3,2,1

tig_prmz

tig_prmz

Well-known member
3\. Fulton
2\. Sue
1\. Lawrence

felt like we went backwards for the first time this year. arm grabs for thompson and even woods killed us. woods and farah's worst game by far this year and tedesco.
changes will be made for the next game coz of the bye but i would've preferred if we went with the same 17 and gave them a chance to redeem themselves.

players weren't playing for their teammates out there.
attack = wow! more of that PLEEASEE
 
3 Fulton
2 Woods
1 Tedesco

Not sure what you mean by Woods and Tedesco having a bad game….
as you can see I thought they were among our best.
 
idk how people can say your FB had a good game when a prop sidesteps you and you cant do a 1on1 last line tackle on a 80 kg guy.

also, how could ur prop be the 2nd best out there when opposition props runs straigh through the hole with him at marker. woods and thompson were arm grabbing fifita and others all the time.
 
Farah probably had his worst half of footy in years in that first half, but he laid on two tries in the second half plus some good kicks and was a different player.

I think potter jinxed him a few days ago when he said he hasn't played a game where he was less than 9/10 all year :slight_smile:

He'll come back strong and be in our best 2 again in our next game as he almost always is.
 
3\. Fulton
2\. Woods
1\. Lawrence

Hon mention: Sue

Farah had a good second half but his first half was not good enough to yield any votes from me
 
I was there live and Tedesco was rubbish tonight. Sorry.

3\. Bodene Thompson
2\. Robbie Farah
1\. Stuart Mills (Sharks player, was SO BAD for them he was great for us)
 
@hybrid_tiger said:
Bodene Thompson was bog ordinary. Again.

Hard to pick a 3-2-1 because almost everyone was awful in the first half.
Click to expand...

Agreed, his try was a hero play that came off. Simona had no one near him, but he decided to throw a dummy and break through 3 tackles rather than give his team mate a clear run to the line.
 
A tough ask to name a 3-2-1- with such an inconsistent performance.

I guess Fulton gets 3 for being consistent. Sue could get himself 2 and 1 to Lawrence who looked pretty good.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
I only saw a team of amateurs played on Fridaynight, not the regular football team. It was nightmarish, please weak me up from my dream/nightmare. Can the West Tigers play that badly again?
 
Just watched the game this morning and thought we played well in reality Todd Carney was the difference and for us Benji not putting the penalty out
3\. Farah
2\. Lawrence
1\. Woods -150 m and 42 tackles deserves a point

Honourable mention to tedesco -cant see how anyone could criticise his performance especially as he is still clearly playing hurt, Fulton as always, and the 2 wingers continue to I press

My 3 worst points
3\. Murdoch masiala
2\. Marshall - he made 4 errors, carney made 4 try assists
1\. Thompson -scored a try but missed 4 tackles and was fairly ineffective otherwise
 
@Boonboon2 said:
Just watched the game this morning and thought we played well in reality Todd Carney was the difference and for us Benji not putting the penalty out
3\. Farah
2\. Lawrence
1\. Woods -150 m and 42 tackles deserves a point

Honourable mention to tedesco -cant see how anyone could criticise his performance especially as he is still clearly playing hurt, Fulton as always, and the 2 wingers continue to I press

My 3 worst points
3\. Murdoch masiala
2\. Marshall - he made 4 errors, carney made 4 try assists
1\. Thompson -scored a try but missed 4 tackles and was fairly ineffective otherwise
Click to expand...

Tedesco is so far away from being a first grade fullback it is not funny. He is a shocker.

Best players in no particular order were Lawrence, Farah, Nofo, Simona and Fulton.

Players who should not be there for the next game, in no particular order, Tedesco, Ayshford, BMM, Thompson and Buchanan.

Sironen is playing out of position and should be moved to the forwards but he is not living up to the high expectations placed upon him.

Blair was so, so. The less said about Marshall the better.
 
@Boonboon2 said:
Just watched the game this morning and thought we played well in reality Todd Carney was the difference and for us Benji not putting the penalty out
3\. Farah
2\. Lawrence
1\. Woods -150 m and 42 tackles deserves a point

Honourable mention to tedesco -cant see how anyone could criticise his performance especially as he is still clearly playing hurt, Fulton as always, and the 2 wingers continue to I press

My 3 worst points
3\. Murdoch masiala
2\. Marshall - he made 4 errors, carney made 4 try assists
1\. Thompson -scored a try but missed 4 tackles and was fairly ineffective otherwise
Click to expand...

If Tedesco is playing hurt he should not be playing. Simona and Nofoaluma are very capable fullbacks and Koro coming back can slot into one of the vacant wing spots.
 
Hard to give a 3,2,1 as the team was rubbish in the first half but came to life in the second half. Based on that, Woods went well, Farah picked his chin up and played well, Lawrence was solid, Simona was elusive and Nofoaluma was busy. Sue and Fulton went ok and I thought Tedesco was alright and took a couple of extremely difficult bombs.
 
Blair is starting to look like he has a role in the team. Last night, I saw him play a little like Kasiano, with his ball-playing ability on show. I think if he continues to develop in this direction, he could become a really good player.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 1,108 (members: 15, guests: 1,093)
Back
Top