Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

BlackWhiteGold said:
If he is medically fine & has the desire and character that Benji wants, why not for a low salary depth roster spot?

Happy to hear other suggestions for an NRL experienced depth centre (able to play right side) who is available plus <$200k

Hiroti & Burns have extended at their clubs, either would have been good.
Click to expand...
Absolute waste of a roster spot imo. I'd rather have Mapaplangi, Tui'tupou and Tavana on NSW Cup/Dev deals than waste a top 30 spot on Corey Allan... Seriously, the guy is only making the Dragons side due to injuries.

Skelton, May, To'a and Turuva with Makasini, Laulilii, Mapapalangi, Tui'tupou and Tavana to cover our wing and centre spots is good enough for me. Need the top 30 spots used elsewhere in the team.
 
Canadian Club said:
Absolute waste of a roster spot imo. I'd rather have Mapaplangi, Tui'tupou and Tavana on NSW Cup/Dev deals than waste a top 30 spot on Corey Allan... Seriously, the guy is only making the Dragons side due to injuries.

Skelton, May, To'a and Turuva with Makasini, Laulilii, Mapapalangi, Tui'tupou and Tavana to cover our wing and centre spots is good enough for me. Need the top 30 spots used elsewhere in the team.
Click to expand...
I’d do both. Have Mapalangi, Tavana & Tui’tupou on T&Ts plus just think we need a ready-made NRL depth centre if May and/or To’a go down.

Look at the value that Marion Seve, Delouise Hoeter, Mawene Hiroti, Max Feagai etc, these types provide when called upon 3 or 4 times a season.

Maybe AD will be this player, maybe Bird will be trained at centre in the pre-season or maybe Naden will be extended. But if not, Corey Allen come on down lol
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
I’d do both. Have Mapalangi, Tavana & Tui’tupou on T&Ts plus just think we need a ready-made NRL depth centre if May and/or To’a go down.

Look at the value that Marion Seve, Delouise Hoeter, Mawene Hiroti, Max Feagai etc, these types provide when called upon 3 or 4 times a season.

Maybe AD will be this player, maybe Bird will be trained at centre in the pre-season or maybe Naden will be extended. But if not, Corey Allen come on down lol
Click to expand...
It's a 30 man squad with a salary cap, you can't have 3-4 back ups for each singular position its not plausible. Most those guys (except Hoeter who has only played 2 games in 3 years) are first man up for their squads in the outside back positions. I couldn't think of a bigger waste of a top 30 spot than Corey Allan...

Worst case scenario where both To'a and May went down, you have Makasini to go straight in and Laulilii (at either centre, or to wing with Turuva moving to centre). We are way better off playing and developing the young guys for a few games than Corey Allan. Corey Allan does nothing for the development of the squad and the young guys. Could you imagine the uproar on this forum if a young gun left because they were stuck behind Corey bloody Allan.

Beyond that, and somehow 3 go down, you have guys like Mapalangi and Tui'tupou who are capable enough and have First grade experience to cover a couple games. A guy like Allan does nothing at all. Mapalangi and Tui'tupou offer just as much, while on lower salaries and complimenting the development of the young guys.
 
Canadian Club said:
It's a 30 man squad with a salary cap, you can't have 3-4 back ups for each singular position its not plausible. Most those guys (except Hoeter who has only played 2 games in 3 years) are first man up for their squads in the outside back positions. I couldn't think of a bigger waste of a top 30 spot than Corey Allan...

Worst case scenario where both To'a and May went down, you have Makasini to go straight in and Laulilii (at either centre, or to wing with Turuva moving to centre). We are way better off playing and developing the young guys for a few games than Corey Allan. Corey Allan does nothing for the development of the squad and the young guys. Could you imagine the uproar on this forum if a young gun left because they were stuck behind Corey bloody Allan.

Beyond that, and somehow 3 go down, you have guys like Mapalangi and Tui'tupou who are capable enough and have First grade experience to cover a couple games. A guy like Allan does nothing at all. Mapalangi and Tui'tupou offer just as much, while on lower salaries and complimenting the development of the young guys.
Click to expand...
Agree to disagree. It’s all opinion based anyway CC. You and I both have no idea what Allan could offer a young backline.

I just think a player of his experience who is both solid in defence and attack can be a valuable squad member. I’ll leave it at that.
 
I'm not sure Corey Allan provides anything that Naden, Mapapalangi, Tu'itupou, Saukuru or Heath Mason don't already offer.

Could be as simple an issue as, if the depth at centre gets tested, Adam Doueihi or Jack Bird need to fill in.

I think May, To'a & Makasini along with Doueihi, Bird, Mason, Saukuru, Mapapalangi, Tu'itupou or moving Turuva or Lualili'i inside for a few games offers enough depth. I think there is a world where Brent Naden is decent value on the roster as a result.

Or, you give Latu some training at centre as well and round out his versatility.

If I'm recruiting from outside- find a backrower that can play some centre. Is Talakai still being shopped around?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 552 (members: 12, guests: 540)
Back
Top