Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Then why didn’t they play him in Cup last season to continue his development as a 7 with Javon instead of giving him scrap minutes off the bench in a position he doesn’t play in?

(Not having a go at you, just genuinely frustrated by the idiocy of the coaching staff)
Agreed but I would be prepared to give them some degree of having to do what they did due to lack of depth and a cruel toll of injuries and suspensions.
 
With all this recent drama …, what’s the word with Pole ?

Now a free agent ..,



Couldn’t agree more., if you are referring to his playing time with us moving forward 👍
Yes, think Pole might be being tempted to go elsewhere. Done his time here and used us as a shop front window to display his wares. Hope im wrong but the silence doesn't bode well.
 
I don’t think it’s a leap to say that a lot of this Latu loan BS is about placating AD and keeping him happy with a spot in the halves.

You don't jeopardise you future halves for Adam [This word has been automatically removed]ing Doueihi, Benji!
Whether it’s true or not, Doueihi and Benji have painted themselves into a corner where it’s easily believable that that’s the reason. They have to wear that.
 
Someone posed the question earlier, does Fogarty even want to come here? The guy signed a 3 year deal with Manly in good faith and now after just one year, they are shopping him around like cattle.

WT are keen to sign him, most of us on the forum are keen for him to come here, but is Jamal? I don’t think anyone has even considered how this the bloke feels about having to move so soon again and joining a club he may not even be interested in.
I think he would not want to hang around a team that doesn’t want him , tigers show he will be our top 1/2 back , it would be a no brainer
 
Agreed but I would be prepared to give them some degree of having to do what they did due to lack of depth and a cruel toll of injuries and suspensions.
I get what you’re saying but I’m still not giving them that out.

Even with all the injuries, there were multiple opportunities to play Latu as a starting half and Benji opted for Jock Madden every single time. The depth issue is on Benji as he is responsible for recruitment and he wanted to let our backup hooker, TDS, walk early

Benji used Latu off the bench to cover his recruitment/retention mistakes and it was at the expense of Latu’s development as a half.
 
Yea it’s fair. Just feel we are weakening our roster not strengthening it

Maybe signings to come
Think a lot of us have a soft spot for Royce but you've seen the reaction to the alternatives to provide cap space, especially Latu.

Organiser and pace coming in and 10 minutes of blunt force trauma going out, well, it's not a difficult decision considering we have some depth in the middle.
 
Don't think our forward depth is good enough to get rid of Royce. We were well below par on forward depth this year and so far we have lost 2 (Afoa and Hunt) and signed two (Frizzle and Mann).

Amongst all signing talk, I just don't think we have addressed our biggest issue and thats forward depth. A winger such as JAC will have limited difference in my opinion, with how we play. It's not like we are creating a heap of opportunities for our wingers. Turuva went 13 games or so without scoring, and it was not as if I sat there and thought he should of scored any...there was literally very few opps that went his way.

We need to be better in the middle and edges first and I don't see that being improved (much).
 
I get what you’re saying but I’m still not giving them that out.

Even with all the injuries, there were multiple opportunities to play Latu as a starting half and Benji opted for Jock Madden every single time. The depth issue is on Benji as he is responsible for recruitment and he wanted to let our backup hooker, TDS, walk early

Benji used Latu off the bench to cover his recruitment/retention mistakes and it was at the expense of Latu’s development as a half.
Dont disagree. I think Benji's use of the bench, and selections for, have been pretty crook. Hopefully better in 27 with some new coaching staff
 
A lot of emotion and speculation about the Latu situation which is understandable. I have been the same as Latu is one of my favourites and I have so much belief in his ability and where it can take us.

But I think we should wait until the club gives us an explanation to its recruitment strategy this season. An explanation which will probably only come once our recruitment for 2027 is done unfortunately.

1 We don't know Benji's reasons for allowing Latu to explore a loan for 2027.

2 Maybe Benji has identified the need for a game managing senior halfback to improve the team.

3 Maybe there was more to the Doeuihi blow-up last season than what has been revealed (cough Luai) & maybe AD is still held in high regard by his team mates. Not condoning how he went about it but maybe his relationship with Benji & team mates has not been affected.

4 Maybe the football dept has seen the need for more senior players who lead standards both on the field & training, hence the arrival of Frizell, Mann, Brailey and possibly JAC and Fogarty.

5 I think we have all identified a lack of speed out wide as a need for us so JAC ticks another box here & explains our early interest in Schiller and bringing back pathways player Mikey Nassar.

6 Maybe we are at 29 contracted players atm if Bunty Afoa & Tony Sukkar are amongst them. Maybe to get a few extra pieces that the football dept have identified (Fogs & JAC and maybe another), we have to let a player or 2 go. May explain Royce still be allowed to explore opportunity plus Latu, who knows who else has been given permission.

Look there a lot of maybes in there and for a reason, we don't know what the club are doing and the reasons for it. And we probably won't know for a while yet either. But no need for some of the comments about Benji & Shaun imo until we hear from them.
 
A lot of emotion and speculation about the Latu situation which is understandable. I have been the same as Latu is one of my favourites and I have so much belief in his ability and where it can take us.

But I think we should wait until the club gives us an explanation to its recruitment strategy this season. An explanation which will probably only come once our recruitment for 2027 is done unfortunately.

1 We don't know Benji's reasons for allowing Latu to explore a loan for 2027.

2 Maybe Benji has identified the need for a game managing senior halfback to improve the team.

3 Maybe there was more to the Doeuihi blow-up last season than what has been revealed (cough Luai) & maybe AD is still held in high regard by his team mates. Not condoning how he went about it but maybe his relationship with Benji & team mates has not been affected.

4 Maybe the football dept has seen the need for more senior players who lead standards both on the field & training, hence the arrival of Frizell, Mann, Brailey and possibly JAC and Fogarty.

5 I think we have all identified a lack of speed out wide as a need for us so JAC ticks another box here & explains our early interest in Schiller and bringing back pathways player Mikey Nassar.

6 Maybe we are at 29 contracted players atm if Bunty Afoa & Tony Sukkar are amongst them. Maybe to get a few extra pieces that the football dept have identified (Fogs & JAC and maybe another), we have to let a player or 2 go. May explain Royce still be allowed to explore opportunity plus Latu, who knows who else has been given permission.

Look there a lot of maybes in there and for a reason, we don't know what the club are doing and the reasons for it. And we probably won't know for a while yet either. But no need for some of the comments about Benji & Shaun imo until we hear from them.

All those maybes still dont make the decision right though IMO. Even accounting for 1 or all of those things, its still a terrible decision
 
Back
Top