OFFICIAL James Tamou [Discussion]

[Chipofftheoldblock]

Bit disappointed really, I know it was a trial and the first trial at that, but it was an ideal chance to show what they have been working on in the off season and how they are going to play. More of the same, 5 hit ups for a kick and no obvious defensive pattern, nofo letting in tries, Tamou turning his back when meeting the defensive line.
Liked Peachey, Junior has worked on his game in the off season and should give the starting centre a run for their money, Kelma showed why Manly went hard for him.

Totally agree Tbones - That is why there is that feeling of despair. If there a difference in both defense and attack in terms of positivity, then most would be okay however the attack was pedestrian and defense was backwards and embarrassing.
They looked unfit and lacked anything that could give you hope. I would rather have a pedestrian attack (to some degree) but what i really want is a fast aggressive defensive structure, that gives limited time and everyone works for each other. To me it was just more of the same crap that has been dissed out over the past years. Is it the coaching or the players??? Maybe bit of both but just want to see desire.
I want to see quick movement off the line instead of waiting and running backwards to make a tackle. I want to see a game plan that actually targets a teams weakness and follows through. I want to see our edge runners run a decent line like Gareth Ellis did back in day.....when you train every day and this is your job surely this is not too much to ask as Rugby League is a pretty simple game to play.

 

[CornerPost]

IMO..Didn't think we did too bad in the trial. No title this year obviously but no wrist slitting either. Thought the young hooker and Dillon were very promising.. centre and front row seem an issue.. tamou defence is ok but offers zero in attack.. mickeali runs hard but is found wanting in defence especially laterally.. no talau, kepoa and douhi leaves that competitiveness for the centre position a little short.. positively the club looks like they're developing some good young middle forwards and outside backs so if we retain the good ones and a bit of luck 23 and 24 doesn't look too bad.. might be another rollercoaster 22 unfortunately..

 

[tony soprano]

IMO..Didn't think we did too bad in the trial. No title this year obviously but no wrist slitting either. Thought the young hooker and Dillon were very promising.. centre and front row seem an issue.. tamou defence is ok but offers zero in attack.. mickeali runs hard but is found wanting in defence especially laterally.. no talau, kepoa and douhi leaves that competitiveness for the centre position a little short.. positively the club looks like they're developing some good young middle forwards and outside backs so if we retain the good ones and a bit of luck 23 and 24 doesn't look too bad.. might be another rollercoaster 22 unfortunately..

Agree mate apparently Tamou hasn't had much of a preseason. Spurs in ankle had surgery

 

[CornerPost]

Agree mate apparently Tamou hasn't had much of a preseason. Spurs in ankle had surgery

Yeah.. he'll start the year but hopefully will be gradually faded out during the season to give those promising 19-21yr Olds a game or two.. hasn't been a lot of footy played in the last couple of years they just need some game time.. interesting to see how they go in reserve grade..

 

[PJ_]

I'm not that fussed about the comments... 2021 was not an issue with strategy, it was an issue with sticking to the strategy. It's about the quality and commitment of the players.

It's about desire and commitment and the boys putting in. Effort is what's lacking

 

[tony soprano]

Yeah.. he'll start the year but hopefully will be gradually faded out during the season to give those promising 19-21yr Olds a game or two.. hasn't been a lot of footy played in the last couple of years they just need some game time.. interesting to see how they go in reserve grade..

He looked trimmed down hopefully he comes good

 

[tiger_one]

IMO..Didn't think we did too bad in the trial. No title this year obviously but no wrist slitting either. Thought the young hooker and Dillon were very promising.. centre and front row seem an issue.. tamou defence is ok but offers zero in attack.. mickeali runs hard but is found wanting in defence especially laterally.. no talau, kepoa and douhi leaves that competitiveness for the centre position a little short.. positively the club looks like they're developing some good young middle forwards and outside backs so if we retain the good ones and a bit of luck 23 and 24 doesn't look too bad.. might be another rollercoaster 22 unfortunately..

Can I just say I love your handle: Corner Post - that says everything about the footy I know!

