Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

I like Tony Sukkar as a prospect, but I’d be pushing strongly to let him spend 12 months gaining valuable experience in the UK Super League and re-signing him with us for 2028.
This leads into my rant- WT should link up with an ESL club and that would smooth the clubs swapping players for different experiences and development needs and still working within their contracts
 
I wouldn’t be surprised if it ends being a swap, Jamal Fogarty for Jock Madden.
Jock sighted in recent photos with Jake Simpkin and Kobe Hetherington.

That will save about $80k for the Tigers considering the Broncos are paying most of Maddens freight …although I guess it might “encourage “ Manly to eat more of Fogarty’s salary in 2027…

The negative is that Fogarty is under contract in 2028 …
 
That will save about $80k for the Tigers considering the Broncos are paying most of Maddens freight …although I guess it might “encourage “ Manly to eat more of Fogarty’s salary in 2027…

The negative is that Fogarty is under contract in 2028 …
Interestingly Fogarty & Madden are both managed by PSM (Orr).

On one hand, don't think they'd like WT to recruit one of their own to potentially block another of their own.

On other hand, it maybe attractive to Manly under a salary squeeze to bring in Madden on peanuts for experience and still subsidise some of Fogarty to us.
 
It just makes too much sense to have:

-Latu Fainu with Javon Andrews deputy
-Jamal Fogarty with Jock Madden deputy

As often is the case atm, the big elephant in the room is Adam Doeuihi.

Maybe there is a world where AD accepts his greatest value is as a utility off the bench able to play nearly every position except prop or dummy half. And this also includes a transition into a tackle-breaking backrower off the bench (which we need depth in).

Let's start the AD to depth backrow campaign. Could be a strike weapon on the edge!
No doubt this is one of a few options where we could get the best value out of Adam Doueihi if he put his mind to it.
If we signed Fogarty and kept Madden, that no doubt gives us 2 similar playing style of number 7’s which would mean our playing style would barely need to change if either of them was starting.
On the Doueihi debate, I’m still not convinced we have enough strike within our team to be without his run threat.
For that reason alone I wouldn’t be writing him off as at least a contender for our starting 6 and if Latu earns our starting 6 spot ahead of him, then I’d still ideally like Douehi as a strike weapon off the bench.
 
It's going to be very hard to remove AD this year. We are already paying $500k for JL to play elsewhere, we will probably have to pay another $300k for AD. I doubt Manly is releasing Fogarty or any other club is releasing a halfback while paying them.

I am happy enough with us having AD, Latu, Madden and Andrews in the halves this year. Survival of the fittest and aim to get an experienced half for 2028 if these guys need support.

Personally I like 6. Fainu and 7. Madden. Jock is not a superstar, but he is a consistent 6/10. He will help Api get us to the same spot on Tackle 5, kick in the same spot each time. Rinse and repeat.

Consistency can be boring and predictable but that's what top teams do on tackle 5.
 
It's going to be very hard to remove AD this year. We are already paying $500k for JL to play elsewhere, we will probably have to pay another $300k for AD. I doubt Manly is releasing Fogarty or any other club is releasing a halfback while paying them.

I am happy enough with us having AD, Latu, Madden and Andrews in the halves this year. Survival of the fittest and aim to get an experienced half for 2028 if these guys need support.

Personally I like 6. Fainu and 7. Madden. Jock is not a superstar, but he is a consistent 6/10. He will help Api get us to the same spot on Tackle 5, kick in the same spot each time. Rinse and repeat.

Consistency can be boring and predictable but that's what top teams do on tackle 5.
Who is more likely to lead us into the Top 8 in 2027 - Jamal Fogarty or Jock Madden? That may be what Benji is determining right now.
 
Am i wrong in thinking we have decent winger depth and additions are needed elsewhere. Or are people thinking another winger would be good?
I guess we lost Skelton but effectively gained Tupou.
We have winger depth but not all of it is good. Tavana and Makasini have a ways to go before they become consistently good first graders and Tupou has never really impressed though he seems to have improved slightly since he was last with us.

Turuva can be a good winger but he showed a bit of weakness in areas of his game this season, plus he’s a short arse like many of our wingers.

I would be stoked if we could snag Campbell Graham if Souths have to shed someone due to salary cap pressure. Sure he’s had some injuries but maybe he’s due for a clear run. On his day he is one of the best winger/centres in the game and he would be head and shoulders above (literally) any wingers we have at the moment.

A combo of Fogarty kicking for Graham would be heaven for us right now. Make it happen Benji!
 
It's going to be very hard to remove AD this year. We are already paying $500k for JL to play elsewhere, we will probably have to pay another $300k for AD. I doubt Manly is releasing Fogarty or any other club is releasing a halfback while paying them.

