OFFICIAL Jarome Luai - #295

Re: game plans.

To me, Luai’s greatest strength is his ability to play "eyes-up footy," thriving on creativity and improvisation rather than a rigid game plan. Take Harry Grant for example—he’s somewhat stagnated at the Storm due to a lack of freedom to express his creativity. This doesn’t mean he won’t develop in other aspects of his game, but it highlights how creative players can be stifled.

One key issue for us is that our outside backs currently lack both speed and size, making it hard to capitalise on field position and turn opportunities into points. Additionally, our halves aren't always effective at creating enough space for our second rowers, limiting our attacking options.
Luai’s creative playmaking and leadership can help address these problems. His ability to break through defensive lines and generate opportunities can alleviate our speed and size deficiencies, turning field position into tries where we’ve always struggled. His knack for creating space and making the most of attacking situations can also benefit our second rowers, helping them find more opportunities to score.

Marshall’s own career as a dynamic playmaker means he understands how to balance structure with creativity. As a coach, he will surely craft strategies that allow Luai’s skills to shine while also addressing our current limitations.

However, the effectiveness of Luai will depend on our go forward and finding the right halves partner IMO. While he excels in creative play, he lacks a strong kicking game, so partnering him with Galvin (who is still raw and learning) could be challenging. A structured playmaker like Aidan Sezer could complement him well, though his effectiveness may be limited by his age.
 
He lacks a strong kicking game? I dont know - last night I saw the best drop outs ever... rugby union style... or NFL. Ball stayed in the air at the designated location. 10 metres in fact. I dont know if it will help us. But we have a deadly weapon if his team mates can co- operate in the spirit of co- operation.
 
Therein lies the issue,
Luai plays best off the back of a go forward pack ie Fisher - Harris, Leota, Martin, Sorensen, Yeoh and as of right now, apart from maybe Pole/ Lainu going forward, the rest of our lot are real plodders.
We need to correct that very early on, otherwise Luai will be so easy to read he’ll get swamped and become ineffective.
Klemmer and bateman have been disappointing this season, ive been happy with seyfarth enough , his baseline was a plodder and i think he has gone up. Twal is flat lining. Reuben is still learning but not sure. Were still missing a couple good forwards. Difficult for a kid to elevate into that role quickly.
 
To me, Luai’s greatest strength is his ability to play "eyes-up footy," thriving on creativity and improvisation rather than a rigid game plan. Take Harry Grant for example—he’s somewhat stagnated at the Storm due to a lack of freedom to express his creativity. This doesn’t mean he won’t develop in other aspects of his game, but it highlights how creative players can be stifled.

One key issue for us is that our outside backs currently lack both speed and size, making it hard to capitalise on field position and turn opportunities into points. Additionally, our halves aren't always effective at creating enough space for our second rowers, limiting our attacking options.
Luai’s creative playmaking and leadership can help address these problems. His ability to break through defensive lines and generate opportunities can alleviate our speed and size deficiencies, turning field position into tries where we’ve always struggled. His knack for creating space and making the most of attacking situations can also benefit our second rowers, helping them find more opportunities to score.

Marshall’s own career as a dynamic playmaker means he understands how to balance structure with creativity. As a coach, he will surely craft strategies that allow Luai’s skills to shine while also addressing our current limitations.

However, the effectiveness of Luai will depend on our go forward and finding the right halves partner IMO. While he excels in creative play, he lacks a strong kicking game, so partnering him with Galvin (who is still raw and learning) could be challenging. A structured playmaker like Aidan Sezer could complement him well, though his effectiveness may be limited by his age.
Great summary Lauren. Luai's kicking will only get better once he steps into the no 7. He has the ability to get behind the first line of defence as he has shown several times in origin. Now we only need a few to go with him to take advantage of his brilliance. He is bargain buy and will flourish next year.
 
To me, Luai’s greatest strength is his ability to play "eyes-up footy," thriving on creativity and improvisation rather than a rigid game plan. Take Harry Grant for example—he’s somewhat stagnated at the Storm due to a lack of freedom to express his creativity. This doesn’t mean he won’t develop in other aspects of his game, but it highlights how creative players can be stifled.

One key issue for us is that our outside backs currently lack both speed and size, making it hard to capitalise on field position and turn opportunities into points. Additionally, our halves aren't always effective at creating enough space for our second rowers, limiting our attacking options.
Luai’s creative playmaking and leadership can help address these problems. His ability to break through defensive lines and generate opportunities can alleviate our speed and size deficiencies, turning field position into tries where we’ve always struggled. His knack for creating space and making the most of attacking situations can also benefit our second rowers, helping them find more opportunities to score.

Marshall’s own career as a dynamic playmaker means he understands how to balance structure with creativity. As a coach, he will surely craft strategies that allow Luai’s skills to shine while also addressing our current limitations.

