Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

If and when the Jack Bird release happens (you'd think in next 48 hours), that will leave us at 27 spots. Fair chance Bunty Afoa moves from T&T to Top 30 especially given the way he has trained in the pre-season + his experience.

Thinking we still need another experienced middle in our squad - one with a point of difference. I'd enter the chat for RAY STONE.

Smaller middle with high leg speed, great energy & leads from the front! Off contract but with the enormous middles depth at the Dolphins, could Benji bring him in for this season!!!
Not only do we really need an NRL quality middle with a point of difference such as Ray Stone with high leg speed and aggression, but assuming Royce and Bunty are regulars on our NRL bench we also lack an experienced middle to help toughen up our very young and inexperienced NSW Cup team.
I don’t think we are learning our lessons in a hurry as it will be like lambs to the slaughter if we have such a young and inexperienced NSW Cup team week after week.
I think we should have signed someone like Liam Knight to fill this role knowing he not long ago openly stated he ideally wants to remain in Sydney as opposed to returning to his UK Super League contract.
As for the backs anyone who has him on Instagram would know Harley Smith-Shields is elite fit and strong and being still quite young with NRL experience, surely he would add a bit of experience and depth to our squad.
 
Last edited:
Not only do we really need an NRL quality middle with a point of difference such as Ray Stone with high leg speed and aggression, but assuming Royce and Bunty are regulars on our NRL bench we also lack and experienced middle to help toughen up our very young and inexperienced NSW Cup team.
I don’t think we are learning our lessons in a hurry as it will be like lambs to the slaughter if we have such a young and inexperienced NSW Cup team week after week.
I think we should have signed someone like Liam Knight to fill this role knowing he not long ago openly stated he ideally wants to remain in Sydney as opposed to returning to his UK Super League contract.

Geez our reserve grade pack shaping up well with all these middles you guys want to buy. We"ll end up with

8. Sione
10.Twal
13.Pole

All in reserves and a cap squad balance completely out of shape
 
To transition back into society
And the best way he can do that is with a job..like WTs train and trial contract(if it isnt already done)
Hes no serial killer..but needs to pay the price for his behavior
Hes done that..served his non parole period as of rite now
And we all need to move forward//particularly WTs with an aging hooker who weve heavily invested in. who is showing wear and tear signs .
and at 27.with no play in past years..may go to 35/36 ,but only if he is fit enough physically and mentally good enough

There's no way he should be given a train and trial deal by us immediately. At best we should be getting him a start at Ryde Eastwood. Personally I dont think we should be making any play at this point in time. Not saying we shouldn't at some stage, but we shouldn't rush it
 
Not only do we really need an NRL quality middle with a point of difference such as Ray Stone with high leg speed and aggression, but assuming Royce and Bunty are regulars on our NRL bench we also lack an experienced middle to help toughen up our very young and inexperienced NSW Cup team.
I don’t think we are learning our lessons in a hurry as it will be like lambs to the slaughter if we have such a young and inexperienced NSW Cup team week after week.
I think we should have signed someone like Liam Knight to fill this role knowing he not long ago openly stated he ideally wants to remain in Sydney as opposed to returning to his UK Super League contract.
As for the backs anyone who has him on Instagram would know Harley Smith-Shields is elite fit and strong and being still quite young with NRL experience, surely he would add a bit of experience and depth to our squad.
Dont get the love for Ray Stone
95kg.... 29yo journeyman..who has never established imself as a first 13 selection
Weve got plenty of these already
Need to aim higher
 
Geez our reserve grade pack shaping up well with all these middles you guys want to buy. We"ll end up with

8. Sione
10.Twal
11.Seyfarth
12.Sukkar/Geyer
13.Pole

All in reserves and a cap squad balance completely out of shape
How do you work that out ?
Assuming we stick with May and Pole as our starting props and Twal as our starting 13, our 6 man NRL bench would likely be;
14. Latu Fainu
15. Alex Seyfarth
16. Sione Fainu
17. Royce Hunt
18. Bunty Afoa
19. Heamasi Makasini

It’s not even certain the 2 that miss out will be able to play NSW Cup on that same weekend and even if they can it’s highly likely there is at least one forward injured most weeks which would mean the players named above will be unlikely to play much if any NSW Cup in 2026.
IF and at this stage it’s a big IF we signed someone such as Ray Stone either before the season kicks off or sometime early in the season, that would help our depth, but aside from these middles we only really have Kit Laulilli pushing for NRL, so there is no doubt we are very light on middle forward depth which could become a big problem if we get a few injuries.
 
Last edited:
There's no way he should be given a train and trial deal by us immediately. At best we should be getting him a start at Ryde Eastwood. Personally I dont think we should be making any play at this point in time. Not saying we shouldn't at some stage, but we shouldn't rush it
Never a rush...but we need to be on the front foot as our circumstances suggest he cld be useful ...and there is a whole piranha of aggressive managers out there
Low risk/potentially high reward
Am no fan of his behaviour...but we hired Packer after all

Family stuff too which mite entangle us to the family
 
Dont get the love for Ray Stone
95kg.... 29yo journeyman..who has never established imself as a first 13 selection
Weve got plenty of these already
Need to aim higher
Not saying to sign him as an elite lock but a player who personifies effort & character and brings high energy, fast leg speed, leader in line speed to our pack (off the bench) not to mention experience and leadership in how to prepare & train. Fits Benji's game plan to a T.

Ray Stone, come on down please!
 
Agree.Its lost relevance IMO.
Stars give it a miss..
Don’t disagree, I think it’s NRL overkill but others like it. I’m just saying, if they’re going to persevere with it then that could be a good time.
Hynes saying he thinks it should be the first match of the first round every season. And evidently VLandys likes that idea as well.
I think SOO night best.
 
