Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

I can't rate Kemmer as a top tier front row like Tapine , Nelson , JFH , RCG ,
these guys are all 800k -1mill value . Klemmer at best is next level down like
500 k -600 k Max. How old is he ? Is he another on the back 9 of his career
Tamou was and Packer the less said the better . I know we are not likely to land the top guys but don't mix our forward recruitment with our half's plan .
We need 3 top class half's on our roster . Douehi and Hastings lots of guile but no speed . If Brooks gone what is our spine?
 
Kaito said:
Jedi, with all due respect I seldomly
Talk about the Brooks situation
Let alone bash him. I'm happy if
He stays, happy if he goes bro -
I'm backing the coaching and the
Recruitment unit to make that call.
I've just noticed you've got a target
On Doueihi's back, I'm just letting
You know that It's noted and a bit
Hypocritical - to the point where I've
Started to question the intentions
Behind it. A lot of punters on here
Are fed up with 10 or so years of
Brooks and inconsistencies,
Imo their argument is more warranted
Than the Doueihi talk, just saying
Click to expand...
Hmm, are you suggesting what I think you're suggesting.
 
Stevec said:
I can't rate Kemmer as a top tier front row like Tapine , Nelson , JFH , RCG ,
these guys are all 800k -1mill value . Klemmer at best is next level down like
500 k -600 k Max. How old is he ? Is he another on the back 9 of his career
Tamou was and Packer the less said the better . I know we are not likely to land the top guys but don't mix our forward recruitment with our half's plan .
We need 3 top class half's on our roster . Douehi and Hastings lots of guile but no speed . If Brooks gone what is our spine?
Click to expand...
Moses needs to be who we get if Brooks goes, can't run with Hastings and douhie as our halves pairing
7. Moses 6. Douhie
or
7. Brooks 6. Moses
 
Kaito said:
Jedi, with all due respect I seldomly
Talk about the Brooks situation
Let alone bash him. I'm happy if
He stays, happy if he goes bro -
I'm backing the coaching and the
Recruitment unit to make that call.
I've just noticed you've got a target
On Doueihi's back, I'm just letting
You know that It's noted and a bit
Hypocritical - to the point where I've
Started to question the intentions
Behind it. A lot of punters on here
Are fed up with 10 or so years of
Brooks and inconsistencies,
Imo their argument is more warranted
Than the Doueihi talk, just saying
Click to expand...


We we should not pass judgement on AD or anyone until 10 years at WT?
 
batboy said:
Mate, No other half has EVER been afforded any excuse for poor games here....
Has to go across the board no?

Funny most happy to point out how bad Brooks is are usually the first to point out why
Doueihi might be in a slump...

Last time he was coming back from an ACL, He was Souths best player - Helping them deep into the finals...
Click to expand...

Can't agree with that.
Brooks whole career at WTs has been littered with excuses. I know I have offered plenty over the years.
JT not allowing him to play eyes up footy.
Farah Moses ,and Benji stifling his game.
Farah Liddle and every other DH slow service.
Rubbish forward pack to play behind ( valid)
His personality, the rest of the squad, Maguire..

Douehi s form has been poor since returning and I think that has been fairly acknowledged by even his biggest supporters.
 
Telltails said:
Can't agree with that.
Brooks whole career at WTs has been littered with excuses. I know I have offered plenty over the years.
JT not allowing him to play eyes up footy.
Farah Moses ,and Benji stifling his game.
Farah Liddle and every other DH slow service.
Rubbish forward pack to play behind ( valid)
His personality, the rest of the squad, Maguire..

Douehi s form has been poor since returning and I think that has been fairly acknowledged by even his biggest supporters.
Click to expand...

Sure, who replaces Brooks tho, without naming Hastings who come to the club last year.

No decent 7 have wanted to come to our club.
 
Telltails said:
Can't agree with that.
Brooks whole career at WTs has been littered with excuses. I know I have offered plenty over the years.
JT not allowing him to play eyes up footy.
Farah Moses ,and Benji stifling his game.
Farah Liddle and every other DH slow service.
Rubbish forward pack to play behind ( valid)
His personality, the rest of the squad, Maguire..

Douehi s form has been poor since returning and I think that has been fairly acknowledged by even his biggest supporters.
Click to expand...
AD since returning had the good game against St Merge and Brisbane
All 3 played well against cowboys
just hope 23 we at least let Sheens run with all 3 and see what can be done. I think two running five eigths could be difficult to defend against with Hastings playing in the middle
If Brooks goes in 2024 then so be it just throwing we get Moses in to replace him at 7, we should not strengthen Newcastle in 23 by giving them a 7
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 625 (members: 5, guests: 620)
Back
Top