Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[BAGNF05]

No, I think given a good run with injury, his size and speed will be huge for us

He’s not in my black book but happily be wrong.

 

[TSP]

They offered him under factory didn’t they?

Wasn’t he rookie of the year?

Pity we don’t have momo anymore to swap him out for!

 

[hammertime]

Is the cooling off period even a thing anymore?

10 days for the current club to counter. Panthers must have waived it, like Luai

 

[GNR4LIFE]

10 days for the current club to counter. Panthers must have waived it, like Luai

Probably. I think they are beyond needing to play moneyball. They’ll make an offer, and if it’s not good enough, they’ve got the juniors to replace whoever it is they lose.

 

[KCTiger2]

everyone on the forum who said we are asleep at the wheel for not signing James [This word has been automatically removed]ing Schiller you just had to trust the process of course we were gonna have a quality player lined up

 

[TSP]

Some report they offered him $350k, I mean this kid is not getting out of bed and putting on a pair of socks for less than 450k.

 

[LeichhardtTiger]

Turuva eh? I guess that means we aren't after Curtis Rona now. 🤣 🍻 🐱

 

[jadtiger]

Turuva eh? I guess that means we aren't after Curtis Rona now. 🤣 🍻 🐱

We probably will be in 5 years time according to some sources

 

[BalmainJnr]

Turuva eh? I guess that means we aren't after Curtis Rona now. 🤣 🍻 🐱

He and Ma’a Nonu will complete the circle.

 

[Buttface]

A few times on here I have seen critcism of Toa based on his defence and missing tackles. The problem is the facts don't back that up. He had an effective tackle % of 84% last year - Much better then Olam or Naden (last yr or this yr) also better then the likes of Bradman Best and Kotoni Staggs. Think people go off personal opinions that just arent real a lot of the time here

When Olam misses a tackle he cannonballs into next week and needs a parachute to stop.

 

[Tito Santana]

Is Turuva really quick? Can we swap him now for Buddy?

 

[Buttface]

Is Turuva really quick? Can we swap him now for Buddy?

They ain’t giving us anyone early, especially not a run on player, no matter what.

 

[Tito Santana]

They ain’t giving us anyone early, especially not a run on player, no matter what.

How good is Turuva? Is he awesome? I want awesomeness.

 

[Camel2281]

How good is Turuva? Is he awesome? I want awesomeness.

I think he's awesome

 

[Bones]

How good is Turuva? Is he awesome? I want awesomeness.

Closer to awesome than awful

 

[balmain boy]

Lobb can finish but he lacks speed, is inconsistent in regards to his yardage carries. to his credit he's cleaned up his defence while at WT. this year's pretty crucial to his development. we need him carrying for 150m+ in Cup, but he's currently averaging 79m a game. that's a massive concern.

I imagine that many halves even giving the option of kicking to the big guy or the small guy they'd focus on the smaller player where they see the advantage.

If kicks don't cone his way in defence he needs to go looking for the ball a lot more

 

[innsaneink]

Not concerned that he looks really skinny these days? And not in a good way like the rangy Storm outside backs.

I have noticed he seems a bit leaner... But I dunno about "good skinny Melbourne style" those guys are units in their own right Coates and warbrick.

I feel Toa is still developing and wether he makes it or not I'm not sure but my money would be on him being another player with a handful of nrl games to his credit then drifts off somewhere either some regional comp or esl... Our reggies teams full of these blokes.
Naden is a first grader already imo,. If he really wants it- has the hunger and desire. He needs to listen to those that know what they're talking about and that's probably everyone he comes in contact with because I think he's a bit dense. Wether benji can instill that killer instinct into him I think there's a good first grader there

 

[innsaneink]

Looks like it's official, Sunia Turuva will be a Tiger in 25. With it being announced, that would indicate that the 10 day cooling off period has been and gone, and no one knew a thing until a couple of days out. Richo has really plugged the leaks, and his re-signing for 4 years is the best thing that could happen to this club moving forward.

There's a waver the current club can rescind if they wish... Richo confirmed this was the case here with Turuva

 

[innsaneink]

10 days for the current club to counter. Panthers must have waived it, like Luai

That's it... Exactly right... You expressed it better than me

 

[phil1986]

I’ve got a weird one here but I was just going through some of our backs and a little devil on my shoulder told me something.

How would Starford Toa fair as a winger. Now before we grab the pitchforks let’s have a little looksie. Now in no way am I saying that Toa and To’o (yes Brian) are on the same stratosphere but I do believe Toa could have a similar impact.

They have pretty similar builds with Toa being a couple centimetres shorter but negligible in weight. They have a similar run style in a strong fend and tough carries, it would also eliminate the amount of defensive pressure he is under as he does tend to miss tackles and have lapses in defence.

All you have to do is go back to the Knights 2020 season on the wing and he was outstanding, now granted he had KP feeding him good ball but he was still great regardless.

Tough carries out of our end is what we need and suffer greatly in. I mean Tupou is the only one with a good carry but he has an error in him and he is leaving. We all know Toa has potential, all you have to do is look back at the cowboys game. It’s just like every other back we have, he fails to find consistency.

Now I’m not expecting him to play like that every week but I still believe he has a place in our backline hopefully. Thoughts?

Thats is where he ends up mate. Has X factor and ability.

Not one to throw the towel in on.