Dont get the love for Ray Stone
95kg.... 29yo journeyman..who has never established imself as a first 13 selection
Weve got plenty of these already
Need to aim higher
While trying to retain and upgrade a few of our current middles such as Sione Fainu, Terrell May, Sanuela Fainu and Fonua Pole, we will not have the cash to spend on anyone too high profile, so we have to think like Melbourne Storm have over the years and look to sign players that won’t necessarily do anything brilliant, but ones who can add something to our team at a lower contract value.
Over the last couple of seasons it’s been quite often we could do with someone who plays with high energy, hits top speed quickly when taking a hit up and demonstrates good defensive line speed.
A no frills player such as Ray Stone has these attributes.
 
Last edited:
While trying to retain and upgrade a few of our current middles such as Sione Fainu, Terrell May, Sanuela Fainu and Fonua Pole, we wk t have the cash to spend on anyone too high profile, so we have to think like Melbourne Storm have over the years and look to sign players that won’t necessarily do anything brilliant, but ones who can add something to our team at a lower contract value.
Over the last couple of seasons it’s been quite often we could do with someone who plays with high energy, hits too speed quickly when taking a hit up and demonstrates good defensive line speed.
A no frills player such as Ray Stone has these attributes.
Definitely need to find a diamond in the rough lock that won’t cost a fortune
 
No different to SOO risk.
Except it means so much less
Lost its soul
While trying to retain and upgrade a few of our current middles such as Sione Fainu, Terrell May, Sanuela Fainu and Fonua Pole, we wk t have the cash to spend on anyone too high profile, so we have to think like Melbourne Storm have over the years and look to sign players that won’t necessarily do anything brilliant, but ones who can add something to our team at a lower contract value.
Over the last couple of seasons it’s been quite often we could do with someone who plays with high energy, hits too speed quickly when taking a hit up and demonstrates good defensive line speed.
A no frills player such as Ray Stone has these attributes.
If we had Bellamy as coach it cld well transform Stone into a late developing SOO player
But we dont..its family first Benji
so its a pricey reserve grader blocking the path to cheaper young guys who mite actually step up to NRL level !!
Harsh I know!
 
Last edited:
From the Australian, wasn't sure where to post. Just a FYI post. Mods can move or delete, I won't get upset.

The NRL is on the verge of appointing Nine newspaper journalist Michael Chammas as their general manager of football at the PNG Chiefs.
This masthead understands that Chammas has been earmarked to take charge of the Chiefs’ football operations after being hand-picked by ARL Commission chair Peter V’landys to become a key player at the fledgling franchise.

The Chiefs, who recently announced that former Digicel PNG boss Lorna McPherson would be their chief executive, are due to enter the NRL in 2028.

Sydney Morning Herald reporter Michael Chammas.

Sydney Morning Herald reporter Michael Chammas.
The head of football role will be one of the most significant appointments given the team is starting from scratch. However, Chammas will take charge of PNG’s football operations armed with one of the most extensive contact books in the game.

The news breaker has reported on some of the biggest stories in rugby league over the past decade, earning a growing reputation as a media heavy hitter through his work with the Sydney Morning Herald, Nine News and 100% Footy.

He now faces an even more significant challenge in ensuring the Chiefs hit the ground running as they prepare to enter the NRL in 2028.

The Chiefs are yet to sign a player or coach, but they will head to market armed with tax-free dollars after the NRL struck an historic agreement with the federal government allowing for players to effectively double their income.

The PNG Chiefs are due to enter the NRL competition in 2028. Picture: Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images

The PNG Chiefs are due to enter the NRL competition in 2028. Picture: Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images
Players aside, the most significant appointment for the chiefs will be their inaugural head coach. That decision will be made by the AFL Commission as they wade through a list of candidates that include the likes of Arthur and Jason Demetriou.

Seven-time premiership winner Wayne Bennett has also been mooted as a prospective PNG coach, although the dream target would undoubtedly be Penrith mentor Ivan Cleary.

It is believed Panthers half Nathan Cleary is also on PNG’s wish-list as they look to make a big splash in the player market.

The Chiefs have had a rocky start to their existence.

Chief executive Andrew Hill quit to take over the role of Panthers Group CEO, while influential board member Wapu Sonk stood down amid corruption allegations, which he vehemently denies.

Hail to the Chiefs: PNG NRL team name revealed
The NRL's...
more
Last month, inaugural chair Ray Dib revealed he was forced out of his role with the 19th expansion side following an uneasy relationship with NRL powerbrokers.

Last year, it is understood Chammas was locked in talks over joining Perth as head of football when it looked like former Parramatta coach Brad Arthur would be appointed coach.

When Arthur was overlooked, the move went cold.

However, it is understood NRL powerbrokers have been intent on bringing Chammas into the tent to play a role in the game’s future.

The Perth Bears appointed former media identity Anthony De Ceglie (right) as their inaugural CEO. Pictured here with NRL chief executive Andrew Abdo and coach Mal Meninga. Picture: Getty Images

The Perth Bears appointed former media identity Anthony De Ceglie (right) as their inaugural CEO. Pictured here with NRL chief executive Andrew Abdo and coach Mal Meninga. Picture: Getty Images
Chammas would be the second media personality to take on a role with an expansion side after the NRL appointed former Channel 7 boss Anthony De Ceglie chief executive of the Perth Bears.

In May last year, Chammas was involved in a fiery exchange with Canterbury general manager of football, Phil Gould, over the Bulldogs’ signing of former Wests Tigers prodigy Lachlan Galvin.

Now, the Nine stablemates could come head to head as opposing football department bosses.

More to come …

More Coverage​

 
Back
Top