Michael Maguire leaves club

Status
Not open for further replies.
TrueTiger said:
I understand that many members and supporters want Madge gone,repeating the same "the game has past him" scenario gets you no where..Madge knows whats expected to win games,he has won premierships,he works hard in the best interest of the team and club...Yet as soon as this team loses the knives come out for him,sure its crap we are going through and because he defends his squad,he gets the blame..
Maybe the game hasnt past him by,he may be trying things a bit differently because of the youth we have,how about Garner in the centres last night,I wouldnt have thought he would be picked there,but Madge must know better than us...
how about this squad and team hasnt understood exactly whats required to compete in the NRL,maybe most of these players havent caught up to the game let alone be past it like the coach apparently has...
Click to expand...
"As soon as this team loses, the knives come out"
This is his 4th season and the knives come out because under his Coaching, we consistently lose.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Just my view but with a change of coach I'd expect significant individual improvement in our players.
Click to expand...
I get it. I screamed for JT to be sacked convinced he was our biggest handbrake and and we would move forward once he was gone. Two well respectec coaches later and plenty of money to spend we seem to have made very little progress in attracting the players we need to the club.
 
JC99 said:
He's the one who moved on a lot of their old players and brought all the Penrith juniors through and helped turn them into guns... by the end of 2020 he had them playing quite well

None of them were rep players before he got there and they weren't playing as a team like they do now. He completely changed how they play
Click to expand...
They were top 4 and sacked hook…
Again, a very selective memory,

They were rep players - might not have played rep footy, but we’re certainly rep players
 
JC99 said:
A better coach would get more out of this roster. Ivan Cleary had a worse roster and had them playing better than this for a while there before he decided to bugger off

Time to rip off the band aid and get it done. You don't need a replacement ready to walk straight into the job, Madge has to go.
Click to expand...

Like sheens said. U play to your team strengths. Brooks is never going to be your grind out a win type player nor does he have the squad for it. Madge cannot adapt to a more attacking style of footy team which the Tigers should be.
 
Robbie undermining Madge? Really, who would have thought? As I said in another posts, something stinks with this place
 
crazycat said:
Madge will go unless he can start winning soon.

Yet I see "tamou out". okay, why does the ex Captain of Penrith who scored a try vs Warriors go? Did anyone really say "don't sign Tamou" when he made the Grand Final?

If we sign Simms will we be ranting about his bad performance here 6 months later?
Someone like Tamou we brought as a top player, and were getting a Medium performance. So something is really wrong with our coaching.
Click to expand...
Tamou is and always been a contract players - plays good in final year of contract . Did same at Penrith
 
tony soprano said:
www.2gb.com

Adam Doueihi slams claims Michael Maguire is too hard a coach as ‘a load of rubbish’

Wests Tigers co-captain Adam Doueihi has slammed calls that coach Michael Maguire is too hard and too tough as a “load of rubbish”. This comes as pressure is building on the Tigers coach after they slumped to their third straight loss on Friday against the Warriors. Doueihi says “to describe a...
www.2gb.com www.2gb.com


Wouldn't say no to flanno

If madge goes chance Doueihi goes with him.
Click to expand...
The only problem with Flanno is it'll be a package deal with his son and that is a problem
 
Telltails said:
I get it. I screamed for JT to be sacked convinced he was our biggest handbrake and and we would move forward once he was gone. Two well respectec coaches later and plenty of money to spend we seem to have made very little progress in attracting the players we need to the club.
Click to expand...
Whether you attract players or not, the issue is Maguire cannot get the best out of those we have.
 
WT2K said:
www.2gb.com

Robbie Farah accused of undermining coach

Continuous Call Team host Mark Levy received an email from a concerned Wests Tigers fan describing some of the commotion going on the field Friday night. The listener described Tiger trainer Robbie Farah blowing up at his players and blaming coach Michael Maguire. Mark Levy reached out to Robbie...
www.2gb.com www.2gb.com
Click to expand...

Does that make news know some random fans claims something . I would imagine 2GB would have had someone on sideline that would have heard that rather than random fan in the stands
 
Telltails said:
The perception of the club is where the problem lies - not with the coaches who have tried to change it. Strong squads make coaches successful. Until this club can attract those players our position on the ladder stays camped in the bottom half of the comp. Api K and I Papalli a start.
Click to expand...
#truth
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Whether you attract players or not, the issue is Maguire cannot get the best out of those we have.
Click to expand...
That's debatable - Matterson played his best footy under Maguire. Alolai, LL, Tuilagi, McIntyre all targeted from other clubs based on their performances under Maguire - three with vastly inflated contracts. Harry Grant never had a problem shining under Maguire. Douehi continues to develop and then there are a host of young players that are always a work in progress - some will make it some won't.
 
WT2K said:
Faf undermining Madge 🤔
Click to expand...
The club wanted Robbie running the water and no doubt using his experience with the squad. If he is seeing things from the sideline which warrant the alleged reaction then Houston we have a problem. I'm not sure what many want him to do if this is true.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 532 (members: 28, guests: 504)
Back
Top