Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[weststigerman]

Flick the combover. Give us some hope.

Agree. Sheens should also be under pressure after this PR nightmare.

 

[gallagher]

2 board members from balmain that have no say, they are a waste of space.
That leaves the failure that is Magpies steering the ship
Together the JV is a marriage in failure

I can't argue with the last line

 

[Spartan117]

The roster that Madge built

Yep,

With very little money and a club culture based on 15 years of failure.

Who would wanna come here.

Now we got this roster and no coach.

Lucky we have Pascoe and Sheens

 

[Demps]

Are we still getting Siro & Sitaleki?

😂

 

[twentyforty]

Agree. Sheens should also be under pressure after this PR nightmare.

Who cares about the PR? This is a results business.
Show me the results!

 

[weststigerman]

Who cares about the PR? This is a results business.
Show me the results!

The PR is a big reason why coaches and players don’t want to come here hence the bad results.

 

[tony soprano]

Are we still getting Siro & Sitaleki?

😂

St Helens game on kayo sirro looked good

 

[tony soprano]

The PR is a big reason why coaches and players don’t want to come here hence the bad results.

That's why the coach is important.

You don't hire madge when you have PR like tigers.

 

[TurnStyle]

Clubs need players like Garner to fill the gaps and be salary cap compliant. With Garner in the side there was no need to carry a back on the bench. God help us, Maguire,s bench and now Noddy,s leave a lot to be desired. In the past, with the amount of time some benches got, we were basically playing with 16 against 17.

Great point.
One thing that drives me crazy is having a dummy half on the bench - who can only play that position.
A typical "number 14" I think is wise, but 3 forwards and another hooker makes for exactly the situation you mentioned and they too often find themselves in it.

 

[twentyforty]

Great point.
One thing that drives me crazy is having a dummy half on the bench - who can only play that position.
A typical "number 14" I think is wise, but 3 forwards and another hooker makes for exactly the situation you mentioned and they too often find themselves in it.

No choice if we don’t have a 80min hooker.

 

[tony soprano]

S

Agree. Sheens should also be under pressure after this PR nightmare.

Would be good to know if it was a sheens directive.

Pascoe and Lee seemed keen. Pascoe knows him.

 

[TurnStyle]

We have had a soft underbelly literally the whole time he has been a second rower here. Next to prop, the position where you need mongrel, power and intimidation the most. Next to Robert Jennings letting him go has made me the happiest that any WT decision has made me in a while.

He's no hard nut and yes, they definitely need to find some aggression.
I just like him. Some you do, some you just don't.
As I said, he wouldn't have been on a huge salary, was rarely injured (could be wrong), played out of position and didn't look to spit it.
No biggie his leaving but not a player I'd be moving heaven and earth to move on.

 

[TurnStyle]

No choice if we don’t have a 80min hooker.

Unsaid in my post, but that's my point. Hopefully that changes next year (Api) because it's a waste.

 

[BAGNF05]

He's no hard nut and yes, they definitely need to find some aggression.
I just like him. Some you do, some you just don't.
As I said, he wouldn't have been on a huge salary, was rarely injured (could be wrong), played out of position and didn't look to spit it.
No biggie his leaving but not a player I'd be moving heaven and earth to move on.

We have plenty of mediocre guys, hence our position in rugby league. Also rans.

 

[Balmainlegend]

I’m going to miss the rubbish talk about Ciraldo and Burton nonsense 😂😂

 

[twentyforty]

Gotta get some sleep now. It’s been fun. WT sure does provide the laughs. 😂

 

[TurnStyle]

We have plenty of mediocre guys, hence our position in rugby league. Also rans.

Okay. Next.

 

[jadtiger]

Just a friendly warning to all my fellow WT supporters "Don't go close to any sharp knives or near any high cliffs in the next few weeks" Visits to the reptile park near Gosford are also not recommended

 

[Camel2281]

Sign the Fiji fullback

 

[Tigers_Wests]

Sign the Fiji fullback

He just re-signed for 2 more years with the Panthers.