Search results

And this is the new world that @Kul wants. Good luck guys. Have fun with your bitter fights.

That 2 long terms mods were removed without an explanation will make this my last time on the forum after being here from the beginning of it all. Thanks to all the great mods who put up with the rubbish, particularly @willow Very disappointed. Bye all.

Yes, he is not. But how is Madden an option given ZDC was 3 classes above him last year in reggies?

Very loose with his views at times

Yep. That’s the real worry. I have not seen Jock put in a single performance that has made me think “yeh, he might just have it”

For those saying “give him a chance”. Why? What potential have you seen that I haven’t. He was poor in KOE. We have had much better halves at that level who never made it to first grade. Drinkwater, Miller the list goes on. Jock wasn’t even our best halfback in KOE this year

The fact the club re-signed Jock is pretty incredible. Lovely young bloke but not a first graders rear end

Simpkin, Simpkins and Tuilagi are worth investing in

No he is not. The fact he is even close to first grade is the problem.

You mean the forum favourite?

Agree his kicking game was good. Apart from the two 7 tackle sets he gave away. Rest of his game very ordinary. He gives his all. Just isn’t a first grader. I agree Luke didn’t play well

I am being harsh. I admit that. He certainly is no JT. He is a poor man’s Mathew Head. Tackles like Tulsen Tollet

Cool. Let’s just see how the career of Jock goes. If he proves me wrong, I will be extremely happy

Yeh he was. Go watch the game again. I love his passes to players standing still. They were special

Jock Madden? The guy who was awful out there today? Or is there a different Madden I’m not aware of?

Re Mbye, Not really. That dropped ball was a killer for our momentum. He also dropped the bomb that led to a try. I know it was tough but fullbacks have to catch them

Mate you blame Brooks for everything. I’m still waiting for Luke’s connection to the lab in Wuhan

Yes he should have told grown men how to tackle and hold a ball. Cameron Smith would have made sure his players could hold a ball

Yes it’s Luke’s fault that Adam is slow

LOL Yes, we lost this game because of our half back. He let in the tries through the middle and dropped all the balls. Your analysis is spot on