Rd 18 live game discussion

[weststigers]

Toa the forgotten man

He never knew we existed. Who forgot who?

 

[weststigers]

That Jennings kid for Souths goes alright

 

[innsaneink]

Lol walker.... you wouldnt wanna go to randwick with him

 

[Siberian Kitten]

The ref and bunker were so busy deciding whether Milky dropped it that they missed an absolutely blatant double movement.

 

[Oldman]

The ref and bunker were so busy deciding whether Milky dropped it that they missed an absolutely blatant double movement.

Couldn’t agree more, the arm carrying the ball touches the ground and he promotes the arm out to advance the ball over the try line.
I’ve given up on knowing which way the bunker is going to go on any call these days.

 

[tiger_one]

Epic brain fart lol

 

[tiger_one]

The ref and bunker were so busy deciding whether Milky dropped it that they missed an absolutely blatant double movement.

 

[EllisFan]

View attachment 39966

Believe they took a very similar one off makasini at Campbelltown.

 

[innsaneink]

View attachment 39967

They spent 10 minutes talking about this post game....i guess souths will get the official apology from Annesly on monday...chris butler what a dud

 

[69-05-41]

Unfortunate that Latrine has played his token 10 games for 2026 and is off riding quad bikes in Taree. Souff Sinney needed some trademark head-slamming dog-shots tonight but all Walker could produce was an embarrassing kick in the shins. LOL@Souffs

 

[Merlot]

Unfortunate that Latrine has played his token 10 games for 2026 and is off riding quad bikes in Taree. Souff Sinney needed some trademark head-slamming dog-shots tonight but all Walker could produce was an embarrassing kick in the shins. LOL@Souffs

poor ole Latrell was the poster boy of all us downtrodden, funny how wheel turns.

 

[innsaneink]

Nice start to the weekend Souths getting done

Cogger 2 weeks
Walker 1.

 

[tig_prmz]

I was yelling obstruction before Jenkins got the ball, and then yelling double movement on the first replay.

The Bunker ignores the whole thing and only looks at the put down. What rubbish.

That obstruction was as clear as day but not many especially in commentary seem to talk about it.

 

[tig_prmz]

Why cant we do these shifts so well.....souths do it time and again its so dangerous....speed...we have little

All 13 men moving forward on different lines with genuine speed.

When we do these shifts, 4 of our forwards are just lingering on in the background or have run a 2m decoy next to the dummy half. Those decoys do nothing when doing a spread. The line gets held up for half a second and then they just slide.

 

[tig_prmz]

So Souths 18 year old is killing it and he’s not the first one this season. Why can’t our young blokes play as well as this?

Good coaches at younger levels makes a big difference.

The better the coaches, the more the coaches, the more individual coaching each player gets. They learn professionalism and education.

We get players that have genuine skill like Makasini, Laulili, Roberts etc but they're still way too raw because they haven't been coached to NRL level before they get to it.

I almost feel like we are doing them a disservice by making them play NRL without training them for it first..

 

[jadtiger]

Good coaches at younger levels makes a big difference.

The better the coaches, the more the coaches, the more individual coaching each player gets. They learn professionalism and education.

We get players that have genuine skill like Makasini, Laulili, Roberts etc but they're still way too raw because they haven't been coached to NRL level before they get to it.

I almost feel like we are doing them a disservice by making them play NRL without training them for it first..

Having part time coaches in reserve grade will do that,we are so far behind every other club because of the inaction or quasi sabotage of our owners in not spending real money and providing support to our football club.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

The ref and bunker were so busy deciding whether Milky dropped it that they missed an absolutely blatant double movement.

What I said to my partner when it happened, he was tackled and held onto by the defender, the elbow of the arm carrying the ball fully grounded he then lifted the arm and extended it over the line and double movement penalty should have been result, 2 of this blokes tries should have been awarded as no tries
But, hey its penrith ????

 

[TheEnz]

I dont understand how they did not rule double movement...could the argument be that it was all one movement i.e his ball carrying arm never stopped? If so thats not my understanding of the rule. It was obvious he extended his arm and planted the ball. Im genuinely interested in how they explain it.

 

[jadtiger]

I dont understand how they did not rule double movement...could the argument be that it was all one movement i.e his ball carrying arm never stopped? If so thats not my understanding of the rule. It was obvious he extended his arm and planted the ball. Im genuinely interested in how they explain it.

The NRL will probably bury their head in the sand like they usually do.There is a reason Anusley stopped doing his Monday briefings and the cynic inside me believes he didn't want to publicly acknowledge his team of ref's get things woefully wrong far too often especially the one in the bunker.

 

[innsaneink]

His whole body stopped bar his arm after it touches the ground....compared to the roosters one they were showing that was all momentum and his whole body ended up ingoal