Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[innsaneink]

Junior is responsible for one of the most breathtakingly bad plays I’ve ever seen on the football field, only surpassed by Heighno.

It doesnt define them though, very narrow minded of one if it does

You used to see Hodgo talked about and it was always the Tallis incident, it BS

 

[Kelce68]

That’s a bit like the old no offense but…

I specifically said I didn't make those comparisons though. I said that those names have been mentioned by others.

I was very specific about that.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Junior is responsible for one of the most breathtakingly bad plays I’ve ever seen on the football field, only surpassed by Heighno.

Never heard of Paul Carriage?

 

[BAGNF05]

I specifically said I didn't make those comparisons though. I said that those names have been mentioned by others.

I was very specific about that.

People compared Brooks to Johns too.

My point is, I wanna see it before putting pressure or expectations on a kid.

 

[Needaname]

If he is found guilty hopefully he is never let back in the nrl but I think he would at least get a 1 year ban + at least. Really good player that would elevate the team but at some point you have to draw the line with off field issues like that.

It was interesting to hear Terrell May comments re his brother and his state of mind.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

The club that let their best prop go because they thought they had Ben Hunt signed might.
Just imagine the media beatdown if Wests were that incompetent.

You know with the Roosters that no matter how bad matters get, they will always come out on top. That is the way it always has been.

 

[426Tlgerland]

If he is found guilty hopefully he is never let back in the nrl but I think he would at least get a 1 year ban + at least. Really good player that would elevate the team but at some point you have to draw the line with off field issues like that.

If guilty and get 1 yr ban would that include his time out of the game so far ? .
If so would we take him ( New management etc , or do we think there is a deal in play when Trel signed on

 

[Kaito]

If guilty and get 1 yr ban would that include his time out of the game so far ? .
If so would we take him ( New management etc , or do we think there is a deal in play when Trel signed on

Pretty sure they don't backdate time away from the
game for serious breaches if he's found guilty.
They do that in jail when you're on remand awaiting
court, if found guilty he would have missed 2 seasons.

I think he's a shoe in when & if he's found not guilty —
It was %100 brought up in the meeting before T
signed, benjis 1st words to him were "how's the family"

 

[Buttface]

If he is found guilty hopefully he is never let back in the nrl but I think he would at least get a 1 year ban + at least. Really good player that would elevate the team but at some point you have to draw the line with off field issues like that.

If Mat Lodge can play, then obviously the NRL cannot make a moral decision. He will play again.

 

[Tito Santana]

If Mat Lodge can play, then obviously the NRL cannot make a moral decision. He will play again.

100%.

League is the redemption game - not that I agree with it.

Michael Jennings - ultimate POS.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

100%.

League is the redemption game - not that I agree with it.

Michael Jennings - ultimate POS.

What if they are keen on Taylan May? 🤔

 

[Kaito]

What if they are keen on Taylan May? 🤔

Yeah right. After what they did to his brother smh

 

[Jux]

It doesnt define them though, very narrow minded of one if it does

You used to see Hodgo talked about and it was always the Tallis incident, it BS

I guess the point of difference on those three occasions is that Hodgo didn’t have much say in Tallis manhandling him and Heighno should never have been put in that situation.
Juniors was a brain fade (and haven’t we all had one of those ?) at the most inopportune time. Have to say though, he has recovered very well from that incident to make a real contribution at Easts.

 

[jadtiger]

Dolphins never rebuilt. The whole team was a debut

Most of the dolphins players were very experienced players from other clubs and certainly not making a debut in first grade

 

[Pbulk]

Looking at who is potentially available for the upcoming season it'd be amazing if we could convince the Rorters to do a season swap of Sullivan (they need a half) and Suia Wong (we need a 2nd rower). Benefits both teams IMO

 

[Buttface]

It’s very possible that Makasini is the only player that makes his NRL debut next season. That’s a big turnaround from 10 debutants this past season.

I think that was a plan.

 

[Buttface]

People compared Brooks to Johns too.

My point is, I wanna see it before putting pressure or expectations on a kid.

People compare blokes coming through all the time, it’s human nature. I don’t reckon Big Mak, (he needs Maccas sponsorship asap), is reading the WTF is see what @Kelce68 reckons, and if he is, then he’s got issues. What is important, is the people around him, the people Big Mak respects and listens to, that they are not telling him he’s the next Folou or Inglis.

Love ya work @Kelce68, you too Bags.

What about his baby face, he looks 15 until you pan back and realise that head is atop of a small mountain.

 

[Buttface]

Looking at who is potentially available for the upcoming season it'd be amazing if we could convince the Rorters to do a season swap of Sullivan (they need a half) and Suia Wong (we need a 2nd rower). Benefits both teams IMO

Stop it. I’m not alone.

 

[Buttface]

What if they are keen on Taylan May? 🤔

You must be joking?

 

[jadtiger]

Looking at who is potentially available for the upcoming season it'd be amazing if we could convince the Rorters to do a season swap of Sullivan (they need a half) and Suia Wong (we need a 2nd rower). Benefits both teams IMO

It would be nice but it would be a very very remote chance imho