I am happy enough with us having AD, Latu, Madden and Andrews in the halves this year. Survival of the fittest and aim to get an experienced half for 2028 if these guys need support.

Personally I like 6. Fainu and 7. Madden. Jock is not a superstar, but he is a consistent 6/10. He will help Api get us to the same spot on Tackle 5, kick in the same spot each time. Rinse and repeat.

Consistency can be boring and predictable but that's what top teams do on tackle 5.
Wasn’t it reported that 250k of the 500k we are paying for Luai was negated during the 2026 season?
 
It's going to be very hard to remove AD this year. We are already paying $500k for JL to play elsewhere, we will probably have to pay another $300k for AD. I doubt Manly is releasing Fogarty or any other club is releasing a halfback while paying them.

I am happy enough with us having AD, Latu, Madden and Andrews in the halves this year. Survival of the fittest and aim to get an experienced half for 2028 if these guys need support.

Personally I like 6. Fainu and 7. Madden. Jock is not a superstar, but he is a consistent 6/10. He will help Api get us to the same spot on Tackle 5, kick in the same spot each time. Rinse and repeat.

Consistency can be boring and predictable but that's what top teams do on tackle 5.
I think it’s safe to say the AD thing is dead and buried. There has been no hint of anything since he came back and did the presser. You don’t think the media would be drumming up conflict if there was even a hint of smoke? It’s a dead story imo.
 
Personally I’d move AD to the bench then have him come on after 20 as a 13 and also be a utility if needed. But that would depend on if his ego would let him if not ➡️🚪
 
Who is more likely to lead us into the Top 8 in 2027 - Jamal Fogarty or Jock Madden? That may be what Benji is determining right now.

We already have 5 halves if you count Averillo and we cannot get rid of any of them. If you try to get rid of AD, add $300k to whatever you're giving Fogarty.

Fogarty is def better than Madden, but $600 or $700k better? I don't think so. Esp considering we are already paying JL.

I can't make up my mind. Maybe Fogarty can be a good coach for the younger halves as he's trained under Ricky.

My gut is telling me that we have enough "old" people in our squad. The coaches should have belief in themselves because the halves we have now have potential. Mann, Frizz and Brailey can help instill professionalism whereas Benji and Hodgo can help them with the technical aspects of the game.
 
Wasn’t it reported that 250k of the 500k we are paying for Luai was negated during the 2026 season?
Not sure how much we are paying him but honestly doubt it's anything less than 400k. Parra is stupid but not enough to give him more than 800k for one season.
 
I think it’s safe to say the AD thing is dead and buried. There has been no hint of anything since he came back and did the presser. You don’t think the media would be drumming up conflict if there was even a hint of smoke? It’s a dead story imo.
I think internally is dead. Media will talk about it for a bit longer but I don't think it's mentioned much inside the rooms. Players move on from this stuff pretty quickly.

But, his value has dropped. We would have to chip in almost 50% of his value if we ask him to look around. Considering that, he's worth having on the bench as a utility or 2nd choice halfback at least.
 
Who is more likely to lead us into the Top 8 in 2027 - Jamal Fogarty or Jock Madden? That may be what Benji is determining right now.
I think it’s highly likely that’s exactly what Benji is thinking.
I was as baffled as anyone else when I first read that we had offered Makasini to the Eels for the 2027 season as a swap for Addo-Carr, but it now makes me think we probably did offer him due to trying to make room to fit both Fogarty and Addo-Carr in.
Regardless I still think it is/was a bad idea to even contemplate letting Makasini head elsewhere for a year when we are also short on quality outside backs.
IF we need to find approximately 400k to fit both Fogarty and Addo-Carr in, I’d be looking to move Turuva or if that’s not possible, maybe Seyfarth.
 
Last edited:
I think it’s highly likely that’s exactly what Benji is thinking.
I was as baffled as anyone else when I first read that we had offered Makasini to the Eels for the 2027 season as a swap for Addo-Carr, but it now makes me think we probably did offer him due to trying to make room to fit both Fogarty and Addo-Carr in.
Regardless I still think it is/was a bad idea to even contemplate letting Makasini head elsewhere for a year when we are also short on quality outside backs.
IF we need to find approximately 400k to fit both Fogarty and Addo-Carr in, I’d be looking to move Turuva or if that’s not possible, maybe Seyfarth.

I know Makisini had a poor year … but not that poor surely to ship him off to the slimeys ..

Benji did him zero favours last year …I’d like to see if he has grown into his body a little more over this offseason ..
 
Works for Manly as well if the rumours they are over the cap are true.
I would hope to pay no more than 600k for Fogarty, with Manly subsidising the rest.
They need to offload him more than we need him. Id be going far more aggressive.
 
Back
Top