3 Players In Doubt For Panthers Game

[Cultured_Bogan]

I think he means that the effect injuries have on our side is far worse because they are not direct positional replacements.

Yes, this is exactly what I meant.

Replacing Payten with Flanagan or Galloway with Flanagan makes the loss through injury even worse than it should be.

Besides, haven't we had enough of blaming injuries? Injuries are part and parcel of any football side, and IMO we haven't had it THAT bad this season. Look at Souths last week - they were missing more than half their forward pack and a few backs and still managed to beat us.

I think our worse injury toll has been 2006, and fair enough that year you could blame injury for alot of our performances. But this year, I don't think so. I thought this was the year of no excuses?

I agree there HT. I can't see how swapping an injured prop with a guy who is barely big enough to be considered a second rower is better than promoting a State Cup prop who is performing well. You don't just have the injury weakening the side, you've effectively changed the dynamic by having one less prop in the side.

Can't see what was wrong with your original statement. You posed a logical question without actually taking a shot at Sheens. Still, doesn't stop some from getting sooky and turning the post around so they can lay the slipper in…

 

[Spartan117]

Where is Junior Moors???

Was he in Kiama??

 

[851]

I think he means that the effect injuries have on our side is far worse because they are not direct positional replacements.

Spot on anyone with any idea would know what he meant.

 

[Yossarian]

I think he means that the effect injuries have on our side is far worse because they are not direct positional replacements.

Spot on anyone with any idea would know what he meant.

Yeah that's real helpful. God forbid someone would ask a question just to clarify things.

But thanks for your meaningful insight.

 

[Blake93]

whingeeeeeeee

 

[Yossarian]

And people wonder why some think the forum is going downhill…

Hope your study is going well.

 

[Blake93]

thanks it is, the forum is going because people like you constantly whinge and dont have anything constructive to say about the team, coaching staff or the general tigers community

 

[Yossarian]

thanks it is, the forum is going because people like you constantly whinge and dont have anything constructive to say about the team, coaching staff or the general tigers community

Actually if you bothered reading the posts before flying off with the insults you'd realise it was the opposite. My comment (you can call it a whinge) was about another poster suggesting I had no idea because I asked a question trying to clarify an earlier post.

By all means check my post record - I am not someone who comes on and complains about the team, the coach etc. This week I have been critical about aspects of what happened on Sat night (with some justification I think) but if you bothered to look into it you would see overall I just make a call on things as I see it without being overly negative.

The reason why some people leave the forum is people like you who just load up an insult where its not needed. I love the forum but I can see where people take a break from it. You complain about me whinging but you've made a couple of posts of absolutely zero constructive value in this thread alone.

 

[Blake93]

thanks it is, the forum is going because people like you constantly whinge and dont have anything constructive to say about the team, coaching staff or the general tigers community

Actually if you bothered reading the posts before flying off with the insults you'd realise it was the opposite. My comment (you can call it a whinge) was about another poster suggesting I had no idea because I asked a question trying to clarify an earlier post.

By all means check my post record - I am not someone who comes on and complains about the team, the coach etc. This week I have been critical about aspects of what happened on Sat night (with some justification I think) but if you bothered to look into it you would see overall I just make a call on things as I see it without being overly negative.

The reason why some people leave the forum is people like you who just load up an insult where its not needed. I love the forum but I can see where people take a break from it. You complain about me whinging but you've made a couple of posts of absolutely zero constructive value in this thread alone.

you do realise that entire post was a post "of absolutely zero constructive value". Shouldn't you be getting back to your job

 

[Yossarian]

thanks it is, the forum is going because people like you constantly whinge and dont have anything constructive to say about the team, coaching staff or the general tigers community

Actually if you bothered reading the posts before flying off with the insults you'd realise it was the opposite. My comment (you can call it a whinge) was about another poster suggesting I had no idea because I asked a question trying to clarify an earlier post.

By all means check my post record - I am not someone who comes on and complains about the team, the coach etc. This week I have been critical about aspects of what happened on Sat night (with some justification I think) but if you bothered to look into it you would see overall I just make a call on things as I see it without being overly negative.

The reason why some people leave the forum is people like you who just load up an insult where its not needed. I love the forum but I can see where people take a break from it. You complain about me whinging but you've made a couple of posts of absolutely zero constructive value in this thread alone.

you do realise that entire post was a post "of absolutely zero constructive value". Shouldn't you be getting back to your job

Oh touche! But is that a whinge?? :laughing:

You really don't see you may have been wrong in your initial post?

 

[system]

you do realise that entire post was a post "of absolutely zero constructive value". Shouldn't you be getting back to your job

I do hope, considering your first post in this thread today, that you specialise in irony

Anywho if you look here http://www.weststigersforum.com/forums/viewforum.php?f=17there is a debate going on about this very issue without the need to highjack this thread. Debate the issue that hybrid tiger has raised by all means but if you want to launch into a diatribe about the pros and cons of this forum and it's posters there is a topic in the linked subforum just for that

 

[Blake93]

hahaha thanks for that

 

[senexx]

So did we even cite Merritt?

 

[Bazzinator]

if worse comes to worse and all three are ruled out i would love to see

1\. Daniela
2\. Tuqiri
3\. Ayshford
4\. Ryan
5\. Brown

6\. Marshall
7\. Lui

8\. Gibbs
9\. Farah
10\. Payten
11\. Fulton
12\. Ellis
13\. Heighington

14\. Fifita
15\. Dwyer
16\. Moors
17\. Pritchard

 

[Long_Distance_Tiger]

Can you blokes/girls just stay on the topic and stop Sheens bashing. It's all speculation at this stage so why not make some positive posts instead of turning this into a private sparring match. Take it outside!!!

 

[Yossarian]

So did we even cite Merritt?

I'm not sure you can cite people any more. I think its all up to the match review committee or whatever they call themselves.

 

[stryker]

Our injuries are made worse due to the rubbish replacements Sheens picks for injured players.

I.e second rowers replacing props etc.

For example, I bet if Galloway is out, Flanagan will replace him.

wow, ur starting to join the elite group of people with NFI syndrome…

pull ur head in

Thats harsh T-Rexx…he brings up a very valid point here, if we lose a prop we should replace him with another prop. If we lose a half back we should promote one, not manufacture.

 

[T-REXX]

..

 

[magpie_mania]

our injuries are made worse due to the rubbish replacements sheens picks for injured players.

I.e second rowers replacing props etc.

For example, i bet if galloway is out, flanagan will replace him.

wow, ur starting to join the elite group of people with ni syndrome…

Pull ur head in

if you want flanagan to replace galloway id say your the mayor of the town "ni".

 

[T-REXX]

our injuries are made worse due to the rubbish replacements sheens picks for injured players.

I.e second rowers replacing props etc.

For example, i bet if galloway is out, flanagan will replace him.

wow, ur starting to join the elite group of people with ni syndrome…

Pull ur head in

if you want flanagan to replace galloway id say your the mayor of the town "ni".

please show me where i said that? im dieing to see it…