LIVE GAME Rd 11 Magic Round discussion *spoilers*

• May 17, 2026

• #261

Tucker

Well-known member

mtd#2 said:

It’s not a point I dont believe to be correct.

Click to expand...

Well you need to step back and watch the games with a less critical eye.
Brisbane have been very ill disciplined, just as our mob were yesterday.

 

• May 17, 2026

• #262

mtd#2

Well-known member

So holding a player down after a break, given a penalty, isnt a professional foul - even though a penalty was given? 😂😂

 

• May 17, 2026

• #263

S

Speed2burn

Well-known member

That was a blatant sin bin as you’ll ever get

 

• May 17, 2026

• #264

B

BirchgroveTiger

Well-known member

Tucker said:

They have to scrap 6 agains as well. You can’t catch your breath continually running backwards and tackling.

Click to expand...

Exactly Tucker, and most of the time we don’t know why they’re called!!😖 Get rid of them

 

• May 17, 2026

• #265

E

EllisFan

Well-known member

mtd#2 said:

So holding a player down after a break, given a penalty, isnt a professional foul - even though a penalty was given? 😂😂

Click to expand...

Referees can’t keep up with the speed of the game either.

 

• May 17, 2026

• #266

J

Jedi_Tiger

Well-known member

EllisFan said:

Poor month for us.

Spare a thought for the red V though.

0-9 with Panthers and Warriors to come next.

Click to expand...

warriors with perhaps
no
Barnett
Ford
Boyd
Egan

 

• May 17, 2026

• #267

F

Flippedy

Well-known member

I’m either getting old or losing my eyesight or both, but I honestly can’t see what some of the penalties are for sometimes.

 

• May 17, 2026

• #268

E

EllisFan

Well-known member

Jedi_Tiger said:

warriors with perhaps
no
Barnett
Ford
Boyd
Egan

Click to expand...

Still win by 20

 

• May 17, 2026

• #269

S

Speed2burn

Well-known member

Flippedy said:

I’m either getting old or losing my eyesight or both, but I honestly can’t see what some of the penalties are for sometimes.

Click to expand...

It’s a disaster. You pay to watch the officiating these days

 

• May 17, 2026

• #270

mtd#2

Well-known member

EllisFan said:

Referees can’t keep up with the speed of the game either.

Click to expand...

The referee is the one who gave the penalty, so he kept up, he just chose not to send him to the bin for it. I guess they'll call that "interpretation"

 

• May 17, 2026

• #271

F

Flippedy

Well-known member

Oh man that really sucks!

 

• May 17, 2026

• #272

E

EllisFan

Well-known member

mtd#2 said:

The referee is the one who gave the penalty, so he kept up, he just chose not to send him to the bin for it. I guess they'll call that "interpretation"

Click to expand...

I guess there’s so much happening it’s affecting their decision making. Clear wrong call.

 

• May 17, 2026

• #273

F

Flippedy

Well-known member

No more of a knock on than Toia’s try last week.

 

• May 17, 2026

• #274

T

Telltails

Well-known member

Whattt!! How do you explain that?!

 

• May 17, 2026

• #275

innsaneink

Moderator

Forum Leader

So downward pressure is a thing according to Gee

 

• May 17, 2026

• #276

mtd#2

Well-known member

Also if walsh is off for a his after a hit to his head from a kick, how is Barnett not in the bin?

They went back and looked at it..
So its not a questuon of keeping up, it's incompetency at its finest.

 

• May 17, 2026

• #277

S

Speed2burn

Well-known member

This game is seriously broken lmfao

 

• May 17, 2026

• #278

TigerBurnsy

Well-known member

Telltails said:

Whattt!! How do you explain that?!

Click to expand...

How tf was that not high then the doctor forces Walsh to go off

 

• May 17, 2026

• #279

T

Telltails

Well-known member

Barnett no penalty fair contact - Rhys W told to leave the field

 

• May 17, 2026

• #280

TigerBurnsy

Well-known member

Speed2burn said:

This game is seriously broken lmfao

Click to expand...

Warriors cop a constant bj from the officials