OFFICIAL Jarome Luai - #295

full80 said:
I don't claim to be an expert ( as I start commenting like I am one, lol) but I think a lot of this was in a whole package of investment into PNG as part of a defence strategy to curtail China. Wasn't that long ago that Cook Islands did a deal to allow Chinese military to have a base there, and it explains government's recent trips to Pacific nations. I suspect altering tax laws for a relatively few Australian football players is small stuff in the scheme of things for them. (and all governments do offer 'tax incentives' for other reasons. In my industries lots of US companies are offered 'unfair' tax treatment to entice them here to spend money. Whether or not it is benefit to my industry is another matter).
Click to expand...
It is small potatoes but the Govt did play the rugby league card very well. They knew how big it is up there and using as leverage was a clever political move.
Step one has gone smoothly but I think there’s going to be a few roadblocks along the way.
 
Merlot said:
Also had me wondering - so their money tax free statis is land locked unless they clean it , shuffle it out of PNG.
When Sterlo and that era of player went to mother England for a top up,they used to pay them in flight coming back to Australia in international air space to avoid tax laws /or so the story went
Click to expand...
As someone who has worked overseas it’s not landlocked. On return you can transfer it as long as you paid that countries defined tax for that period. The issue becomes if you didn’t live in that country for the full tax year, and lived in Australia partially, then it’s subject to Australian taxation as well.

Finish your time there at the end of the financial year you can transfer it back without issues. The interesting part will be that the NRL season doesn’t line up with the tax year so could make it messy in that sense.
 
Tom Shines said:
Decisions been made … may as well hope for the best that everyone just moves on .,, I don’t know about you, but I don’t think Wally Lewis or Nathan Cleary is walking out the door early…
Click to expand...
They wouldn’t be at WT in the first place.

Feels to me like Benji’s hand was forced in this.

Luai should of been our 6 next year with Latu & Javon competing for the 7.

Instead we’ll enter 2027 as wooden spoon favourites and a coach under enormous pressure.
 
TheEnz said:
Even if deep down Benji has decided our chances of making the top 8 are zero, he will still be committed to winning more games and finishing higher than last season....that's probably more critical for him and the club than giving a few young guys a taste.
Click to expand...
This is where a Head of Football steps in and says no, if our halves next year are going to be kids, we better get them some experience. Shame we don’t have anyone in that role.
 
EllisFan said:
This is where a Head of Football steps in and says no, if our halves next year are going to be kids, we better get them some experience. Shame we don’t have anyone in that role.
Click to expand...
Agree 100% EllisFan. There would be plenty of work to do in that area of responsibility and if they haven’t got a HoF, then those tasks would be either ignored or farmed out to a single person or a handful of people with “other more important responsibilities.” Ones that have KPIs.
Other clubs have high respect for the role.
 
TheEnz said:
Dont know if they are "off" him, however i have seen a bit of a shift in the dynamic and to be entirely honest even from the start he seemed to be a bit aloof from the rest of the team. He has a number of businesses he pursues outside of the WT so you very rarely see him in any of the pics the guys share when they are out with each other. On the field and in the media he is all in with the team, however outside of that i don't think he really socializes with them.
Click to expand...
This was happening well before PNG signing.
 
EllisFan said:
This is where a Head of Football steps in and says no, if our halves next year are going to be kids, we better get them some experience. Shame we don’t have anyone in that role.
Click to expand...
We will have 2 very experienced halves in Doueihi and Jock Madden and 2 young emerging halves in Latu and Javon Andrews.
That to me looks like a good balance and if we can recruit to ensure we have a bit more strength around them even if we have a few injuries, I can’t see how a combination of those 4 halves cannot get the job done.
 
Last edited:
Halbrowne61 said:
I think Benji must make the call “ for the good of the team” to start putting him in the bench to give our young guys a go.

IMO there’s something ( don’t know what) not right about this whole saga , but whether we’ll ever know is unlikely.
Or maybe I’m just cynical in my old age.
Click to expand...
I agree, i dont blame either Luai or the club, i see both sides and believe theyre both valid in what theyve done. But for Luai to say it took a bit of time to sink in, shows me that the club would have told him your all good for next year then changed their position. I get its for the future but believe theres more. Just think its an excuse and think some in the dressing room are off him.
 
TheEnz said:
Dont know if they are "off" him, however i have seen a bit of a shift in the dynamic and to be entirely honest even from the start he seemed to be a bit aloof from the rest of the team. He has a number of businesses he pursues outside of the WT so you very rarely see him in any of the pics the guys share when they are out with each other. On the field and in the media he is all in with the team, however outside of that i don't think he really socializes with them.
Click to expand...
Just my speculation, thing that makes it hard is all the injuries to key players we've had. If we have this slump with our full team id be certain imo that we have a fractured group. With the injuries we've had and lack of depth at the club the heavy losses although they sting are understandable. Really hard to guage. Just strange that the club has changed footing.
 
Putting this here because I heard an imbecile journalist describing there being a tax payment when a player returns to Australia. No true at all. Thats a UK things.

short version:

Luai sells his Aussie house, buys a house in PNG, moves wife and kids there, sets up local bank accounts, genuinely demonstrates he is living there permanently… he won’t pay income tax. If he then ‘changes his mind’ and decides to move back to Australia in 5 years, he still won’t pay income tax on money he brings back.

Long version:

If a player like Luai actually restructures his life around PNG (family relocates, no Australian home retained, under 183 days in Australia, genuine PNG abode), he could become a non-resident for Australian tax purposes. Then:

• Only Australian-sourced income remains taxable here (e.g., Australian investment income, rent).

• PNG-sourced salary and PNG-sourced image rights (third party deals) fall outside Australia’s tax net entirely.

• If dual-resident under domestic law of both countries, the DTA tie-breaker (permanent home, centre of vital interests, habitual abode, nationality, in that order) decides which country wins primary taxing rights.
 
TheEnz said:
Dont know if they are "off" him, however i have seen a bit of a shift in the dynamic and to be entirely honest even from the start he seemed to be a bit aloof from the rest of the team. He has a number of businesses he pursues outside of the WT so you very rarely see him in any of the pics the guys share when they are out with each other. On the field and in the media he is all in with the team, however outside of that i don't think he really socializes with them.
Click to expand...
Ive seen the team post training sessions at a particular cafe atleast 5 times this year, never once seen Luai.. I also dont think ive seen twal either to be fair.
 
EllisFan said:
They wouldn’t be at WT in the first place.

Feels to me like Benji’s hand was forced in this.

Luai should of been our 6 next year with Latu & Javon competing for the 7.

Instead we’ll enter 2027 as wooden spoon favourites and a coach under enormous pressure.
Click to expand...

I don’t think they will be in the spoon favourites… probably around 4th- 5th last
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 2,963 (members: 4, guests: 2,959)
Back
Top