3 2 1 V Warriors

[gallagher]

A tough choice after Farah. So many good games.
Farah 3
Aloiai 2
Thommo 1

 

[TJ21]

3 Faz
2 Twal
1 Aloiai

I would like to know what madge said to Aloiai in the preseason!

 

[happy_tiger]

Benji had a very controlled game

You'd have given him a 7/10

But I reckon at least 6 players 8 /10 or more

But in saying that I'd keep Benji in the 6 if he can play with those game smarts for 25 rounds

My concern is the Dogs game …much like the Manly game at almost the exact same stage last season ....we start to possibly run over the top of them and our spine start thinking 2005 ...

 

[newtiger]

Not only Josh, but the whole team!!!

 

[gallagher]

Yes, a big concern.

 

[Kev]

Its another example of how the awarding of dally m points are usually incorrect. They give them to the biggest names instead of the best performers.
Anyone who watched closely would know that the forwards dominated that game. I doubt I could have fit a back into my top 5 performers. Not rewarding Twal for his huge effort isnt fair.

 

[old_man_tiger]

Absolutely no surprises this week, I'm posting a day early as I won't be able to tomorrow and the vote is not changing.

3 - Farah (135 points)
2 - Twal (61 points)
1 - Aloiai (36 points)

Thompson (16 points) and Packer (13) were next. 7 other players polled between 1 and 8.

The season Tally so far:

Farah - 4 points
Ryan Matterson/Josh Aloiai - 3 points
Alex Twal - 2 points

:tiger2:

 

[fibrodreaming]

Thanks for your efforts OMT.

Interesting that the fans see it so differently from the Dally M judge (Hodges).

Benji and Luke got points in the Dally Ms. I didn't vote for either, but after watching the replay, Brooks went better than I first thought.

 

[happy_tiger]

Appreciation for this mate …know how much time running comp is involved

 

[old_man_tiger]

Appreciation for this mate …know how much time running comp is involved

Pleasure guys, happy to do something for the forum since I spend so much time here.

Interesting that the fans see it so differently from the Dally M judge (Hodges).

Benji and Luke got points in the Dally Ms. I didn’t vote for either, but after watching the replay, Brooks went better than I first thought.

Prefer this method to the dallyMs because we actually recognise the value of the pack. Guys like Benji (who was ok by the way) attract so much more attention than guys like Aloiai and Twal.

Here's my first bold prediction. Probably my last. Farah will be leading the Dally M points at rd 6 and not leading the forum comp.

 

[Tim Sheens]

Thanks for your efforts OMT.

Interesting that the fans see it so differently from the Dally M judge (Hodges).

Benji and Luke got points in the Dally Ms. I didn’t vote for either, but after watching the replay, Brooks went better than I first thought.

Yeah, we all look at a game slightly differently. I gave Brooks my two points as well, with his defence being a big highlight of the game through my eyes.

 

[Kul]

Thanks for your efforts OMT.

Interesting that the fans see it so differently from the Dally M judge (Hodges).

Benji and Luke got points in the Dally Ms. I didn't vote for either, but after watching the replay, Brooks went better than I first thought.

I agree with this

Yeah, we all look at a game slightly differently.