Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Stevec]

Hertherington I think would be an interesting prospect on an edge, he's fast and tough, give him time to work on his line running and get him to practice those suicide lines like Ellis and Lawrence use to run. He's got speed and cardio for a prop, not sure what his lateral defence is like and he would need to learn to control aggression, bit moving out of the middle might help him channel some aggression. I wouldn't pay him much, but we might be able to get him cheap, just a thought

The most suspended guy in nrl

 

[mikey]

With Naden signing, will the Cessna fly into the sunset given he had back surgery?

 

[426Tlgerland]

the dogs situation could be great for other clubs if they are doing a mass clean out , there are players you can get cheap I would think with dogs kicking in some funds if still under contract and these guys had a crap coach. Let’s face it Barrett was not very good at manly or dogs , Madge may well be the key to Naden and maybe another . Vaughan they say $ 100 k in super league well $ 200 k he may stay hear , that’s a cheap back up prop , Hetherington again part paid by dogs Madge could get him right , he is a top shelf player if the crap gets taken out of his game , again could be cheap he plays tough , Burton also could be a good pick up for any club , could be a good fullback or centre option , he may have a sneaky get out with Barrett gone ,

 

[old_man_tiger]

We should have a crack at Burton at least for a few months, like tpj at the pamfers. Would be handy in getting us back to 9th (which I'd take atm!)

 

[rihannafan1]

I guess LEE’s Fedora was right about plenty of movement after Magic Round

the dogs situation could be great for other clubs if they are doing a mass clean out , there are players you can get cheap I would think with dogs kicking in some funds if still under contract and these guys had a crap coach. Let’s face it Barrett was not very good at manly or dogs , Madge may well be the key to Naden and maybe another . Vaughan they say $ 100 k in super league well $ 200 k he may stay hear , that’s a cheap back up prop , Hetherington again part paid by dogs Madge could get him right , he is a top shelf player if the crap gets taken out of his game , again could be cheap he plays tough , Burton also could be a good pick up for any club , could be a good fullback or centre option , he may have a sneaky get out with Barrett gone ,

I wouldn't believe the Vaughan story. Sounded like journos having a tantrum because Vaughan had said something mean about them. As if an NRL team wouldn't offer him $200k. He's better than a fringe first-grader and that's what they earn.

 

[Spartan117]

Dogs.

Hetherington Maybe

Vaughan Definitely No.

 

[Red88_Tiger]

Dogs are lucky the dolphins are in the market to fill half a squad

 

[Spartan117]

Seyfarth is way over rated on here.

Guilty- I really appreciate Alex Seyfarth. He does his job with great effect and never gives up or stops.


Not every player has to be or can be Origin grade.

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]

Tigers making some good moves lately: Hastings, Api, Naden is decent - but most of all, landing Papalii for $600k, then standing firm & letting Sharks pay $575k for Nikora, is an underrated and rare W for the club.

 

[Camel2281]

Guilty- I really appreciate Alex Seyfarth. He does his job with great effect and never gives up or stops.


Not every player has to be or can be Origin grade.

I love his effort but he's a pretty poor backrower. His skill set suits playing as interchange prop but he's not got the size for it, nor the dynamism of a Rueben Cotter to make it work

 

[tony soprano]

Great runner, reader of the game, defender. Wish he was our fullback.

He's a bit too large and slow for fb I think

 

[SeanT]

Jeez not even bothered with Naden either way. Keen to hear how our offer to Crichton goes. It would make everyone actually think we can make the finals next year.

 

[2041]

They can laugh all they like - they’re paying 30% of his wage…
And he’s just the first - and one of the least paid….

Shits about to get real for them.

Dogs fans really living it up as if all getting rid of Brent Naden is the same thing as a complete roster overhaul. Fellas, if he's the guy who's out the door on day one, no fuss, it suggests he's probably not the worst contract on your books.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

With the Naden signing, I can only conclude that Matthew Komolafe (Eels NSW Cup winger) is now off our radar & Kade Dykes is for 2023 onwards (hopefully).

I think ultimately Naden & Talau will be our backup outside backs with Kepaoa & T'oa going on to secure our Centre positions. And hopefully Scolari on a development contract next season as a future wing replacement.

I'm on the fence about Jack Hetherington. Bulldogs would need to subsidise a large chunk and he comes with a lot of baggage & we'd be hoping Maguire/Sheens can turn him into a disciplined beast that refs don't even notice??? I think we are more in need of another forward leader if Tamou does retire. Depending on if our Joseph Tapine dream comes true soon, that may be Luke Thompson rather than JH.

 

[bathursttiger1]

Dogs are lucky the dolphins are in the market to fill half a squad

That’s correct but who are the Dogs going to sign?

 

[earl]

His skill set suits playing as interchange prop but he's not got the size for it, nor the dynamism of a Rueben Cotter to make it work

You are right but he has the motor to play that interchange prop role. The problem is we have Twal as well. You only need so many worker props.

 

[Red88_Tiger]

That’s correct but who are the Dogs going to sign?

I’m sure Gus has a plan🤣
But I really don’t care

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Guilty- I really appreciate Alex Seyfarth. He does his job with great effect and never gives up or stops.


Not every player has to be or can be Origin grade.

I never said every player needs to be origin grade.... That doesn't even happen for the top sides....

He doesn't do his job with great effect, he is solid in defence with lateral & hold down issues and is well below NRL standard with the ball.

He is a squad depth player that should be called upon every now and then at best - the fact that he is called upon every week / starting - really highlights our depth issues in the backrow which get worse next year.

 

[Fish88]

Tyrell Sloan must seriously be on the nose with Griffen at the dragons. Kid can play. If we have already secured Dykes then probably not required but could be a great fullback / wing option

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

I love his effort but he's a pretty poor backrower. His skill set suits playing as interchange prop but he's not got the size for it, nor the dynamism of a Rueben Cotter to make it work

His skill set currently is more aligned to the workhorse lock but without the offensive ball skills.
Right now he is dead last on mtrs v minutes within NRL players this year - never want to see that in a prop or backrower.