Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Halbrowne61]

Great tape BT1, there was another highlight reel I saw from 2013-2021 which highlighted amongst other things,how many tries he scored. I have heard Sheens say a couple of times he wants him to score more tries this year. Will be interesting to see if that comes to fruition.

 

[hammertime]

The club should take some reponsibilty for what they coached out of him. That there, is one bloody good half.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

I told myself I’d no longer comment on Brooks but can we please stop hanging on to one game from 10 years ago….

 

[diedpretty]

I told myself I’d no longer comment on Brooks but can we please stop hanging on to one game from 10 years ago….

Why dont you read the proceeding posts that outlined a history - or maybe you are just another one of the i want it now generation.

 

[balmain boy]

But there’s a difference between Munster and Moses. Munster didn’t actually go to market therefore no rival club could legally make him an offer. I understand where you’re coming from though and I agree with ya. But I can’t compare the two as Moses whether willingly or not is on the market and is considering his options, while Munster re-signed with the Storm 2 or 3 days before any rival club could’ve made him an offer.

Actually, the Storm gave him permission to talk to other clubs, so the whole thing could get wrapped up sooner.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

Why dont you read the proceeding posts that outlined a history - or maybe you are just another one of the i want it now generation.

Well 10 years of no finals you’re right in saying I want it now 😂😂

 

[Halbrowne61]

I told myself I’d no longer comment on Brooks but can we please stop hanging on to one game from 10 years ago….

I see your point and I for one have not been a huge Brooks fan iof late but if we were able to recreate his old attitude to the game then we would all benefit.
Maybe it’s too late now but it certainly felt good to see him on the start of his career and what might have been.
But maybe it’s not. I don’t mind a bit of day dreaming. Let’s see what happens this year.

 

[gallagher]

I see your point and I for one have not been a huge Brooks fan iof late but if we were able to recreate his old attitude to the game then we would all benefit.
Maybe it’s too late now but it certainly felt good to see him on the start of his career and what might have been.
But maybe it’s not. I don’t mind a bit of day dreaming. Let’s see what happens this year.

It's eternal hope but you gotta be positive at the start of the year. There is reasonable hope this year.

 

[balmain boy]

Pretty crazy too, if my memory serves me correct Brooks by passed NYC (the under 20s at the time) and reserve grade and was accelerated to first grade. Cannot be the best development pathway.

He didn't bypass them. He went from SG ball to Flegg, played half the season on Flegg before getting promoted to NSW Cup, where he again dominated and then got his callup against the Saints.

Moses had a much smaller frame so he took a bit longer to get promoted, he only got called up to NSW cup when Brooks went to NRL and likewise killed it in NSW Cup.

Brooks didn't play a full season or two of Flegg, but the top players rarely do. If you're good enough you're old enough

 

[Yossarian]

I wish I saw Brooks as a junior. I'm sure it's nothing like he has been the last few years I suspect a lot has been coached out of him.

I saw him play for Balmain SG Ball against Central Coast. I think he was coming back from injury but I thought Moses looked much better at the time.

 

[Yossarian]

First time commenter long time reader -
Its rough to get a read on the moses situation. Miks rugby league page on instagram reckons Mitch has already re-signed with the Eels and just waiting for it to be registered by the NRL to be announced and his oil is pretty spot on in the past, also seems pretty confident shutting down any commenter who thinks otherwise, then again they said it would be announced this week just gone and it hasnt.. nothings official until its official but man i wish it would be announced one way or the other now so we can either move on or bring him into our plans.

I’m not saying he’s wrong but he’s been pushing that since 4 Jan and here we are a month and a day later and nada. I really don’t think a club needs to wait for the NRL to register a contract for a re-signing.

 

[tony soprano]

He didn't bypass them. He went from SG ball to Flegg, played half the season on Flegg better getting promoted to NSW Cup, where he again dominated and then got his callup against the Saints.

Moses had a much smaller frame so he took a bit longer to get promoted, he only got called up to NSW cup when Brooks went to NRL and likewise killed it in NSW Cup.

Brooks didn't play a full session or two of Flegg, but the top players rarely do. If you're good enough you're old enough

Holding them back a bit not a bad thing in my opinion.

Regardless wad not the root cause with Brooks which is the 4 coaches that proceeded ruined his game in my opinion.

 

[jirskyr]

The club should take some reponsibilty for what they coached out of him. That there, is one bloody good half.

That's one game. He'll have played 200 more after this season is done. Tim Sheens will be his 5th coach.

I don't know how you explain 4 different coaches over 10 seasons individually and collectively coached good footy "out of him".

The easier explanation is he just can't maintain the standard he set at his debut, and you don't get many chances to surprise your opposition.

 

[LeichhardtTiger]

That's one game. He'll have played 200 more after this season is done. Tim Sheens will be his 5th coach.

I don't know how you explain 4 different coaches over 10 seasons individually and collectively coached good footy "out of him".

The easier explanation is he just can't maintain the standard he set at his debut, and you don't get many chances to surprise your opposition.

In otherwords,"Brooks is OK cos I say so" Thanks Jerky

 

[clontarfkid]

Why dont you read the proceeding posts that outlined a history - or maybe you are just another one of the i want it now generation.ILet me see..how long have we been paying him????

II want that level of performance NOW and the ensuing10 years ago based on his debut and the windfall $$ that have gone in his direction subsequently only to regress backwards almost every year..to the point were now spooners,with worst attack in nRL..and hes stillthe 7
Brooks is finally on notice from the club. to perform his future renewal shldnt be dictated to by I Moses manager yet again, but by WTs based on his form and wher it resembles the success of 10 years ago

 

[Snidest 0]

Moses’s having a massive ego mixed with some real skill will love the challenge of being the top gun. Latrell said one of the reasons he knocked us back was he did not want the expectations that go with the salary, Moses is a different breed, he will thrive on it

Pfffft!!

Latrell loves the limelight!

Just didn't want to play for us!

 

[Tigers_Wests]

Their best Junior imo (Joey O’Neill) wont hang around now they have signed and given a top 30 spot to the young Bronco. O’Neill is better than any of our Flegg & Reggies halves. He is just one of several outstanding players they will lose.

Wonder if this is who Buzz is talking about?

 

[Demps]

Wonder if this is who Buzz is talking about?
View attachment 4346

Averillo or Kyle?

 

[Tigers_Wests]

Averillo or Kyle?

Can't imagine clubs lining up for Kyle. Also thinking it is a half with Buzz listing Oloapu and Reynolds (so maybe not Averillo..although there would be clubs after him).

Someone whose path has been blocked is my guess. Could be Khaled Rhajab, Bailey Howard, Joseph O'Neill. All talented halves whose path to 1st grade was just made more difficult.

 

[Demps]

Can't imagine clubs lining up for Kyle. Also thinking it is a half with Buzz listing Oloapu and Reynolds (so maybe not Averillo..although there would be clubs after him).

Someone whose path has been blocked is my guess. Could be Khaled Rhajab, Bailey Howard, Joseph O'Neill. All talented halves whose path to 1st grade was just made more difficult.

Might be worth a chat....

Gus said Khaled likely to debut this year at 7