Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tigahhh]

Melbourne chased him hard last year on Nov 1 but he chose to stay loyal and re-sign. It's the second time they had tried to get Fonua back down there. His brother will probably make his debut for the Storm in the next 1-2 seasons.

He copped a heap on the forum for his performances at the back end of the year, but he was one of our best players in the opening 10 rounds before he got injured. He's still only 23 and will only get better over the next 3-5 years as he comes into his prime years for props

couldn’t of said it better mate. his loyalty was huge.

 

[gregjm87]

Mate I have been pushing this idea for over a decade and every time I mention it I get smashed by non believers. You will not get an equal comp till everyone is playing on the same field. The cap has been more effective in the last couple of years bringing teams closer together but there is still a gap between a few clubs at the top and the rest of the pack.

Although I still very much doubt it would create an equal comp, that is not the biggest issue.
How do you possibly create a fair point system that doesn't under-rate/over-rate players? For the players a point system over-rates, how do they then get a fair contract given they will be a points liability? Won't the players under-rated by a point system still only go to the more powerful/cashed up clubs?
These are just the more obvious questions but I could ask plenty more. I'm happy to listen to any actual points system plan out forth but I've never seen anyone put up any without countless flaws that the proposer can't suggest a work around.

 

[user118245]

How can stefano come out and publicly court and lure him to the club when he’s under contract to us? The NRL has no backbone when holding up players to their contracts nowadays

 

[Tigerbenb]

Big Tom Ale ? Anybody

 

[GNR4LIFE]

How can stefano come out and publicly court and lure him to the club when he’s under contract to us? The NRL has no backbone when holding up players to their contracts nowadays

Stefano isn’t the one in the position of negotiating contracts.

 

[2041]

Although I still very much doubt it would create an equal comp, that is not the biggest issue.
How do you possibly create a fair point system that doesn't under-rate/over-rate players? For the players a point system over-rates, how do they then get a fair contract given they will be a points liability? Won't the players under-rated by a point system still only go to the more powerful/cashed up clubs?
These are just the more obvious questions but I could ask plenty more. I'm happy to listen to any actual points system plan out forth but I've never seen anyone put up any without countless flaws that the proposer can't suggest a work around.

It's one of those "nice idea, would never work in practice" things. You can pick so many holes in it I'm surprised there aren't photos of Kurt Cobain wearing it on stage.

Mainly what would happen is a huge market growing for players with low points ratings. There's no way a points system would be able to assign a fair rating to rookies, so you'd end up with massive bidding wars for people like Makasini. If there's no salary cap, or only a nominal one, you'd get ludicrous distortions like 19 year olds getting offered millions for short-term contracts then suddenly losing huge amounts of their market value when and if their points value goes up.

Then you have the problem of points values being recalculated, presumably, annually. What happens if you have a team that massively overperforms expectations and all the players' values go up, but a lot of them are on contracts that go longer than this year? The Raiders, for instance, would be massively over next season's points cap simply because they've been good. Now they're forced sellers: they get penalised for playing well.

As you say, I could go on all night. It's a completely unworkable concept, which is why no serious competition in the world uses it.

 

[innsaneink]

Big Tom Ale ? Anybody

Never heard of him except in this thread every 2nd week or so

 

[Tom Shines]

Melbourne chased him hard last year on Nov 1 but he chose to stay loyal and re-sign. It's the second time they had tried to get Fonua back down there. His brother will probably make his debut for the Storm in the next 1-2 seasons.

He copped a heap on the forum for his performances at the back end of the year, but he was one of our best players in the opening 10 rounds before he got injured. He's still only 23 and will only get better over the next 3-5 years as he comes into his prime years for props

He extended last year for 2 years from memory through 2027 …I will be surprised if we keep him beyond that as there has been speculation that he eventually wants to return to Melbourne ..

I think he deserved criticism for his play the back half of the year to be honest …anyhow let’s hope he plays well the next two years as I think he is capable and we need to be better up front

 

[tigerballs]

It's one of those "nice idea, would never work in practice" things. You can pick so many holes in it I'm surprised there aren't photos of Kurt Cobain wearing it on stage.

Mainly what would happen is a huge market growing for players with low points ratings. There's no way a points system would be able to assign a fair rating to rookies, so you'd end up with massive bidding wars for people like Makasini. If there's no salary cap, or only a nominal one, you'd get ludicrous distortions like 19 year olds getting offered millions for short-term contracts then suddenly losing huge amounts of their market value when and if their points value goes up.

Then you have the problem of points values being recalculated, presumably, annually. What happens if you have a team that massively overperforms expectations and all the players' values go up, but a lot of them are on contracts that go longer than this year? The Raiders, for instance, would be massively over next season's points cap simply because they've been good. Now they're forced sellers: they get penalised for playing well.

As you say, I could go on all night. It's a completely unworkable concept, which is why no serious competition in the world uses it.

The only thing that would work is a type of transfer system. Maybe where a player debuting for a club is on a discount for that club if his contract goes up. If his contract goes up to $500k, maybe the value against the cap is 75%, or $375k. If he goes elsewhere, his contract is 100% on the cap.

 

[jirskyr]

It's a delusional idea that instead of having a salary cap each player should be attributed a points value. Each team then is allowed to make up there roster up to a certain point value.
It's believed it will create a more even comp but the biggest flaw no-one can put forth any fair way for the point value attributed to each player.

You said it. Fantasy football for real-life NRL rosters.

 

[jirskyr]

Never heard of him except in this thread every 2nd week or so

I've very familiar with his brother Pale