Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Fingers83]

No your exactly right ......going to Melbourne wasn't to try and take step forwards to better their career ...it was a like for like move ...wasn't it .....just remind me ...how many times have the storm missed the 8 since 2011 again

JAC had already signed with Melbourne for the year following his stint with the tigers. He was released by the sharks and picked up on a 1 year deal at WT.

 

[happy_tiger]

JAC had already signed with Melbourne for the year following his stint with the tigers. He was released by the sharks and picked up on a 1 year deal at WT.

He signed with Melbourne mid season after he signed with us ......can still remember the arguments about whether he was a good enough defender on the WTF ......if memory serves someone at the helm was on holidays ....again .....Grant Mayer

 

[Eternal Tiger]

Liam Martin, Lienu, Cam Murray we’re all juniors playing reggies at one point!
All I seem to hear is let’s stop buying these over priced has beens and blood from within......then it’s no let’s get klemmer he has these stats and would ad starch to our pack.
Can’t have it both ways. Think back to the 05 days and we had Galea, Fulton, Harrison, Skando, Gibbs Then Fifita, Woods, Tapau.
They were all juniors I believe!
Buying Klemmer and blocking the path for a local junior is the reason we see so much talent move elsewhere.
But hey his stats say it all don’t they.

He signed with Melbourne mid season after he signed with us ......can still remember the arguments about whether he was a good enough defender on the WTF ......if memory serves someone at the helm was on holidays ....again .....Grant Mayer

No, it was Pascoe 🤦‍♂️

 

[gallagher]

JAC had already signed with Melbourne for the year following his stint with the tigers. He was released by the sharks and picked up on a 1 year deal at WT.

Bs

 

[Odessa]

No, it was Pascoe 🤦‍♂️

And he wanted 180K a season to stay

 

[tiger05premier]

Quality wingers won't stay if they can't get quality ball and field position ...I guess JAC and Koroibete are proof to that fact ...if we don't fix the forwards issues and the definite spine issues we have ...no one of quality in the outside backs will ever come

JAC went to a bulldogs team that were crap in every position on the field

 

[tony soprano]

JAC went to a bulldogs team that were crap in every position on the field

Time to get over JAC

 

[Fingers83]

From The Mole..

Klemmer/Brooks swap deal not happening. Klemmer could still be at concord in 23, Brooks still likely headed to Newcastle in 24.

Story here

 

[earl]

a bloke who I had seen close up in 1986 being in the same Qld schoolboy side

Renouf is one of my all time favorite players. You must have played footy at a pretty high level.

 

[earl]

I guess JAC and Koroibete are proof to that fact

I completely disagree mate. They left because we didn't value them. Koro is to me heaps better than Tedesco. I think he is on a different level.

We just let him walk.

 

[earl]

What “proof” do koroibete or JAC add to your opinion… neither left for any reason remotely close to what you’re suggesting..

More history revisionists

100% correct. They both left because we didn't rate them. Unbelievable.

 

[Fingers83]

100% correct. They both left because we didn't rate them. Unbelievable.

I remember the JAC game against the broncos where he absolutely smoked everyone for a length of the field try. It was so clear then that he was a mega talent. How can a whole first grade football department miss it?

Unforgivable

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I remember the JAC game against the broncos where he absolutely smoked everyone for a length of the field try. It was so clear then that he was a mega talent. How can a whole first grade football department miss it?

Unforgivable

I've read a couple of comments suggesting Dominic Young is just a winger. Rinse and repeat anyone. Young is an oustanding talent and x factor gamebreaker.

 

[the_third]

I've read a couple of comments suggesting Dominic Young is just a winger. Rinse and repeat anyone. Young is an oustanding talent and x factor gamebreaker.

hey paws - you know our juniors pretty well. if we sign Dom Young, who do you think we can expect to leave the club?

 

[tony soprano]

Renouf is one of my all time favorite players. You must have played footy at a pretty high level.

I'll never forgot that footage of that run think in GF against ST George an all time run.

 

[tiger05premier]

Time to get over JAC

I'm over him

 

[tony soprano]

I'm over him

Goes missing in tough games. Ciraldo may help him. Reports he does lots of mind work with the players.

 

[earl]

I'll never forgot that footage of that run think in GF against ST George an all time run.

He was so good. I remember him playing the Tigers in one game and every time he touched the ball he busted us.

 

[happy_tiger]

JAC went to a bulldogs team that were crap in every position on the field

For fullback money just remember .....

 

[TheDaBoss]

NFL news | Former Wests Tigers junior Etuale Lui gunning for place in NFL | The Mole Exclusive