Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

I think we have to face facts
We are struggling to put an NRL level quality team on the park atm
Looking at what we have who are Quality 1st grade footballers
Bula , Noffa , Toa ( not at 6 ) Tupou ( needs a class left center inside him)
Pole ,Klemm, Steph ,Paps , Bateman ,Twal , and of course Api
Naden is a big maybe and can't count Brooks ( he doesn't even want to be there) Da Silva maybe one day
Douehi won't be back even next year ( Sheens hinted at that at Presser)
Weve got about a dozen quality 1st graders and we need at least 18
In the meantime give Daino another go as for all his faults he does have instincts
We either need to do some serious recruiting or sit back enjoy a Dynasty of Spoons . Our Pathways are not going to solve this !
 
Hunt lives in the shire… I’d give him $1.25 mil over 3 years if that’s what will get him done

We’re legitimately one position away from being something and he’s everything we need
We need the Scotty Prince replacement.
Even though last night was disappointing in some respects we turned up with good attitude. ATM a lack of halves and execution are our enemies.
 
Sheens mentioning in the press conference today we’re looking at some super league halves

Could he be referring to Welsby or Dodd?

Didn’t Dodd just sign with some NRL leading agent
Which means they let Jofa go without a contingency to fill that Roster Spot. The negligence by Management to give Members and Fans a side that can challenge to get to 8th place is disgusting. Constantly playing under the Cap destines you to the Spoon.
We will never succeed while Lee,Pascoe and this Board remain. In the sporting landscape, they're losers.
 
Which means they let Jofa go without a contingency to fill that Roster Spot. The negligence by Management to give Members and Fans a side that can challenge to get to 8th place is disgusting. Constantly playing under the Cap destines you to the Spoon.
We will never succeed while Lee,Pascoe and this Board remain. In the sporting landscape, they're losers.
Lee, Pascoe and SHEENS (as he has scuttled two seasons releasing players and under the cap, in the hope of future opportunities)
 
I think we have to face facts
We are struggling to put an NRL level quality team on the park atm
Looking at what we have who are Quality 1st grade footballers
Bula , Noffa , Toa ( not at 6 ) Tupou ( needs a class left center inside him)
Pole ,Klemm, Steph ,Paps , Bateman ,Twal , and of course Api
Naden is a big maybe and can't count Brooks ( he doesn't even want to be there) Da Silva maybe one day
Douehi won't be back even next year ( Sheens hinted at that at Presser)
Weve got about a dozen quality 1st graders and we need at least 18
In the meantime give Daino another go as for all his faults he does have instincts
We either need to do some serious recruiting or sit back enjoy a Dynasty of Spoons . Our Pathways are not going to solve this !
We need to buy A 7. And use Brooks as 6 And also aback up like Watson and piss Wakeman off , Also a centre
Toa on side new guys the other or Bring Reilly in now and give him a go season is shot , also Give James a crack off the bench , piss Sayfarts off and keep Blore
 
Still miles better than Brooks as a half.
Wait, back up.
This is the same argument with Hastings. ..
34 year old Hunt, yes better then Brooks.
Do we offer him 1 mil a year for 2 years to come here?
Considering the Dragons were ready to punt him at 700k?

The Dragons are where we are, yes Hunt is bringing the goods but WT, please. STOP TRYING TO DRAG PLAYERS HERE. Moses, offered overs. Johnson, we tried pulling him out of NZ, Hunt, wants to go to QLD.
STOP.

Hastings was a decent signing at 500-600k. If no top shelf halfbacks want to come here then lets get people who can do the job and keep signing a Monster pack. Spend the money on Frizzel or a Panther Or heck get Manu/Olam in our centers and have a backline that can defend.

Average halfbacks do well in a pack that can hold their own. See Chad Townsend.
 
Repeated so often it's boring, but letting Hastings go has not proven successful. Was a better half than Brooks last year and now we won't even have Brooks.

Lots of positives in the way we play, but our halves are our biggest weakness and we acted like it wasn't an issue in the offseason.
 
Hunt lives in the shire… I’d give him $1.25 mil over 3 years if that’s what will get him done

We’re legitimately one position away from being something and he’s everything we need
100%

We need to get this done even if he is the highest paid player in the NRL.

Not often a premium Half is available that legitimately is looking to cash in.
 
Wait, back up.
This is the same argument with Hastings. ..
34 year old Hunt, yes better then Brooks.
Do we offer him 1 mil a year for 2 years to come here?
Considering the Dragons were ready to punt him at 700k?

The Dragons are where we are, yes Hunt is bringing the goods but WT, please. STOP TRYING TO DRAG PLAYERS HERE. Moses, offered overs. Johnson, we tried pulling him out of NZ, Hunt, wants to go to QLD.
STOP.

Hastings was a decent signing at 500-600k. If no top shelf halfbacks want to come here then lets get people who can do the job and keep signing a Monster pack. Spend the money on Frizzel or a Panther Or heck get Manu/Olam in our centers and have a backline that can defend.

Average halfbacks do well in a pack that can hold their own. See Chad Townsend.
I’d pay hunt a mil a year for 2 seasons. Our salary cap is reportedly much more balanced than dragons. We can afford him. We need experience and direction desperately

To me it’s not dragging them here if you sell the dream and they decide to come. You need to target the best players even if it’s low odds. I don’t seem the point in only targeting average players because you’d be just “dragging” them here too.

I would have personally kept Hastings for a season or two for depth at the very least but he was reportedly offered no7 at 900k a season. That’s how poor the halfback market is.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top