However, the effectiveness of Luai will depend on our go forward and finding the right halves partner IMO. While he excels in creative play, he lacks a strong kicking game, so partnering him with Galvin (who is still raw and learning) could be challenging. A structured playmaker like Aidan Sezer could complement him well, though his effectiveness may be limited by his age.
FWIW I think his kicking game has been good for the Panthers and was the same last night. He doesn’t possess an absolute cannon like Moses, Burton or even Cleary but from what I have seen it is very accurate.
 
Re: game plans.

To me, Luai’s greatest strength is his ability to play "eyes-up footy," thriving on creativity and improvisation rather than a rigid game plan. Take Harry Grant for example—he’s somewhat stagnated at the Storm due to a lack of freedom to express his creativity. This doesn’t mean he won’t develop in other aspects of his game, but it highlights how creative players can be stifled.
You make some very interesting points but I was especially interested in what you said about Harry Grant.

Don't know what anyone else thinks but I find his play these days really boring and I didn't really think much about it until you mentioned him.
 
You make some very interesting points but I was especially interested in what you said about Harry Grant.

Don't know what anyone else thinks but I find his play these days really boring and I didn't really think much about it until you mentioned him.
@Lauren
I think Harry has struggled since smith and then Cheese left and Harry has had to be the main man. I reckon he has either been told to rein it in or he thinks he has to play boring football, (Cam Smith style), now that he is the main man.
I reckon Harry would love playing a less structured game, more “eyes-up” football.
Some people like to have fun while they play to win. Some people just like to win no matter what, or how boring or distasteful or whatever they have to do to just win, including bending the rules without being seen to intentionally break them of course.
I reckon Harry falls into the first group and has been pushed into the second group to early. But certainly his play his become a little less dynamic and more predictable.
Needs to come back to the Tigpies to learn a different side of playing hooker under Api and that’ll give TDS a little more time.
 
@Lauren
I think Harry has struggled since smith and then Cheese left and Harry has had to be the main man. I reckon he has either been told to rein it in or he thinks he has to play boring football, (Cam Smith style), now that he is the main man.
I reckon Harry would love playing a less structured game, more “eyes-up” football.
Some people like to have fun while they play to win. Some people just like to win no matter what, or how boring or distasteful or whatever they have to do to just win, including bending the rules without being seen to intentionally break them of course.
I reckon Harry falls into the first group and has been pushed into the second group to early. But certainly his play his become a little less dynamic and more predictable.
Needs to come back to the Tigpies to learn a different side of playing hooker under Api and that’ll give TDS a little more time.
Once on Wednesday last tackle 20 metres out he went himself right when Ponga and co were lined out left. Really a missed limited chance for Qld.
 
I was happy as anyone when Luai signed. I also massively overestimated the ability of the existing roster, particularly the forward pack. Luai will be great, but more signings and movement of deadwood are required otherwise look for another grim year
I somewhat agree with this statement, however having played a lot of footy through to under 20's in my youth, I can say that a good general can change a team. it's hard to explain. I've played in a game where we were down 12-4 at halftime and a player rocked up late, came on for the 2nd half and we won 28-12.. he was a halfback, he didnt score any points, just ordered the troops around the field.

I am riding this one, the Luai factor is huge!
 
Luai will not change the team by himself, but the club has to do things to set him up to play well. Forwards, defence coaches, edge players, no leaks, etc. It will take quite some time, but there has to be a belief that he is the man to change things around no matter how bad things get before they get good
I think many under estimate the power of the right player.
 
I think many under estimate the power of the right player.
He needs guys to buy in and go with him.
Api, Bula, Turuva, Doueihi, Galvin, Fainu brothers, Pole, Bateman, Olam are a good start. We need that many again to come through or preferably be brought to the club to be competitive and have him make the difference.
A couple of shit crazy props, a rep level back rower and centre and a very good winger at a minimum need to be purchased.
 
I wonder if Laui has contacted Stefo to try and keep him here.
Surely he wants as many good forwards as possible to help him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
I was happy as anyone when Luai signed. I also massively overestimated the ability of the existing roster, particularly the forward pack. Luai will be great, but more signings and movement of deadwood are required otherwise look for another grim year
The forwards are a let down as they havent dominated games as I thought they may have given their combined experiences and talent. Thats not to say they havent done their job. We often enjoy good field position - and that is not from an over-abundance of penalties, our average set meters are pretty competitive every week - and that is not from kick return meters, and most weeks we are getting multiple forwards hitting 100m - we had 3 blokes crack 150m against Melbourne for example. The pack generally give the halves and the back 5 enough chances to score to stay in the contest.
We do need them to be more dominant in defence though thats for sure.
 
I wonder if Laui has contacted Stefo to try and keep him here.
Surely he wants as many good forwards as possible to help him.

I think he's staying Jonesy, hopefully another 2/3
year extension, something feasible for both parties.
He's already contracted 4 next year and doesn't want
to leave Sydney. I get the feeling that some members
on here are going to have to reconcile the fact that
he'll stay a tiger, and that they've said some pretty
foul shit about him since news broke that he's allowed
to explore his options haha. Personally, I'm neutral,
ideally if you lose him you have something lined
up already. Would be really bad to lose Blore for Olam
and Stef for NAS just like that. Would be concerning
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top