Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

while I struggle with it myself, I’ll try and paint a picture based on what it is when it works…

at its core, Benjiball is based on repeat efforts and elite physical fitness. defensively that looks like multiple men in tackles and aggressive linespeed, hard scramble and tying in from the inside, kick pressure and supporting one another constantly.

in attack it manifests in offloads and second phase and wearing down opponents by constantly applying pressure with similar shapes and slight variations.

it requires belief, patience and cool heads, because it isn’t sexy or particularly polished.

the forward pack is typically mobile and toils. the backs have a low centre of gravity designed to break tackles and make ground.

in the spine, the 1’s main responsibility is to play through the middle corridor like an old school fullback and sniff around for offloads and take carries. the 9 looks to utilise their deceptive skillset to hold up the markers and the A and B defenders.

in the halves, one is the controlling and organising type that is typically the pass before the pass, while the other plays both sides out the back of shape like a typical fullback, arriving late to apply pressure and put defenders in two minds in good ball territory.

see wins against NZ in NZ, Newcastle at Campbelltown (2026) and Cronulla and St George (2025) for it’s best examples.

how’d I go?

Well it’s quite a detailed explanation so thanks for that…👍

I think my briefer description matches how they actually been playing though most games the past two years … and we can’t really blame Latu for those deficiencies given his lack of opportunity .. ( I’m not saying you are either ..just responding that he “doesn’t fit Benji’s scheme” .,.how would we know) ?

Has Bula been fulfilling his role in the system as described I wonder ? Not after he got the new deal anyway 😂

The line speed was great early when they were winning and then went out the back door …

Seems to me that we weren’t able to properly cover the losses of Sam F, KPP and Taylan last year …and that was the main reason we went down the gurglar
 
So you can constantly knock him and have your opinion on him and that’s fine. But you don’t like that I am defending him. I may just be an average supporter I’m still entitled to my opinion.It won’t matter what I say you will just keep going on. As I have said no finals next season I’m happy for him to get the boot
Easy big fella. No one said you aren’t entitled to defend him. If you are going to come at me though, at least justify your position. Don’t expect to take a broad swipe without a push back.
 
while I struggle with it myself, I’ll try and paint a picture based on what it is when it works…

at its core, Benjiball is based on repeat efforts and elite physical fitness. defensively that looks like multiple men in tackles and aggressive linespeed, hard scramble and tying in from the inside, kick pressure and supporting one another constantly.

in attack it manifests in offloads and second phase and wearing down opponents by constantly applying pressure with similar shapes and slight variations.

it requires belief, patience and cool heads, because it isn’t sexy or particularly polished.

the forward pack is typically mobile and toils. the backs have a low centre of gravity designed to break tackles and make ground.

in the spine, the 1’s main responsibility is to play through the middle corridor like an old school fullback and sniff around for offloads and take carries. the 9 looks to utilise their deceptive skillset to hold up the markers and the A and B defenders.

in the halves, one is the controlling and organising type that is typically the pass before the pass, while the other plays both sides out the back of shape like a typical fullback, arriving late to apply pressure and put defenders in two minds in good ball territory.

see wins against NZ in NZ, Newcastle at Campbelltown (2026) and Cronulla and St George (2025) for it’s best examples.

how’d I go?
Sweet 4 examples out of 48 games..... effective aye......
 
I know you're not being racist, mate, but there's no need to bring backgrounds into it when half our squad are proud Polynesian boys bleeding for the club.

All that matters is how they go on the field.
Fair enough mate no disrespect I love what the poly boys bring to the club

It was a bit tongue in cheek it's the offseason let me have a bit of fun when we don't have to deal with losing
 
Well it’s quite a detailed explanation so thanks for that…👍

I think my briefer description matches how they actually been playing though most games the past two years … and we can’t really blame Latu for those deficiencies given his lack of opportunity .. ( I’m not saying you are either ..just responding that he “doesn’t fit Benji’s scheme” .,.how would we know) ?

Has Bula been fulfilling his role in the system as described I wonder ? Not after he got the new deal anyway 😂

The line speed was great early when they were winning and then went out the back door …

Seems to me that we weren’t able to properly cover the losses of Sam F, KPP and Taylan last year …and that was the main reason we went down the gurglar
yeah it probably does. the ladder positions of the past few years certainly reflect that, and I certainly agree that Latu hasn’t been given the time he probably deserves to determine whether he fits.

Bula definitely dropped off after the injury. he’s got work to do. as you say those injuries hurt us no end.
 
@Vicious Jye Gray should be on our radar, we don't have players in our current squad who make line and tackle breaks.

Bula really needs to step up this year. If he doesn't have a big year we won't be playing finals.
That’s a hard one as Jye can really spark his teams attack, but his lack of size and height does make him a defensive liability, particularly under the high ball.
 
