Luke Brooks #167

cktiger said:
So what... and why do people care so much about Brooks now he's at Manly?
Click to expand...
Does that go for those also shitting on him? 🤔
cktiger said:
Amazing to see so much butt kissing for a player that took advantage of being overpaid for so long ... then couldn't get out the door quick enough when offered his real worth.
Click to expand...
This argument again. Let’s death ride him and belittle him for a decade. Demand the club cut ties with him. Then when he’s the one to leave of his own accord, suddenly it’s a betrayal 😅
cktiger said:
Don't wish him bad luck or bad injuries but seriously glad he's not stinking up the halfback spot in our team.
Click to expand...
Another wonderful argument. We’re still last. Go figure.
 
Telltails said:
So team went better when Brooks was at 7?
Click to expand...
Read what I wrote
- Instead of twisting what I wrote to suit your POV.

Hastings had
3/11 wins in the 7
3/13 Wins in the Halves (total)
1/3 Wins at Lock

You can Math right?
PM if you get stuck and I'll shoot the numbers through for ya...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
batboy said:
Read what I wrote
- Instead of twisting what I wrote to suit your Stoopid POV.

Hastings had
3/11 wins in the 7
3/13 Wins in the Halves (total)
1/3 Wins at Lock

You can Math right?
PM if you get stuck and I'll shoot the numbers through for ya...
Click to expand...
Thanks don't need your help to look up wins and losses.
Seems there is a notion Brooks was used poorly by the club for not seeing him as a running 5/8 even though Maguire moved him to 6 prior to being sacked, and where he is also now playing at Manly. So was interested -seeing you are an authority on all things to do with Brooks and take it upon yourself to come at anyone who you assume doesn't rate him as highly as you do - if we were better with him at 7 instead of 6 considering you stated we were better when Hastings played lock. That is all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
Telltails said:
Thanks don't need your help to look up wins and losses.
Seems there is a notion Brooks was used poorly by the club for not seeing him as a running 5/8 even though Maguire moved him to 6 prior to being sacked, and where he is also now playing at Manly. So was interested -seeing you are an authority on all things to do with Brooks and take it upon yourself to come at anyone who you assume doesn't rate him as highly as you do - if we were better with him at 7 instead of 6 considering you stated we were better when Hastings played lock. That is all.
Click to expand...

What's any of that got to do with Hastings?
(Isn't that what we were talking about?)
 
Telltails said:
There was a discussion about not using Brooks properly - ie running 5/8th which did happen under Maguire before he was sacked. Hence how Hastings came into it.
Click to expand...

Dunno man,
You replied to me referring to Hastings - in more than one post...
On your point, You'd have seen the part earlier where I don't put much stock in jumper Numbers?
Left and right Halves and all?
 
His best years were when partnered with Benji.

Couldn't organise was more an individualistic half......but was a shame seemed to be plagued by injury, no pre-season basically last year when the club and coaches loaded him up with go forward forwards.

Would've done good with Galvin taking charge.

Anyway, not to be a good bloke and loyal clubman.
 
Magpie_Magic said:
His best years were when partnered with Benji.

Couldn't organise was more an individualistic half......but was a shame seemed to be plagued by injury, no pre-season basically last year when the club and coaches loaded him up with go forward forwards.

Would've done good with Galvin taking charge.

Anyway, not to be a good bloke and loyal clubman.
Click to expand...

I'd dumb it down a bot more than that MM,
Best years were when he was playing with a senior half that played some OK footy....
(Something young halves generally have the luxury of)

Basically the only time in his career he'd had that.
 
Jedi_Tiger said:
he did have a fair few coaches at the Tigers, 4 or so in his tenure. In hindsight one coach should have said to him you are playing 6 and go and recruit a 7 or he should have said it to the coaches.
Click to expand...
The club chased a heap of experienced halves while he was here.

People were too busy blaming the little fella and forgetting we couldn’t attract a marquee player for shit.
 
Yeah well I think once is more than enough if Manly happen to progress....and yeah the loyalty part wasnt lost on me, but thats fairly hypocritical these days
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Does that go for those also shitting on him? 🤔

This argument again. Let’s death ride him and belittle him for a decade. Demand the club cut ties with him. Then when he’s the one to leave of his own accord, suddenly it’s a betrayal 😅

Another wonderful argument. We’re still last. Go figure.
Click to expand...
Glad I gave you the opportunity to kiss him on the clacker even more.🤣
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 479 (members: 22, guests: 457)
Back
Top