OFFICIAL 2025 Grand Final Discussion Thread

Who wins?

  • Melbourne Storm

    Votes: 33 58.9%
  • Brisbane Broncos

    Votes: 23 41.1%

  • Total voters
    56
I'm team Madge. He was the wrong coach for our club, but you could never doubt his passion or commitment. Would love to read a tell-all on his time here with us. I bet you he had to deal with some stupid stuff caused by the way the board worked and the fact we had two clowns in charge.
 
Very quiet week / Build up to.the game...i guess thats the two out of sydney teams factor.
Would hardly know theres a GF tomorrow.
Saw.one bloke in a storm shirt at the local.shopping mall that's it
I’m not surprised. I’m not feeling any particular enthusiasm towards it. Personally I’m more interested in the social catch up and drinks with friends than the game itself.
 
I'm team Madge. He was the wrong coach for our club, but you could never doubt his passion or commitment. Would love to read a tell-all on his time here with us. I bet you he had to deal with some stupid stuff caused by the way the board worked and the fact we had two clowns in charge.
Why do ou think he was the wrong guy....and who do you think may have been better
Not having a go, just curious
I thought at first he'd get us super fit, and would help with our shitty defence...but as you said his management didnt help him one bit
 
Why do ou think he was the wrong guy....and who do you think may have been better
Not having a go, just curious
I thought at first he'd get us super fit, and would help with our shitty defence...but as you said his management didnt help him one bit
I thought Madge would get us fitted and more regimented during games but I think the change was too much for them. I actually believe if he had coached the following year we would of finished around 9th instead of the spoon

Then when sheen’s took back over I thought that at least we would become entertaining to watch even in in losses

But alas I was wrong
Just aswell I don’t gamble
 
Why do ou think he was the wrong guy....and who do you think may have been better
Not having a go, just curious
I thought at first he'd get us super fit, and would help with our shitty defence...but as you said his management didnt help him one bit
If we waited one year and got an interim coach after Cleary, or just made him see out his contract, we could have had Wayne Bennett.
 
If we waited one year and got an interim coach after Cleary, or just made him see out his contract, we could have had Wayne Bennett.
Yes what a monumental C up that was from our pathetic management at the time.

We may not have had to suffer for that long if Bennett got a hold of our roster and had his fingerprints over our junior pathways, we could have been in a really strong position presently.
 
Either the Storm lose consecutive gf’s or the Broncos lose two in three years. You don’t want to be in either of those positions.
 

Staff online

Back
Top