Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

twentyforty said:
When you mention our young forwards coming through, why no mention of Stefano 33 games and Shawn 18 games?
These two were great additions by Maguire. If you exclude the 3 games totalling 11 minutes off the bench for Eels both got their start at WT. couple of legends in the making there!
Click to expand...
Because stefano is already a 1st grader , while blore is in the unknown bunch having not played for nearly two years . I don’t think that take much working out
 
liltiger said:
Matamua looks like a great prospect aswell, just young and needs to learn how to curb his aggression. He will get it sorted in time.
Click to expand...

He has the key word potential.

In an honest not hopeful assessment on his 22 nrl run he didn’t show any NRL qualities, he was found out & if anything cost us badly.

Hopefully next few years he progresses and his potential translates into an NRL quality forward but as it stands he is a long way off NRL quality from last years form.
 
Many talk about culture, Penrith have it in spades. Jack Gibson recognised the importance of bonding the side off the field. He made the guys don suits, for special occasions to lift their profile and esteem. He has regular BBQ's for players and partners. I would not expect the Tigers to be that extreme, but getting the players together away from the game helps build that culture.
 
I remember pre Xmas there were reports of Moses and Douhei training together at Holy Cross ?
Does anyone know if they still getting together occasionally or was that only in lieu of formal training not having started for them ( after WC)?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
The_Patriot said:
Exactly. It's about correcting where the club has gone wrong not great coaching on game day
Click to expand...
Short term pain for long term gain, we know through experience Sheens can set things up so the club is stable in the future with a great production line of talent, it's then about looking after and maintaining the systems implemented and not letting everything turn to water like it recently has.
 
twentyforty said:
Maguire is a premiership coach, but comparing his time at WT with that of a coaching legend like Tim Sheens who is yet to coach a single game, is unfair. To start with Maguire arrived facing a club in big trouble. The CEO and previous Coach feuding and unhappy boardroom which spilt over to a lack of support to Maguire, who battled to balance a cap in terrible shape while being undermined by the board.
The thing to remember about Maguire's tenure is that he left the club in much better shape than he found it and that's his legacy.
Sheens otoh has 2 years to build on Maguires legacy, with a much easier run, particularly in terms of the cap.
Click to expand...
Sheens was here for a decade and did all those things and won a comp. Also producing some of the best talent running around in the game now.
 
Mighty_Tiger said:
He has the key word potential.

In an honest not hopeful assessment on his 22 nrl run he didn’t show any NRL qualities, he was found out & if anything cost us badly.

Hopefully next few years he progresses and his potential translates into an NRL quality forward but as it stands he is a long way off NRL quality from last years form.
Click to expand...
No doubt when he was on the pitch last year was prob not ready for an nrl start and was thrust into it due to necessity with injuries, iv got no doubt the potential is there, but like so many others it will be realised or squandered.
 
liltiger said:
We need tradesmen type players, no frills who get the job done, like Heighno and Liam Fulton
Click to expand...
I'd rather have transcendent, once in a generation talent or, failing that, obvious rep calibre. But there's also a place for solid first grade standard footballers, sure. I'm just not sure how successful a club is likely to be if its recruitment policy is to deliberately target slightly better than average.
 
sleeve said:
Many talk about culture, Penrith have it in spades. Jack Gibson recognised the importance of bonding the side off the field. He made the guys don suits, for special occasions to lift their profile and esteem. He has regular BBQ's for players and partners. I would not expect the Tigers to be that extreme, but getting the players together away from the game helps build that culture.
Click to expand...
You know what else Penrith have? Really talented footballers. I'd start by looking for those and sort out the card nights and dress code when we've got them.
 
SeanT said:
Except for one game Farnsworth put it all over Kotoni staggs.

AJ and Toa weren't starved of defence, where I'd like to pint out they were poor. AJ and Toa arnt even nrl quality centres. Farnsworth is an international in that position.
Click to expand...

Demps said:
I think there's a clear plan here.

Both off contract, both have been underwhelming - one quite longer than the other.

I think the coaching staff will see how both fire and then make a judgemental call.

One or the other , maybe both - maybe neither...

It'll be an interesting season nonetheless.
Contract season for both + Laurie.
That's bulk of the spine.

Balls in their court.
Click to expand...
My honest opinion is AD WILL be in centres for best part of the year Daine to be 5/8, Brooks 7 once season get rolling. Based on performance and of course attitude of all 3 will decide on who gets rewarded, can't help but think Sheens & Benji wouldn't take kindly to a player personally demanding which position he is to play if Mosses does sign I feel Adam will either move on or be let go
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
There is a lot of attention given to Sheens but I just read this article and apologise if it has been posted before. Marshall's comments are poignant and his referral to team bonding is imo significant. It is always interesting to read the thoughts of our next coach so WTs (and its supporters) are in a very interesing position.

www.nrl.com

Marshall: Why Wests Tigers are ready to rise

Benji Marshall has pleaded with Wests Tigers fans to 'stick with him' as the rookie coach revealed a new era is dawning at Concord.
www.nrl.com www.nrl.com
Click to expand...
I wonder why Benji sees team bonding as such a challenge?
 
Earl said:
He looks like a ball player which makes him different to a lot of players and that makes him stand out a bit. I also think he has a lot of work to do as well but you never know.
Click to expand...
Anyone new who knows how to pass, particularly in traffic, is bound to have attracted some attention during the last few seasons. Lol
 
Luke Brooks #1 Fan said:
2UgdMtp.png


That's Justin Matamua right? He's looking bigger and hopefully that means he's stronger and more ready for NRL.
Click to expand...
Yeah the dude in that pic looks like Asu Kepaoa .. ??

But back to Justin Matamua is he big enough for the NRL or will he be just another light weight forward with hype from the juniors .. ??
 
Bucko73 said:
My honest opinion is AD WILL be in centres for best part of the year Daine to be 5/8, Brooks 7 once season get rolling. Based on performance and of course attitude of all 3 will decide on who gets rewarded, can't help but think Sheens & Benji wouldn't take kindly to a player personally demanding which position he is to play if Mosses does sign I feel Adam will either move on or be let go
Click to expand...
Yeh it annoys me when players want positions but arnt good enough to warrant them.

1. Stains
4. Douhie
6.laurie
7. Brooks is way more rounded and gives us more attacking threats. However Brooks can't be the only kicker. Not sure if Daine has a long kicking game.
 
Anyone give us an update on the players performances at training? Who looks good, backline positions ideas? Are aken and Nofo sureties for the wings?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 618 (members: 20, guests: 598)
Back
Top