Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Top 8 lol…

Saints, parramatta, storm, Brisbane all have better rosters than us and didn’t make the finals …

Unfortunately for us to make the 8 next year even if those two guys come

We need bula and Latu to be like unbelievable

Rn bula is average and Latu is not consistent

If those two have break out years which I can’t see bula havjg bc I think he’s shown us his level already … than we could make the 8

But I doubt it

We need origin and rep players and marquee players in the spine and we don’t have them

Apart from API all other spine players are out of the top 8 - that’s just fact
 
Prime JAC was the best pure winger I've seen in the speedster sense. At 31, he is definitely past his silkiest best, but he is still super fast off the mark and an excellent finisher. We need a winger, so this is an easy Yes.

Fogarty is an interesting one. He is a proper in-game kicker, cool under pressure and could steer a team effectively, exerting leadership from the middle. If he were to rediscover +80% goal-kicking form that would be particularly valuable. He is clearly better than our current best halfback options, but he will be 33 next month, so there's that.

On that note, I am all for a healthy mix of experience and youthful exuberance, but I note (a) we didn't exactly have a team of rookies to begin with and (b) have already signed a bunch of 30-something's for bench spots and depth. They might help us grind out wins, but the direction with recruitment this off-season has become a bit confusing to me, not to mention slightly triggering of former days.
 
@BlackWhiteGold - Unsure about Bunty.

We know he was on a development deal last year & we know we have 1 development spot still vacant so maybe it is the same this year. Maybe ask Shaun?

We definitely have 27 signed. Sukkar still pending. So maybe 28.

Fogarty & JAC could be 29 & 30 depending what's happening with Bunty.

I guess we I'll find out more over the next few weeks
 
Prime JAC was the best pure winger I've seen in the speedster sense. At 31, he is definitely past his silkiest best, but he is still super fast off the mark and an excellent finisher. We need a winger, so this is an easy Yes.

Fogarty is an interesting one. He is a proper in-game kicker, cool under pressure and could steer a team effectively, exerting leadership from the middle. If he were to rediscover +80% goal-kicking form that would be particularly valuable. He is clearly better than our current best halfback options, but he will be 33 next month, so there's that.

On that note, I am all for a healthy mix of experience and youthful exuberance, but I note (a) we didn't exactly have a team of rookies to begin with and (b) have already signed a bunch of 30-something's for bench spots and depth. They might help us grind out wins, but the direction with recruitment this off-season has become a bit confusing to me, not to mention slightly triggering of former days.

One thing Fogarty isn't is cool under pressure. He has shown time and again he crumbles.
 
@BlackWhiteGold - Unsure about Bunty.

We know he was on a development deal last year & we know we have 1 development spot still vacant so maybe it is the same this year. Maybe ask Shaun?

We definitely have 27 signed. Sukkar still pending. So maybe 28.

Fogarty & JAC could be 29 & 30 depending what's happening with Bunty.

I guess we I'll find out more over the next few weeks

Assumption may be wrong, Bunty must be on a train and trial as he has been photographed at training
 
One thing Fogarty isn't is cool under pressure. He has shown time and again he crumbles.
Yes.
He was really good in 25 until that finals series came along. He relies a lot on his other halves partner to get the backline moving and Strange was on fire that year as well, although missing the second final with illness.
 
Yes.
He was really good in 25 until that finals series came along. He relies a lot on his other halves partner to get the backline moving and Strange was on fire that year as well, although missing the second final with illness.

Ive noticed he cant nail a field goal under pressure and he has missed some really easy conversions at important times. He just has that lack of something inside him that likes those moments. Steady week to week, but dont rely on him to get ya home in a big moment.
 

Jamal Fogarty has two years remaining on his contract and turns 34 next month. Let's be realistic: he was an average NRL halfback even in his prime.


If Benji Marshall wants to stake his coaching future on a player who is best an average half, then good luck to him. I think it's completely the wrong decision.


If we're negotiating with Manly, why not take a different approach? Offer to take Bullemor and Navale on full freight and give the Tigers arguably their strongest forward depth in 15 years.


Then back Latu Fainu and Andrews to develop into the halves combination we actually need. Give these young players an opportunity and give the fans something to genuinely get excited about.


I'd much rather invest in the future than pay a premium for someone else's ageing halfback.
Fogarty played some good football for the Raiders and a couple of good games for the Eagles. If Manly are subsidising his contract substantially, that is a good outcome. But he is nothing more than a stop gap and WTs must have a young half such as Conti developing to take over for the long term.
 
A.D would be very handy off the bench. Can cover lots of positions. Also if we are behind a need an X factor to come on and change the game.
Imagine the blow up when Adam is told he is coming off the bench. Hope we can still offload him after the the way he carried on last year. Doubt anyone other than a superleague team would want him.
 
It's bizarre that we've gone from having one of the youngest squads in the NRL three years ago to potentially having the oldest if Fogarty signs. We will literally be Dad's Army in 2027.

I hope it works, but there seems to be a lack of balance within our squad now.
Nearly 25% of our squad 30 and over. While some are bit players, others such as Fogarty, Frizell and Api will imo be major contributors to the team. Twal is Twal and he'll play to his usual high standard. We've gone from one extreme to moving towards another. The major outcome for me is at the end of next season, we have high quality players to replace them on retirement.
 
Nearly 25% of our squad 30 and over. While some are bit players, others such as Fogarty, Frizell and Api will imo be major contributors to the team. Twal is Twal and he'll play to his usual high standard. We've gone from one extreme to moving towards another. The major outcome for me is at the end of next season, we have high quality players to replace them on retirement.
We're all crossing our fingers that this is the case. I'm sure every Tigers supporter wants to make the eight next year. But it's not a long term solution, and it could potentially block our juniors and potentially force some to leave.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top