Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[balmain boy]

Very poor treatment of two players that have played a significant part in elevating that club.

That's the dogs culture. Help us with immediate success or we'll force you out the door immediately.
Suits mercenaries but there's zero security for players signing there. If Gus doesn't like you you're done

 

[The Chad]

My guess would be we were looking at Voltano to replace Luke ? Guessing he’s leaving

Maybe.

I swear the supporters on here are even more reactionary than the 360 Journo's.

Luke made a joke to his mate Galvin. Whoopdee doo.

If Luke decides he wants out too- what do we lose? Another guy that hasn't proven himself?

 

[tigahhh]

Maybe.

I swear the supporters on here are even more reactionary than the 360 Journo's.

Luke made a joke to his mate Galvin. Whoopdee doo.

If Luke decides he wants out too- what do we lose? Another guy that hasn't proven himself?

Would be sad if he leaves but it’s not the end of the world, sure jurno’s will make it out to be though.

 

[tigahhh]

Tony Sukkar?

The 105kg backrower that averages about 95-100m a game in KOE?

I thought Sukkar has been very solid this year for us 😆

 

[The Chad]

I thought Sukkar has been very solid this year for us 😆

He has. For a couple of seasons.

I'm starting to wonder if people know which player Sukkar is.

The one in the centres is DOUEIHI.

The one at lock is TWAL.

They don't all look the same. 😀

 

[Tiger Stripes]

To me it seems like we were keen on getting rid of the excess Galvin stench. Don’t be surprised if Kit & Luke are next

All replaceable IMO.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

2 more years …


No .. the club if they pay him $900k

Is he worth 900k?

 

[Don Kershane]

Very sharp, Don.

At least someone got it.

 

[The Chad]

I want to Kit to kick on. I really do.

And Luke looks like he has talent.

But teeny little guys, even built solid, are still teeny little guys that need to be so much better to compensate for what they cannot train...size.

 

[tigahhh]

He has. For a couple of seasons.

I'm starting to wonder if people know which player Sukkar is.

The one in the centres is DOUEIHI.

The one at lock is TWAL.

They don't all look the same. 😀

I feel more safe with Sukkar out there than Seyfarth. He does need to work on his class with the ball but that’s with experience, hes still developing.

 

[Tom Shines]

Is he worth 900k?

I dunno … I thought we were talking about whether he is leaving ?

He seems a bit more chilled and go with the flow type… he might actually be happy hangin out with the bro’s ..

 

[tigahhh]

I dunno … I thought we were talking about whether he is leaving ?

He seems a bit more chilled and go with the flow type… he might actually be happy hangin out with the bro’s ..

yeah he’s definitely a big part of the group. They love him

 

[The Chad]

I feel more safe with Sukkar out there than Seyfarth. He does need to work on his class with the ball but that’s with experience, hes still developing.

Does he though? Right now, he's going to be back-up to KPP & Samuela Fainu. He's a role player.

If he's just a really good, solid defender....I mean, there are people clamouring to sign Kobe Hetherington....

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I dunno … I thought we were talking about whether he is leaving ?

Not in this instance. The comment I replied to was regarding his contract

He seems a bit more chilled and go with the flow type… he might actually be happy hang in out with the bro’s ..

We always think the next time will be different.

 

[balmain boy]

Why is he on the bench in NSW Cup and not getting a run in firsts when Panthers origin players are out?

Because he's not a modern back rower. He doesn't provide any strike, just work ethic.
We have a heap of workers but no one who can break the line, or score if they do make half a break.
I'd take him on a train and trial and he can earn a spot from there.

Saukuru is miles ahead of him in my view and we should be extending him for another year now.

 

[tigahhh]

Does he though? Right now, he's going to be back-up to KPP & Samuela Fainu. He's a role player.

If he's just a really good, solid defender....I mean, there are people clamouring to sign Kobe Hetherington....

Maybe not. I just kept thinking about a game where I think it was api hit him short and he almost scored to win the game but the ball hit the deck. Could’ve been API’s pass lol

 

[balmain boy]

If only we could develop a player like Preston.

Or we could just sign a Preston. Like the dogs did.
He was a lower grader with great potential when they signed him. We don't sign nearly enough players from other clubs juniors

 

[Tom Shines]

We always think the next time will be different.

I actually think each situation is unique and not necessarily dependent on what others have done ..

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Or we could just sign a Preston. Like the dogs did.
He was a lower grader with great potential when they signed him. We don't sign nearly enough players from other clubs juniors

The Bears are gonna go hard for Preston.

 

[Vicious]

I feel more safe with Sukkar out there than Seyfarth. He does need to work on his class with the ball but that’s with experience, hes still developing.

Sukkar runs the ball a lot stronger than Seyfarth, it’s Sukkar’s defence, particularly his goal line defence which is currently a long way behind someone like Seyfarth and is the concern in playing him for long minutes.