Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[weststigerman]

Update on Brandon tumeth contract.

Apparently it has all been soughted so it's still going to be a 2yr deal worth just over 200k. Happy days.

Are you allowed to play a top 30 player 62k or 110k? I thought the minimum wage was above that?

 

[The SHADOW]

Are you allowed to play a top 30 player 62k or 110k? I thought the minimum wage was above that?

its All grey, unless you have a good accountant, why , how much are trial and train on.

 

[Deleted member 3518]

Are you allowed to play a top 30 player 62k or 110k? I thought the minimum wage was above that?

It’s 110k minimum . The development contracts are like 88k I think

 

[batboy]

Update on Brandon tumeth contract.

Apparently it has all been soughted so it's still going to be a 2yr deal worth just over 200k. Happy days.

200K all up I hope?
He's barely played Reserve grade.

 

[supercoach]

Fox Sports.

Ben Gardiner, who is the Tigers current assistant and stood in as head coach on Sunday, has reportedly been informed his services won’t be required in 2023.

I would have given him the top job in front of Benji. I have watched him closely for a couple of seasons now and he seems to have a great connection with the players and is well respected .

 

[batboy]

I don’t, easily our best winger!

Depends how he feels that day....
And which shot the cameraman gets.

His attitude is crap - Has been for a long time...
Needs a reality check.

 

[batboy]

But for the next 2 years there's the need for another hooker. Simpkin still has a role to play here.

Rua is also signed for as long as Simpkin is...

 

[yeti]

Don't think I'd want him at 6 here either and that's the only way you'd get him.

Needs to drop about 10 kg to be an effective 6.

Maybe an incentive based contract would work. Really need to be careful with this type of player. We've been burned before.

 

[yeti]

To be honest... next year with Api he is likely to play 80mins or close to...
So i'd be focussing on Rua Ngatikaura as that hybrid hooker/middle forward role.

To be honest, I also have seen more from Brown than I have from Simkins

 

[tigerballs]

I don’t believe our halves trust them. A. They’re leaving and B. They mostly just plod. Prime example Kelma clearly over ran Brooks on that pass meaning the only option was to hit him low on the right hip and the rest was history. Should not have passed it but probably won’t next time.

I think he was meant to be running decoy and Brooks passed it to him anyway. That happens.

 

[hank37w]

Wow

Sheens has hours of footage of the young guns identified as coming through that he has sent Benji.

Hope they don't get a knock on the door from the AFP.

 

[The SHADOW]

Sorry that’s multi skilling for ya

 

[rihannafan1]

Fox Sports.

Ben Gardiner, who is the Tigers current assistant and stood in as head coach on Sunday, has reportedly been informed his services won’t be required in 2023.

A coaching pathway for one and the rest can stay in reserves. Gardiner will be one that goes on to coach firsts elsewhere imo.

 

[Camel2281]

I don't know what we can possibly gain from this.

What if he does an ACL or has more concussions in the finals? He becomes less valuable to us even though he has a guaranteed salary.

If it goes well, he might try and stay there and there is no way Melbourne will pay for his full contract value.

Funny that no other club agreed to this other than Wests Tigers.

$100k saving is what we gain for a bloke who's playing reserve grade

 

[rihannafan1]

Simpkin is 20. You'd have to be a freak physically to be going well at 9 at that age, let alone have the talent. Put Rua or Tallyn there when they're 20 and I doubt they're any better

 

[Camel2281]

Hey mate any idea why Simpkin not getting a go over Peachy

I'd say that it's in Jake's best interest to be playing 80mins a week in Cup than 25 minutes in NRL. He missed so much development due to Covid

 

[barnzee]

Simpkin is 20. You'd have to be a freak physically to be going well at 9 at that age, let alone have the talent. Put Rua or Tallyn there when they're 20 and I doubt they're any better

Rua is 22 mate 23 next year

 

[Camel2281]

Are you allowed to play a top 30 player 62k or 110k? I thought the minimum wage was above that?

120 is minimum but development contract is 62k. Might be 200 over the 2 yrs with 2024 top 30

 

[barnzee]

To be honest, I also have seen more from Brown than I have from Simkins

And so you should Simpkin is 20 mate Brown is 28

 

[craigtob]

But if this loan benefits us and we get a better player back after been there why not go through with it? There is no way the tigers are sitting there going oh god poor storm are in trouble they have so many injuries we have to help them out. They are going this is an opportunity to give a player we have contracted long term experience at at far superior club and gain skills that will benefit from in the long run. I guarantee nofo comes back a better player next year with finals experience

This will definitely end bad for us.
Using your words,he is a experience player indeed,will he come back? I don’t think so.
Why would he?
He is still under contract with us until 2025.
He is going to a great club that wants him
And leaving a club that doesn’t mmmmm what would you choose?
I know what I would do!