Search results

  1. G

    OFFICIAL Jarome Luai - #295

    Definitely a reason. Doubtful he was the reason for any of them. I'd prefer Luai doesn't leave but don't think it is a huge problem if he does. He will never play to his contract value. Yes, the intangibles and culture change I believe is/was very much driven by him. So in this respect I...
  2. G

    Koroisau Suspended

    Personally I think rulings are fairly consistent with some outliers. Now when I say consistent that is assuming comparing apples with apples. Referencing the Burton tackle does not do this so whilst I agree he is lucky not to be missing games comparing a hip drop to a throw is not apples with...
  3. G

    LIVE GAME Rd 8 - Discussion spoilers

    No, they are not. I tipped them to miss the 8 at the start of the season but I thought they would be in the cluster of teams competing for the final couple of spots. I've seen nothing to suggest they will be one of those teams.
  4. G

    LIVE GAME Rd 8 - Discussion spoilers

    They could though I doubt they will. Munster has been awful but we've seen them pick and stick and get performances in the past. Plenty of decent/in form options in DCE, Walker, Dearden, Clifford, Campbell, Boyd but none demanding selection.
  5. G

    Koroisau Suspended

    Why is Martin still being accused of feigning injury? He tried to play on but eventually left the field. Early reports (pre-scans) suggesting he is out for 3 weeks.
  6. G

    LIVE GAME Rd 8 - Discussion spoilers

    Grant the only locked in. Munster and Loiero probably based purely on incumbency. Maybe Coates as well if he can return for a few decent games. Utoikamanu a chance.
  7. G

    LIVE GAME Rd 8 - Discussion spoilers

    Evidence that a coach is only as good as his squad?
  8. G

    LIVE GAME Rd 8 - Discussion spoilers

    I don't really care but I've always been an advocate of support your team, not disrespect the other team.
  9. G

    Koroisau Suspended

    I stand corrected. His was much worse.
  10. G

    Koroisau Suspended

    Could you please explain what metrics you used to judge it to be worse?
  11. G

    Koroisau Suspended

    Don't think he was a realistic chance. Not saying he didn't deserve to be in consideration, simply that I don't think he ever was.
  12. G

    Koroisau Suspended

    Grade 2. Seems right when compared to other hip drop charges.
  13. G

    TEAM LIST Round 8 vs Raiders

    Surely it's just about getting some minutes into him in ressies.
  14. G

    TEAM LIST Round 8 vs Raiders

    Herbert was originally from Whakatane, like Marshall. Herbert moved as a child to Auckland where he lived on the same street as Toa.
  15. G

    Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

    He didn't blow out in weight last year. He was playing big minutes in reserve grade all last season.
  16. G

    Where are we at competitively?

    From what I have seen thus far. Panthers are a class above. Dragons are a class below. All other teams in between there is not a lot between them. I did not think we would be top 8 before the season, not far away but not genuinely challenging the 8. 6 games in I now believe there is no excuse to...
  17. G

    TEAM LIST Round 7 vs Broncos

    Numbering for wings and centres mean absolutely nothing as far as left and right go.
  18. G

    Rd. 7 NRL discussion *Spoilers*

    It will stop some. It will also be manipulated as free interchanges for others.
  19. G

    Rd. 7 NRL discussion *Spoilers*

    2002 they lost 6 in a row. Still managed to finish 10th, 1 win away from the 8.
  20. G

    Rd. 7 NRL discussion *Spoilers*

    2012. They went on to win the comp
Back
Top