Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Mccarry]

Do you have a link? too blurry to read ☺️

Sorry Ferret. I should have checked before posting.

Try this link instead. Once you see logical fallacies explained it becomes much easier to spot and stomp on them

Logical fallacies as a robot poster

 

[Mccarry]

Can u attach or share a link??

Here you go… enjoy. Your mates won’t know what hit them

Logical fallacies link

 

[diedpretty]

I'd be looking at Rocco Berry from the Warriors. A solid centre who can defend well and can cover FB if needed. Signed until end of 2024. Would imagine Warriors will want to re sign him but nothing as yet.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

I'd be looking at Rocco Berry from the Warriors. A solid centre who can defend well and can cover FB if needed. Signed until end of 2024. Would imagine Warriors will want to re sign him but nothing as yet.

Could be onto something @diedpretty With RTS returning to play centre plus Pompey signed until 2025 & Ali Leiataua promoted to top 30 next season, Warriors may need to sacrifice someone for cap purposes.

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Sorry Ferret. I should have checked before posting.

Try this link instead. Once you see logical fallacies explained it becomes much easier to spot and stomp on them

Logical fallacies as a robot poster

Legend 👍🏻

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I'd be looking at Rocco Berry from the Warriors. A solid centre who can defend well and can cover FB if needed. Signed until end of 2024. Would imagine Warriors will want to re sign him but nothing as yet.

Yes he is a very good prospect and son of a former All Black centre.

 

[Kelce68]

I can’t resist.
Your method of argument is straight out of the Terrorgraph. It’s often called a false binary or an Either/Or.

I want to gently help you shake off the Terrorgraphs influence on you.

You have created a (fake) position that there are only two options.
1. Existing Admin
2. Robbie Farah.

You method works well for one liners, people who can’t think and News Corp overall. It works even better when your mates have had a few beers.

Not trying to be rude just made me laugh.

Turns out… drum roll… there are thousands of potential options who could be good candidates.

Check this picture out. It’s amazing how much power it gives you to deconstruct another position. As Wests fans we need all the help we can get there

View attachment 6907

Good premise, fallacies are rife these days.

Though, it behoves me to remind you that the insertion of the 'Murdoch Media Tyranny' trope is, by definition, a cherry picking fallacy; the use of of logical fallacies in general is almost ubiquitous in mainstream media these days, not just those outlets whose political opinions differ from your own. They all distort the narrative and commit fallacies at scale with their audiences, both on the left and the right.

 

[Buttface]

Yes he is a very good prospect and son of a former All Black centre.

He gotta kool name to yell at the tv too.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Tariq Sims/ Luke Thompson. They would of been handy. Not dandy. Just handy.

 

[jadtiger]

Tariq Sims/ Luke Thompson. They would of been handy. Not dandy. Just handy.

Luke Thompson has been an overpaid dud for years and would be the last bloke in the NRL i would want to see wearing our jumper

 

[colinbh]

Tariq Sims/ Luke Thompson. They would of been handy. Not dandy. Just handy.

I*m glad that you are not a selector.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Tariq Sims/ Luke Thompson. They would of been handy. Not dandy. Just handy.

Handy nope. If we grab someone off the market it’s either impact or growth. Neither these 2 offers us that.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

I hear you all loud and clear.

 

[Needaname]

Here you go… enjoy. Your mates won’t know what hit them

Logical fallacies link

Great image, do you think someone with a bit of time up their sleeve could put the same argumentative statements against whether the board is at fault for the Tigers demise and see how it stands up?

 

[Qwertyrick]

Reilly intrigues me. Have always thought he was a wasted spot in the top 30 but he seems to have a lot of fans on this forum. Be interesting to see how it plays out.

Come across this on a tigers Facebook group

 

[dazza65]

Come across this on a tigers Facebook group

the guy can play. As with all young kids - does he have enough in the tank to improve to be a top line NRL centre?

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

the guy can play. As with all young kids - does he have enough in the tank to improve to be a top line NRL centre?

Everytime ive seen him play he's been solid, worth persisting with i reckon.

 

[Tigerdiehard]

Come across this on a tigers Facebook group

Think Reilly could really come into his own in 24 with another pre season under his belt if he is able to lock down a centre spot

 

[426Tlgerland]

Come across this on a tigers Facebook group

Called for him to be in the team from early in the year , never got a decent shot at proving himself until end of season , guy can play just needed to be given a go instead we stuck with crap players in poor form , guy is a keeper

 

[boonboon]

A few things I really like about Reilly.
1. He was playing left centre all year in NSW cup he came up to NRL and we put him on the right and his defence held and his attack still was good. That impresses me as rarely do players change sides well especially rookies
2. When he got hurt against Manly he played on and not just played on but made 2 tackles in a row and got back into the defensive line hurt.
3. Twice during his short nrl career - he was the bloke scrambling back to collect kicks when he wasn't necessarily the bloke who should be back their - covering with effort.

Now he is quick, has good hands and a good step so attack wise he is good but those 3 effort areas above are what really caught my attention.

Even when he came across in NSW cup his deficiency was defence but it wasn't tackling - he puts his shoulder in it was just inexperience of knowing how to defend and what the lines were and of course that was an issue because switching that from 7s rugby to League its very different.