The Sin Bin

[tig_prmz]

I only just finished watching the highlights, but that sin bin was surely an awful call.. might be ok with a Penalty but he's hit him before the ball has made contact with the boot. Not reckless or late.

And since they score off the same play, doesn't that negate the offence any way? If someone commits a professional foul and they end up scoring, they don't still get sin binned.

Wonder how the NRL explains this one

 

[TieDye]

Still searching. NRL saying they misread the rules. ARL saying "nothing we can do" and Nonutssley on Monday morning: "consistent not fair…”

 

[TieDye]

If that was on Brooks or even Hastings we would be, undoubtedly, lucky to get a penalty.

 

[Speed2burn]

put it this way I reckon we’d be lucky to get a penalty if the shoe was on the other foot

Moses hit brooks with a swinging arm late in the game.. bunker had plenty of time to intervene and didn’t

Nrl sucks

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

End of the day Mata made a rookie mistake and didn’t go in with arms. He was always going to be in significant trouble especially with an Oscar award winner in Moses on the other side of it.

Shoulder charge on a ball kicker is a sin bin most games these days.

 

[Fraze23]

I think we copped dud calls all night. The worst had to be off the kick off when Gutherson clearly grounded the ball in his own ingoal, then we get penalised off the first tackle...

 

[the_third]

A shoulder charge to the kicker is a send off

 

[Moh]

Only watched it a couple of times, really didn't look like a shoulder charge to me.

 

[Aceshigh]

Not a sin bin for mine

 

[Demps]

Yeah, the refereeing is always garbage.

That ref in particular is a dork.

 

[426Tlgerland]

I feel we are same as lasst season , no rub of the green Mosses on brooks clear penalty but we get nothing , The sin bin was probably harsh as it was not late just no arm wrap , and Parra laid all over us and nothing again , and I’m not sure if it’s my eyes but Mahonnys for Parra 80 % of his passes are forward one he passed on this side of the line but the player catches it a mtr on the other side of it , where are the lines people

 

[Demps]

Brooks shoulda laid down after the Moses slap


I think the way he bounced off like it was nothing and played on like no effect really hindered it.

Bunker could of and should of intervened also.

 

[426Tlgerland]

Spot on demps the bunker needed to come into it , but hay it’s the tigers so it’s missed

 

[Tcat]

Hopefully Moses on report for taking Brooks's head off and then having a joke about it with the ref. He really is a smug little bastard.

 

[tigerbenji]

I think we copped dud calls all night. The worst had to be off the kick off when Gutherson clearly grounded the ball in his own ingoal, then we get penalised off the first tackle...

That happened right in front of where I was sitting, bad call by the Ref.

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

I thought he got binned because it was a shoulder charge on the kicker. I was in the hill and couldn’t see the screen that well but that was my take

 

[LARDS]

I didn't think it was a shoulder charge. More of a shirt front at worst. With a push. Possibly a penalty if a try wasn't scored. Definitely not a sin bin.
Ruined what could have been a close game.
If it wasn't the tigers it's play on.

 

[Eternal Tiger]

Brooks shoulda laid down after the Moses slap


I think the way he bounced off like it was nothing and played on like no effect really hindered it.

Bunker could of and should of intervened also.

2secs later Brooks incorrectly plays the ball. Classic Brooks

 

[gallagher]

End of the day Mata made a rookie mistake and didn’t go in with arms. He was always going to be in significant trouble especially with an Oscar award winner in Moses on the other side of it.

Shoulder charge on a ball kicker is a sin bin most games these days.

Sin bin every day of the week

 

[1eyedmel]

Yeah, the refereeing is always garbage.

That ref in particular is a dork.

Every time I see that ref I think he is walking around with a large pole up his arse.