Sweet 4 examples out of 48 games..... effective aye......
I sought to give examples of it working at its best, not necessarily other wins or close losses or thrashings.

the win and loss columns of the past few years indicate it hasn’t been working too well, but I think there’s been plenty of indications of square pegs in round holes.

wanting to bring in Fogarty indicates to me that they’re trying to find players that fit the system as opposed to bending others to try and fit.
 
Bula definitely dropped off after the injury. he’s got work to do. as you say those injuries hurt us no end.

With Bula, I hope his decline in form is the result of an injury, that can get better …we are up the creek otherwise given his contract …I think the other three can come back well this year … those 4 mentioned are our 4 best attacking options right there,and we need them in the attacking 20 …
 
Easy big fella. No one said you aren’t entitled to defend him. If you are going to come at me though, at least justify your position. Don’t expect to take a broad swipe without a push back.
I’m sorry I’d didn’t realise I was taking a broad swipe and as in your first post you are asking me to justify my opinion I don’t feel the need to do so. As i keep saying i am happy for him go if he fails next season .I don’t want to get into disagreements with fellow tigers supporters like everyone on here I just want success for the club.
 
I sought to give examples of it working at its best, not necessarily other wins or close losses or thrashings.

the win and loss columns of the past few years indicate it hasn’t been working too well, but I think there’s been plenty of indications of square pegs in round holes.

wanting to bring in Fogarty indicates to me that they’re trying to find players that fit the system as opposed to bending others to try and fit.
It's an observation not a criticism....if they wanted to loan Latu out last year was the time to do it. If it's about development they would put him in cup for the year with Andrews. It has zero to do with his development and everything to do with Benji keeping his job.

Forgarty and Fox are not taking us to the top 8 and we will be lucky to avoid the bottom 4 should we persist with AD in the halves .....
 
I sought to give examples of it working at its best, not necessarily other wins or close losses or thrashings.

the win and loss columns of the past few years indicate it hasn’t been working too well, but I think there’s been plenty of indications of square pegs in round holes.

wanting to bring in Fogarty indicates to me that they’re trying to find players that fit the system as opposed to bending others to try and fit.
I would say Jock Madden and Jamal Fogarty are very similar in playing style, it’s just a matter of opinion on whether Fogarty who will likely cost us somewhere near 600k per season offers much more than Madden who is supposedly only costing us around 200k.
IF we could guarantee Jock would be at his best much more often, I don’t think we would be considering Jamal, but on what has been demonstrated throughout their NRL careers so far, it’s more likely to get high quality games out of Jamal on a more consistent basis.
In saying this I think Jock was playing injured which was hampering him at the back end of last season, so maybe it’s a little unfair judging him on those games and we should instead be judging him on the quality he showed in the early part of last season.
Personally I would not be upset if we showed a bit of faith in Jock and started the 2027 season with him at 7, but I can also understand the interest and would not be unhappy if we sign Jamal.
I just don’t think it works for us by having both of them as we 💯 need to keep Latu with us and have him playing him in the halves for our NSW Cup team, if he’s not demanding a spot in the halves for our NRL team.
He should no longer be considered a bench player for our NRL team, either starting halve for NRL or NSW Cup.

I think we need the speed and class of Addo-Carr more and that would make the likes of Makasini, Saukuru and Tupou have to work hard, play extremely well and force their way into our NRL team.
 
Last edited:
With Bula, I hope his decline in form is the result of an injury, that can get better …we are up the creek otherwise given his contract …I think the other three can come back well this year … those 4 mentioned are our 4 best attacking options right there,and we need them in the attacking 20 …
No more excuses for Jahreem..
Hopefully injury free and some straightening halves ( or at least one) and a fit Ta may and jake A helps
 
I’m sorry I’d didn’t realise I was taking a broad swipe and as in your first post you are asking me to justify my opinion I don’t feel the need to do so. As i keep saying i am happy for him go if he fails next season .I don’t want to get into disagreements with fellow tigers supporters like everyone on here I just want success for the club.
So you feel you can attack others opinions and create strawmans without telling them why they are wrong? Bold strategy, Cotton.
 
We’re did I say he can or can’t. What I’m trying to say is for 15 years no finals it can’t just be the last 3 or 4 coaches. At the end of next season if we don’t make finals he can go. But will that solve the problem just constantly changing coaches just asking

But you are saying that like the Benji critics dont agree or arent saying the same. Most of, if not close to all, agree with what you just said. Just because one says Benji cant coach doesnt mean they dont think the rest of the stuff you have pointed out. Or do you want them to state eveything that is wrong with the club every time the criticise Benji?
 
Back
Top