Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

weststigers said:
Penrith use Dylan Edwards to take the hitup prior to the kick chase so the team presents a full defensive line.

Edwards is then able to stay in position while the other 12 chase.

Most other teams are chasing with 11 players because the forward is left at the play the ball and the fullback has to get to position.
Click to expand...
Well picked up. I'm impressed.
 
Vicious said:
You would think so, but for whatever reason we regularly have players in our top 30 or next tier squads that are being prevented from playing their best due to lack of condition.
And that’s not to mention how many do not develop or perform to their best due to lack of motivation.
Players 20-40 have to be treated the same and with the same respect as the best players in the team, I’m not so sure that is happening.
Click to expand...
Surely Luai can pass on what happens at penriff
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
weststigers said:
Penrith use Dylan Edwards to take the hitup prior to the kick chase so the team presents a full defensive line.

Edwards is then able to stay in position while the other 12 chase.

Most other teams are chasing with 11 players because the forward is left at the play the ball and the fullback has to get to position.
Click to expand...
Yep Edwards & Turbo have been doing this for a couple years now. I’m sure a lot of other teams will do the same over the next few years
 
just old magpie said:
I think Miller might surprise a few people ne t year after a tough preseason.
Click to expand...
Wouldn't be surprised if he played more minutes this year.
But don't think it will be anywhere near enough to be of any consequence to our results.
Takes a long time for props to develop and get acclimatized to the weekly punishment of NRL.
Stef was only just able to play fairly consistently this year (age 24 season) and he was a much more refined product when he came to us.
Think Miller will get some games mid year when there's a bit of natural attrition in the pack, but if we need him to provide anything more than a bit of youthful impact for 4-6 games next year things will not be going well.
 
Juice said:
Yep Edwards & Turbo have been doing this for a couple years now. I’m sure a lot of other teams will do the same over the next few years
Click to expand...
Im not sure if our fullback is suitable for this tactic.
He would probably get monstered and produce a very slow Play the ball
 
balmain boy said:
Well put it this way:

He could earn 400k over the next 2 years, or he could earn 1.4 million. That's a pretty big incentive to sign an upgraded extension.

You can still try break a contract later on if they REALLY want to, but he's still ridiculously young. He'd become the highest paid youngster in the comp, possibly ever.
Click to expand...
Agree with this but concerning thing is richo would’ve already tried this I’m sure.

And if $1m over two years is not an incentive enough than I reckon we’re only a 50/50 keeping him unless he galls in love with luai - which is a possibility
 
balmain boy said:
Well put it this way:

He could earn 400k over the next 2 years, or he could earn 1.4 million. That's a pretty big incentive to sign an upgraded extension.

You can still try break a contract later on if they REALLY want to, but he's still ridiculously young. He'd become the highest paid youngster in the comp, possibly ever.
Click to expand...
looks like spell check took over that post, I’m surprised you understood what I was saying.
 
Iron Fist said:
The kid is only 17 and the club is shouting his signing from the rooftops. Top 30 in 2026. Nice way to lay on the pressure on him. Another thing you wouldn’t see at Melbourne, Penrith or Roosters.
Click to expand...

Hottest prospect in the country, very ungrateful take
on his signing. Your posts are often a bit more insightful.
Ran 100m just under 10secs, 100kg, 6"2 and growing.
Playing u/18s for Australia & 1stXV, can't please every1
 
LARDS said:
Im not sure if our fullback is suitable for this tactic.
He would probably get monstered and produce a very slow Play the ball
Click to expand...
There’s gunna be a plenty of fullbacks out there unsuitable for that tactic, but if teams see benefit in it then fullbacks will all be that giant athlete type.
 
tigermate said:
Agree with this but concerning thing is richo would’ve already tried this I’m sure.

And if $1m over two years is not an incentive enough than I reckon we’re only a 50/50 keeping him unless he galls in love with luai - which is a possibility
Click to expand...
If we're not going to offer him more than $500k a year we don't deserve to keep him.
 
2041 said:
If we're not going to offer him more than $500k a year we don't deserve to keep him.
Click to expand...
He was suggesting $700k for next two years …

I think we need to offer him $850 next two years and then go up to $1m for next 3. Do a 5 yr deal at $4.7m….

Don’t think he would say no to that
 
Kaito said:
Hottest prospect in the country, very ungrateful take
on his signing. Your posts are often a bit more insightful.
Ran 100m just under 10secs, 100kg, 6"2 and growing.
Playing u/18s for Australia & 1stXV, can't please every1
Click to expand...
Makasini can be compared to how Joseph Suuali was considered at the same age, therefore if we didn’t put him on a top 30 contract he would have had no trouble getting it at a rival NRL club.
If it were up to me, both Makasini and Large would have been put on top 30 contracts for 2025 in order to keep them both.
I’m not a fan of just putting any young player on a top 30 contract as I think we have a few that were elevated way too early before earning it, but it is a different approach when it comes to generational talents such as Galvin, Latu Fainu, Talyn Da Silva and Makasini.
 
Last edited:
Vicious said:
Makasini can be compared to how Joseph Suuali was considered at the same age, therefore if we didn’t put him on a too 39 contracted he would have had no trouble getting it at a rival NRL club.
If it were up to me, both Makasini and Large would have been put on top 30 contracts for 2025 in order to keep them both.
I’m not a fan of just putting anything player on a tol 39 contest hand I think we have a few that were elevated way too early before earning it, but it is a different approach when it comes tjbgeberational talents such as Galvin, Latu Fainu, Talyn Da Silva and Makasini.
Click to expand...

I agree, we fast tracked a lot of these kids 4 sure.
in the same token, we got rid of Onitoni in order to
retain Lachie who's proven so I haven't got any issues
there — Harry Grant stayed in QLD for 2 years and
then played with us to get a start. Some guys are
ready for the next level and some ain't @Vicious.
Makasini is that guy, I'm very grateful he's at our club.
 
hodgo said:
i know this sounds weird but our forward pack will be better with the addition of ball running wingers
Click to expand...
Not stupid at all, it will be proven correct, there is a certain user on here who kept saying the Storm wingers were the best in the comp, and the Penrith wingers were one dimensional midgets who are no good in todays game.
Well Penrith had the least tries scored against them from kicks this year, and the so called best coach and wingers couldn't score a try against them from kicks in the grand final, maybe old mate was wrong, and the bus driver was right after all.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 482 (members: 8, guests: 474)
Back
Top