That’s not a good enough reason to keep him. He has to actually be playing good footy in order to keep him. Why should we keep him when we know what the result will be?
LIVE GAME Round 4 vs Storm
- Thread starter Tiger_Fanatic3
- Start date
Live Game Discussion
Jedi_Tiger
Well-known member
I would say if the club is serious
Brooks doesn't get re signed
Shop AD wherever you can to get him out too even to the point heavily subsidise his 650k contract to play elsewhere
Back to back spoons incoming and a guy who's won 2 of his last 24.
I cannot think of a more stupider thing to do than extend some one who is so out of his depth and simply cannot deliver within his role.
tony soprano
Well-known member
Imagine if the brought mitchell pearce in effective immediately
I think AD unless someone does want him will be kept. Even if its just for depth. We need to go to market and try to bring over a new 1,6 and 7 for 24 if we want to try and have success. Keeping Brooks isn’t the answer.
Jedi_Tiger
Well-known member
we extended the other bloke in AD too, the club does some silly things mate. Both should probably go tbh
Honestly would not have a problem with that.
tony soprano
Well-known member
How mad was the defence on the Munster tackle they just stood and watched
tony soprano
Well-known member
Blore has been average side kick stephano too
Jedi_Tiger
Well-known member
heard early in the week a swap was brewing with Aiden Seizer and Brooks. Let's see if it has any legs
Probably wasn’t the smart move but it was only a one year deal. Its 50/50 really. But if they can offload him by all means do it but yeah can’t keep Brooks anymore.
Just outta curiosity where do you get your info from? I think you said the same about Ramien coming to us.
Halbrowne61
Well-known member
No, I think we all know now, he must be released. No re-signing, OUT.
Chuck in Nofo, Talau and Laurie.
Let's pro actively try and improve this squad.
TigerNeddyK
Well-known member
And we never ever pressure the kicker
earl
Well-known member
I can't see them keeping him based on performance. AD is lucky he signed an extension but I don't think you play him in the spine again. He is just too slow.
ElleryHanley
Well-known member
Again...hate to say this, but if you have ever seen Twal interviewed there just is nothing 'there'.
And that translates onto the footy field.
Honestly, Brooks...Twal...and Nofa all clearly have very, very, low IQs. I am not knocking that, but it translates onto the footy field also unfortunately.
earl
Well-known member
The problem is mate we probably 3 spine positions. I can't see how we can do it ? Just one quality player would be huge.
Idk with AD. Tonight wasn’t good from him but we really don’t have anyone else to play the spine. If we take Brooks out AD is most likely in the halves. You keep Brooks in he’s either his 6 and Brooks is 7 again. Club needs a whole new spine for 24. Except Api of course.
Jedi_Tiger
Well-known member
problem is getting blokes
we need welsby bigtime
