Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tigermate]

Well he is certainly in like company then.
Stef, Blore, Laurie, yet to establish themselves after different levels of hype. Will be interesting to see who steps up if any do at all. Then it will be the age old arguement player or coach...

Stef and Blore haven't been on the field long enough bc of injuries however at least they have locked positions.

Stef in the limited game time has lived up to the hype (or thereabouts) for me, when he has played.

Blore - started well, got injured, came back and was a bit average, got injured, so yes this year he'll either prove he's on the up and up or level out.

Laurie - i'd agree with you but he's only played 1 or 2 seasons? can't recall and he has been our voted players player for those years right? again can't remember.

 

[Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan]

I agree with a lot of this. At his best he is just an average first grader. Moses Mybe is way faster than Douhie. It’s Douhie’s lack of pace that puts a low ceiling on what he’ll be able to achieve in his first grade career. We should let him play out the season and let him move on. The money could be better used elsewhere.

Sorry but I disagree. Moses Mbye is terrible. Doueihi can create points. Mbye parades on the field pretending to be a footballer.

 

[sleeve]

please tell me what you would rate him out of 10, in what position would you play him, and provide some examples which back up your position.

He talks the the talk- Not much else.

 

[tigermate]

Was just a throw away comment.
Sorry bro, not getting into it 2night ...

all good legend... just interested in what I have missed in all the games i've watched as a die hard fan.

 

[tigermate]

Sorry but I disagree. Moses Mbye is terrible. Doueihi can create points. Mbye parades on the field pretending to be a footballer.

I reckon he's got 8 games to prove himself and win another contract at a good price for himself ... or he's moving on.

 

[Tucker]

I'd like nofo gone if someone would take up the contract.
Think Feledy will be a gun in a few years

Feledy has my attention.
Tough looking bugger with big wraps.
Hopefully see a bit of him this year.

 

[tigermate]

Do Brooks next...

haha.

Brooks has no voice, has poor game management, has a poor short kicking game and has been very low on confidence... but...

He's a solid defender, with a a good running game, reasonably ok kicking game (attacking kicks to corners for wingers is ok, long kicks ok, grubber kicks for drop outs not so great), he always try's his best and has stuck solid with the club.

He's a running half back or running 5/8... but he needs a leader around him in the halves like a moses, or hooker being Api, who can be the voice, direct the game management and take over short kicking game and pump up his tyres to give him confidence.

If you want him for the other stuff you're wasting your time and only going to make his confidence worse.

And he's probably worth $650K - $750K for that role.

 

[earl]

With Tupou, Ngutlik, Bula, Scolari and Hill there is genuine depth now of young quick backs. A coaching team who will make full use of them if they put in the effort.

Which one of them will prove to be a top tier player ? Will any of them ?

 

[sleeve]

Sorry but I disagree. Moses Mbye is terrible. Doueihi can create points. Mbye parades on the field pretending to be a footballer.

He is an average kicker, and can throw a decent pass, he is awkward to tackle . Against that, he also throws some terrible passes, has an overated and telegraphed kicking game, takes the wrong option on the edge, can't tackle and is a ball hog.

 

[earl]

You guys are gonna shit your collective
beds when he's named co-captain haha

I'll be fine with AD and Brooks sharing the captaincy.

 

[The_Patriot]

the hate, or objective criticism as I have made several examples of his game that would be difficult to argue with, comes from the guy wanting $950K and most on here, including the media, think that we should "build a team around him"...

he's had what, 3 seasons here, playing in 3 or 4 different positions, hasnt been able to lock one down, hasn't shown us that he can turn a game on his own... etc etc...

at some point you have to let them go and try someone else. how long does the hope of "potential" last? 4 seasons, 5 seasons, 9 seasons (brooks?) ... because every pre-season will be different and we quickly forget about the seasons before us, which is why we end up in a loop of mediocrity.... players underperform, everyone thinks they're terrible, the season ends, we wait around like lemons for preseason, we are busting to watch footy again, preseason starts and we get hopeful again because we're fans and totally biased and forget about last season because this season "will be different".

I want to win. period.

Stopped reading after you mentioned him wanting 950k.

I'm a busy man, no time for the he wants too much so I now hate him crowd.

Cheers

 

[WT46]

if we miss hopefully theres a Pom post or media release (we thought we had him) so we know to move on.

Oh that’s probably coming next Thursday or wait maybe next Friday

 

[hank37w]

Can we please start a Casey jones thread

Casey Jones was no where near the great guy that they make him out to be.

Did you ever see him give fireman Wally a drive.

 

[tigermate]

Stopped reading after you mentioned him wanting 950k.

I'm a busy man, no time for the he wants too much so I now hate him crowd.

Cheers

he does want $950K though... but that's not why i don't rate him.... I wish he was worth $1.2M and playing for us!

my reference to the money was to state a position that he is over hyped - by the media, by the fans on here and by his own ego - because he is the one wanting that money.

 

[Wiz]

Sorry but I disagree. Moses Mbye is terrible. Doueihi can create points. Mbye parades on the field pretending to be a footballer.

I never said Mybe was good. He wasn’t. But the original poster said Douhie was faster than Mybe which, in my opinion only, is not correct. I believe Mybe is a much faster runner than Douhie. Both are average players only at their best though (also only my opinion).

 

[tigertuff]

He is an average kicker, and can throw a decent pass, he is awkward to tackle . Against that, he also throws some terrible passes, has an overated and telegraphed kicking game, takes the wrong option on the edge, can't tackle and is a ball hog.

And prioritizes looking for a lost mouth guard over making a tackle.

 

[tigermate]

I'll be fine with AD and Brooks sharing the captaincy.

would never make AD captain ... only because if by round 8 he doesn't have a contract that he deems worthy from us he'll be totally anti the club.

 

[Speed2burn]

With Tupou, Ngutlik, Bula, Scolari and Hill there is genuine depth now of young quick backs. A coaching team who will make full use of them if they put in the effort.

Reality is we might only be ale to squeeze out 1 possibly 2 regular first graders out of that lot. The step up from being a talented junior to 1st grade is huge

Unless you’re in the Penrith system … by the time Cleary is ready to retire I’m sure they’ll have a ready made replacement who is just as good

 

[old_man_tiger]

I have a large supply of popcorn and beer,could be a really fun day/night

Poured a Jameson, I fear it won't be enough.
Can't say anything about Doueihi or Brooks anymore haha.

Both were amongst the worst halves we've ever had in our colours last year (yes I know how bad some have been) and the worst in the comp. They have a nice splintery spoon to prove it.

Choose your excuses etc.... but fact is they need to perform and we should ALL be hoping they kill it or get the chop, nothing else is acceptable.

Edited to remove the alcohol talking.

 

[clontarfkid]

This has to be his year, there are no more excuses for him, he has the pack now, I agree he needs to perform or should go. But I have a funny feeling he will sign a new deal early on in the new year, without having to perform for it, if Benji wants him then I can see them offering him a new deal soon. I would prefer he earnt it though, or go.

That's my biggest fear re Benji calling the shots..a quick sugar hit of PR particularly if we lose Moses announcing that we managed Brooks career into a one club player with a x year extension blah blah...when in fact most want Brooks to actually earn it
Gotta be the luckiest to ever play the game