TillLindemann
Well-known member
Proven wrong? Yesterday was the most garbage display of attack in the history of rugby league, against a hamstrung, shithouse opponent to boot, and you are cheering on the halfback who directed that shitshow.
Who is our worst
- Thread starter Harvey
- Start date
king_sirro
Well-known member
Has to be week to week NRL.
Release a player, upgrade a player.
Someone's gotta go....
We have a few options there.
💯
That game was an all time low for not just the Tigers, but the game of rugby league as a whole...
WesternSuburbsBoy
Well-known member
Earl mate you have a lot of respectable opinions on here but I genuinely don’t know you can say Brooks is not the problem. I thought he was one of our better player yesterdays & even said as much. But still even with Brooks being one of our better players it was still quite a poor performance from him especially that first half.
Have you ever seen a halfback get tackled on the 4th as much as Brooks yesterday? No leadership whatsoever
Don't even get started on his... "reported" ... income.
The truest statement that's ever been posted on here is... this team will never play finals with Brooks in it.
ah Demps, one for the ages.
earl
Well-known member
There is no way you release Brooks early. You just play him as a secondary half - a 6 or whatever you want to call it. He isn't an issue at all. I mean his contract is an issue this year but it's over this year as well. We shouldn't resign him unless we get 8 weeks where his worst game is at the same level as yesterday. That should be his worst game. You also don't sign him for anything more than like 500k.
AD is the issue though because he has been considered a guy that can lead us. I've considered him at that level. I don't think he is up to it.
To'a has proven he is the best centre in the club and he proved it again yesterday.
We have two big issues now:-
1. AD. A key player who we were looking to build around but he isn't progressing in the halves.
2. Stef - a key forward who was meant to lead our pack going forward but he is making so many mistakes. I reckon he'll get his game together but it's a massive concern.
I think we need a top quality 7 and a top quality 1 longer term.
As many on here know I have been critical of Luke over the years but also praised him as well...
I mentioned after RND1 that Brooks has been in rehab for an injury and has had a long layoff...
I said that this year is his year to prove his worth,he is doing what needs to be done atm,ITS the other players that are new to our system that have to get used to Sheens and Benji coaching,lets face it Api comes to us from a very successful system,Klemmer is an international forward,Papi a rising second row demon and a mix of youth that are very talented..The answer in my opinion is that AD has to perform in a team where he does his job NOT TRY and win games on his own,Brooks really needs to do what Hastings did last year ie. yell point and direct this mob THATS WHAT A HALF DOES...Luke did some good things yesterday and I will give him the chance to show us an improvement in his job as the season develops,it will be hard for many to adapt to Sheens style,let alone his apprentise coach...
worst player in my opinion is Noffa,big extention for little output from an experienced winger...
Word it how you want to word it... I was trying to be kind. 😂
Api, aside... the spine is playing without any smarts or understanding of what their role is.
Api is playing league God difficulty and the rest are struggling on schoolboy.
Bob Fulton .
earl
Well-known member
This is a better argument. Brooks was easily one of our best players. He was caught on the 4th which left Api and Doueihi to make the 5th play. They couldn't do anything with it. That was the issue.
The problem is people are expecting Brooks to win us the game but he isn't that player. You can get good defense, good running game, minimal mistakes, a decent kicking game but you don't get a creative player who is going to win you games regularly.
We need other players to step up.
Clearly yesterday Brooks wasn't the problem. Stef was really really bad. AD was really really bad. I thought Api was pretty good but he didn't nail those big plays when he had a chance. Brooks didn't get those chances.
Coaching the pick of a state, in a two team, three game series.
Not really the same.
Should have made an approach to Bomber. Did well with Cronulla.
earl
Well-known member
This isn't really true right. You can function with Brooks playing the way he did yesterday because he didn't stuff it. It's the mistakes which kill us.
You do need some class player to create and Brooks isn't that guy.
You can't function with Stef and AD making so many mistakes. Nofo was really poor as well.
I was hopeful AD would come good but I'm starting to think we are trying to make him into something he isn't which is exactly the problem that Brooks has had for a while.
He's a d1ck. Acted like a 9 year old.
AD is awkward to tackle, which is his strength. He's only 5/8 to get him closer to the action, but he should be centre until ready for 2nd row.
The only good game we've played this year was against Canberra. Guess who wasn't playing? Completely consistent with every other year. Hastings and Madden would've been a strong halves pairing - toughness, control and flair vs lack of direction and confusion.
AD ,is not, and never has been a good 5/8 . Overated, and used as a battering ram for the Brooks haters.
No i'm not a Books big fan, but he is far better then the baggers make him out to be. TT, To'a , appear brain dead and lacking agression and basic talent, Laurie is not a fullback, Nofa is past it. we need genuine SPEED in the backline.
After two dismal weeks, I'll bet WT have a lucrative new contract ready for Brooks. For 5 years for $6million.