 

[Cobarcats]

It is what it is

Aaron Woods, did I get it right this time 😁

 

[tig_prmz]

Madge has learnt his systems from Storm and seems to think that the same type of coaching will work in 2022. I'm sure Madge has changed and tried to be calm but the fundamental thing is that he can't seem to get the players motivated enough.

Our players just seem absolutely clueless. Heard Tamou say that "they want to keep things simple".. I'm sure it's just a throwaway line but seriously at NRL level, you can't just keep things simple.

I know it sounds pessimistic based on one trial, but I was actually quite surprised by how slow and weak we looked. Manly is a top 4 side but they looked stronger and fitter without even trying.

I've been saying this for 3 years. Wests Tigers are improving, we have come a long way since the JT days (as much as I hate Cleary, he's partly responsible) but the NRL and other clubs have improved and gone very far ahead of us.

I hope the NRL introduces some sort of a draft system, we need some freakish luck to go our way.

 

[TrueTiger]

Madge doesnt need to change things as far as his coaching goes,he has had experience from a couple of good systems...Im not just being a big fan of Madge Im telling you guys how it is...

Our players and the guys that have been in the system for a while at the WTs are in a place of absolute complacency,it has been there for several years,the old we do as we like and if its not good enough ...sack the coach...same thing year after year,however some of the new guys respect Madge and his methods thats why Tamou always speaks about the players having to put in and not blame the coach..
the sooner some fans wake up to the fact that some of these highly paid wannabees start to perform like they have pride and dignity in the club and colours that expand to the huge fanbase and earn their respect,instead of waiting to collect the paycheck for appearing ,then the better off this joint will be..
year after year I hear Madge isnt the one.Potter wasnt the one ,JT wasnt the one and on it goes....start looking at where the blame lies...and its not the coaching but the playing group that need to do their job and have a good hard look at themselves as far as NRL playing goes....

 

[Merlot]

we have played to the local under 6's game plan since Madge got here.what ever is at fault i hope it changes quicksmart

 

[Geo]

we have played to the local under 6's game plan since Madge got here.what ever is at fault i hope it changes quicksmart

Under 6's don't have to tackle now so prepare for Wests Tigers world domination..they are experts at that..

 

[Harvey]

Madge will be lucky to last 6 weeks, nothing has changed.

Same lack of interest shown by players, stagnating attack, same robotic bench rotation and even leaving an injured player on the field when there is unlimited interchange, and then conceding a try through the gap he left.

 

[Fade.To.Black]

Madge will be lucky to last 6 weeks, nothing has changed.

Same lack of interest shown by players, stagnating attack, same robotic bench rotation and even leaving an injured player on the field when there is unlimited interchange, and then conceding a try through the gap he left.

All part of flying under the radar😳

We are like an animal playing dead but ready to strike😂

 

[supercoach]

Taylorball was a expansive style of football compared to Madgeball.
Sadly you have to play a style that your cattle have a chance to be able to play.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Madge will be lucky to last 6 weeks, nothing has changed.

Same lack of interest shown by players, stagnating attack, same robotic bench rotation and even leaving an injured player on the field when there is unlimited interchange, and then conceding a try through the gap he left.

If that’s the case it will show that this club is indeed the biggest joke in the NRL. We had the chance to cut him loose after the Dogs debacle, but gave him a reprieve. If we sack him after 6 weeks, we will have robbed a new coach of an off season, and this year will be a write off. I mean, it already is, but you know what I mean.

 

[Demps]

Bring back Jason Taylor
😂

 

[Fade.To.Black]

Bring back Jason Taylor
😂

Couldn't stand the gimp he had a very punchable face but he did have us in the mix for the finals race- albeit with a much better roster than what we have currently.

 

[BAGNF05]

All part of flying under the radar😳

We are like an animal playing dead but ready to strike😂

Our right edge defense should get an Oscar

 

[Demps]

Couldn't stand the gimp he had a very punchable face but he did have us in the mix for the finals race- albeit with a much better roster than what we have currently.

Malnourished.

I won't rag on him too much, has relatives on this forum 😉