Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

If there is any possibility the story is true, I doubt there is any benefit to his development … they are doing it to free up money to accomodate Fogarty..,

God knows how this story of Manly’s money problems suddenly become another Tigers debacle 😂
This is the issue. Freeing up money to sign Fogarty. Manly didn’t agree to how much we wanted them to contribute. So instead keeping the pressure on them by not budging on our number we roll over again but this is has far more severe consequences. Anyone comparing this to Harry Grant loan clearly has no idea. We aren’t shipping Latu off to gain Nrl experience, we are shipping him off to free up space to sign a guy who I don’t think gets us into the 8. If only we had a coach who believed in development. If only we had a coach who played 6 & could help that young player master his craft at 6. Oh wait hmmm. If only our CEO had a backbone. So many “if only”. I am certain this is Candid Camera & we are the Annual star.
 
There is no way in the world that after being given control over NRL recruitment and retention, that Benji is going to back down and accept other people making these recruitment and retention decisions for him.
So it’s either give him a chance to build a playing roster he is happy with, or if we can’t do that we need to sack him and start over again.
This is where signing the overrated Luai in the first place and more recently even slightly overpaying players such as Bula and Turuva has come back to bite us, and here we are now trying to find a way to save approximately 400k to sign Fogarty and Addo-Carr.
Had we not overspent on the other players, we would NOT be needing to offload or loan out anyone.
 
Last edited:
There is no way in the world that after being given control over NRL recruitment and retention, that Benji is going to back down and accept other people making these recruitment and retention decisions for him.
So it’s either give him a chance to build a playing roster he is happy with, or if we can’t do that we need to sack him and start over again.
This is where signing the overrated Luai in the first place and more recently even slightly overpaying players such as Bula and Turuva has come back to bite us, and here we are now trying to find a way to save approximately 400k to sign Fogarty and Addo-Carr.
Had we not overspent on the other players, we would NOT be needing to offload or loan out anyone.

Some might question the decision to also extend AD for a further 2 years … they also probably had an opportunity to walk away when he refused to play last season.
 
Mail
the club wants latu to spend time in cup next year, latu open to it, club also happy for him to play elsewhere including superleague they do see him as our future, but want to make sure he isnt thrown into a furnace like every other prodigal son that we heap pressure on to

the club will not let him leave until a deal is done, his brothers are locked in, club working with nrl to clear a path for mainse
 
Mail
the club wants latu to spend time in cup next year, latu open to it, club also happy for him to play elsewhere including superleague they do see him as our future, but want to make sure he isnt thrown into a furnace like every other prodigal son that we heap pressure on to

the club will not let him leave until a deal is done, his brothers are locked in, club working with nrl to clear a path for mainse

Sorry mate … I’m not really buying this …although it seems you have covered off all options

If it’s really about his development..; this could be kept in-house… there is really no benefit to send him away ..:

The main issue they should be working on with the conditioning staff, is getting his body right so he can actually remain on the field for an extended period which if we are being brutally honest .., he has not managed to do in three seasons
 
Some might question the decision to also extend AD for a further 2 years … they also probably had an opportunity to walk away when he refused to play last season.
Why when he was reportedly re-signed for under 500k, he was clearly our best player in 2025 and again our best player while we were successful up until round 9 in 2026.

Based on playing ability, his contract is not a bad contract.
If he starts the 2027 season playing 6, with a dominant on the ball halfback in Jamal Fogarty playing 7, they should compliment each other.
In saying this I still think we should ideally start the 2027 with Latu Fainu and Javon Andrews partnered together in the halves in NSW Cup and offload Jock Madden who I really like as a player, but Latu and Javon need and deserve to be our first choice back ups if the players in front of them are not performing up to expectation or injured.
 
Mail
the club wants latu to spend time in cup next year, latu open to it, club also happy for him to play elsewhere including superleague they do see him as our future, but want to make sure he isnt thrown into a furnace like every other prodigal son that we heap pressure on to

the club will not let him leave until a deal is done, his brothers are locked in, club working with nrl to clear a path for mainse
They dont wanna throw him into a furnace wearing a tigers jersey but happy to do so with him wearing another clubs jumper?

I see
 
Mail
the club wants latu to spend time in cup next year, latu open to it, club also happy for him to play elsewhere including superleague they do see him as our future, but want to make sure he isnt thrown into a furnace like every other prodigal son that we heap pressure on to

the club will not let him leave until a deal is done, his brothers are locked in, club working with nrl to clear a path for mainse
*sigh of relief*
 
Mail
the club wants latu to spend time in cup next year, latu open to it, club also happy for him to play elsewhere including superleague they do see him as our future, but want to make sure he isnt thrown into a furnace like every other prodigal son that we heap pressure on to

the club will not let him leave until a deal is done, his brothers are locked in, club working with nrl to clear a path for mainse

So basically the club is saying how we have handled Latu the past 3 years has been wrong and right when an opportunity comes up to use him in his specialist position we are gonna go back to square one and develop him the way we should have the past 3 years. You honestly cant make this shit up. The club is being run by complete imbeciles and Benji is top of the list. He is running this club into the ground.
 
