous 🥵 happened to You.
Are you able to tell us?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 794 (members: 6, guests: 788)
Back
Top