Mail
the club wants latu to spend time in cup next year, latu open to it, club also happy for him to play elsewhere including superleague they do see him as our future, but want to make sure he isnt thrown into a furnace like every other prodigal son that we heap pressure on to

the club will not let him leave until a deal is done, his brothers are locked in, club working with nrl to clear a path for mainse

Fogs and the Fox? Locks
 
So basically the club is saying how we have handled Latu the past 3 years has been wrong and right when an opportunity comes up to use him in his specialist position we are gonna go back to square one and develop him the way we should have the past 3 years. You honestly cant make this shit up. The club is being run by complete imbeciles and Benji is top of the list. He is running this club into the ground.
No doubt Latu’s development has been badly mishandled and he’s not the only one.
Much lesser known players have also been badly mishandled, but nobody cares about them.
The common denominator was signing Luai in the first place and being impatient when knowing full and well the club had prodigious talents in Galvin and Latu Fainu on its hands.
Roll around to where we are now as we can’t go backwards, what is the harm in planning on having Latu Fainu and Javon Andrews starting the 2027 season as our NSW Cup halves pairing, letting them continue to build their combination and confidence and having them available to be the first players called up to our NRL team if the players in front of them are not performing or injured?
 
Why when he was reportedly re-signed for under 500k, he was clearly our best player in 2025 and again our best player while we were successful up until round 9 in 2026.

Based on playing ability, his contract is not a bad contract.
If he starts the 2027 season playing 6, with a dominant on the ball halfback in Jamal Fogarty playing 7, they should compliment each other.
In saying this I still think we should ideally start the 2027 with Latu Fainu and Javon Andrews partnered together in the halves in NSW Cup and offload Jock Madden who I really like as a player, but Latu and Javon need and deserve to be our first choice back ups if the players in front of them are not performing up to expectation or injured.

what is ADs best position ? This is the problem with him … whilst I agree there have been times over the past two years he has been our best player ( we are one of the weakest teams in the comp) .. there doesn’t appear to be a natural fit for him… a half must be able to pass the ball and set up outside players… I also really question his motor to play at 13 …this leaves him with a bench spot which I could deal with , although I’m not sure his ego will.

I think to give him a now three year committment is looking like a poor decision .,even at $500k per year …

I really question what the plan is for Andrews … you think if there was mutual interest they would have gone in hard to lock him up already ,,,he can now sign elsewhere for 2028 and he is QLD boy that might look north for his next opportunity
 
No doubt Latu’s development has been badly mishandled and he’s not the only one.
Much lesser known players have also been badly mishandled, but nobody cares about them.
The common denominator was signing Luai in the first place and being impatient when knowing full and well the club had prodigious talents in Galvin and Latu Fainu on its hands.
Roll around to where we are now as we can’t go backwards, what is the harm in planning on having Latu Fainu and Javon Andrews starting the 2027 season as our NSW Cup halves pairing, letting them continue to build their combination and confidence and having them available to be the first players called up to our NRL halves if the players in front of them are not performing or injured?

Mate , Galvin wanted out before he played a first grade game … he refused to even look at their over the odds offer … his pathway was never blocked ,,,,far from it ,,,they put him in the NRL as soon as they could ,,,the reality is that he was never going to stay here …didn’t want to and he was always going to have other options

Latu could have been handled better , although from memory this time last season you weren’t that keen either to play him in the NRL team in 2026… his injury issues have hampered his development primarily IMO..
 
No doubt Latu’s development has been badly mishandled and he’s not the only one.
Much lesser known players have also been badly mishandled, but nobody cares about them.
The common denominator was signing Luai in the first place and being impatient when knowing full and well the club had prodigious talents in Galvin and Latu Fainu on its hands.
Roll around to where we are now as we can’t go backwards, what is the harm in planning on having Latu Fainu and Javon Andrews starting the 2027 season as our NSW Cup halves pairing, letting them continue to build their combination and confidence and having them available to be the first players called up to our NRL team if the players in front of them are not performing or injured?

I think the harm is that Latu is the half we have that can really tear oppositions apart but he is the one being held back constantly.
 
The “logic” is this ..

If this story is actually true - tbey want to loan out Latu to free up money to sign Fogarty…I don’t think it needs to be more complicated than that

the story seems odd to me … he is off contract end of 2027 , so his agent is already free to approach other teams.,,

Don’t forget we had a story earlier in the week that Makasini was getting “loaned out” to Parramtta … tnat story seemed to go nowhere…maybe this one might be the same
You find another way to get Fogarty. This kid has been screwed around enough. And if @kade7 is to be believed, I only feel further justified in what I said. Their acknowledging that they have failed in their handling of him.
 
Even after a nights sleep, I’m struggling to see the logic here. The way I see it, there are only two reasons you would loan out players. One being a kid with virtually no NRL experience, and you don’t see a pathway to first grade for them that year. But down the line, you obviously do. Or, it’s a player who is surplus because you are well covered for depth. Not a kid at 22, who has played the house down any time he has gotten a decent crack and didn’t manage to injure himself. If the saying “If he could just stay fit” applied to anyone more than Latu, I’ve never seen them. How stupid was I to assume that a halves role was automatically his after Galvin left. He’s been F’d around so long, I have no idea why he’d still want a bar of this place or Benji. Regardless of his brothers.
I hope he goes to a good club and gets some proper guidance and doesn’t come back. Best thing he’ll do for his career
 
Back
Top